Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Proposed Sales Tax on Business Services Has Horrible Timing
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 6 years ago on
May 27, 2019

Share

California’s elected leaders are enjoying the fruits of a go-go economy, with record surpluses and record spending on education. So, naturally, there’s talk of tax increases.

Opinion

Loren Kaye
Special to CALmatters

Californians have enjoyed nearly 10 years of economic growth, and one of the biggest beneficiaries has been the state budget.

Since the depths of the recession the state budget has increased by 82%. That’s more than $95 billion. Compare that to the recession years when governor and legislators were forced to cut tens of billions of dollars in spending.

Healthy reserves and more spending on schools: what could go wrong?

Plenty. What goes up will inevitably crash down. Gov. Gavin Newsom earlier this month pointed to economic “headwinds.”

A Thinly Veiled Effort to Raise Taxes

California’s state budget is notoriously volatile. The top 1% of earners pays nearly half of all income taxes. These taxes provide 70% of all general fund revenues. The Newsom administration forecasts that a moderate recession could reduce state revenues by $70 billion over three years.

A handful of elected officials and deep thinkers believe the answer to this volatility is to impose a new state sales tax on services. They say we need to “modernize” our state tax code. That means adding a sales tax to services like auto repair, accounting, attorneys, architects, advertising. And that’s just the “A”s.

My organization, California Foundation for Commerce and Education, dug into this claim, and asked Encina Advisors, led by Justin Adams, a Stanford-trained economist, to determine its validity. We found:

  • A state sales tax on services would not meaningfully reduce budget volatility, no matter how you slice it. We looked at a variety of proposals that have been introduced in the Legislature in recent years and projected their impact on California’s budget revenue in future years.  None of the proposals would have meaningfully reduced budget volatility.
  • The primary driver of California’s budget volatility is the state’s reliance on the personal income tax. Unless lawmakers and voters commit to modifying the personal income tax rates, they’re not serious about addressing budget volatility.

We are inevitably led to conclude that, far from being an answer to budget volatility, a tax on services is merely a thinly-veiled effort to raise taxes and pull even more revenue into state government.

Finally, and most troubling, a sales tax on services would make California’s affordability crisis worse.

Talk of New Taxes Should Be Political Malpractice

We found that adding a sales tax on services would increase the costs to consumers and businesses of services they use every day from lawn care to lawyers, child care to morticians. Limiting the new sales tax to services purchased by businesses won’t shield consumers. Businesses will simply pass along those costs.

Worse, these added costs to businesses are baked into prices every time the product or service moves along the production chain, a dynamic called “pyramiding.”

We found that a 5% sales tax on business services would increase the cost of a typical new house by 3%, from $546,000 to more than $562,000. This comes from adding a tax to the contractors, attorneys, architects, real estate, mortgage financing and other services that go into the cost of a house.

The costs of building new schools or expanding or repairing infrastructure would be similarly boosted by a higher services tax.

With record budget surpluses, talk of new taxes should be political malpractice. Since a services tax doesn’t itself reduce budget volatility, dressing it up as a tax reform is like painting stripes on a donkey and calling it a zebra.

Loren Kaye is president of California Foundation for Commerce and Education, Loren.Kaye@CalChamber.com. He wrote this commentary for CALmatters, a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s Capitol works and why it matters.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

UP NEXT

Millions of Americans Like Trump Better in Theory Than in Practice

Inside Trump’s Extraordinary Turnaround on Immigration Raids

3 hours ago

Trump Approval Steady at 42%, Support Weakens for His Immigration Policy, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

4 hours ago

Madera County Wildfire Prompts Evacuation Warnings, Road Closures

A wildfire burning near Raymond Road and Avenue 16 in Madera County has prompted evacuation warnings and road closures, authorities said Mon...

2 hours ago

A wildfire near Raymond Road and Avenue 16 in Madera County has prompted evacuation warnings and road closures as officials urge residents to prepare to leave if threatened on Monday, June 16, 2025. (Madera County SO)
2 hours ago

Madera County Wildfire Prompts Evacuation Warnings, Road Closures

Sanger police are searching for Kaylani Thompson, 17, who went missing Saturday, June 14, 2025, after leaving her home and was last seen getting into a white sedan. (Sanger PD)
2 hours ago

Sanger Police Seek Public’s Help to Find Missing Teen

A view of the cityscape in the aftermath of Israeli strikes, in Tehran, Iran, June 16, 2025. Majid Asgaripour/WANA (West Asia News Agency) via REUTERS
2 hours ago

Trump Says Everyone Should Immediately Evacuate Tehran

3 hours ago

Inside Trump’s Extraordinary Turnaround on Immigration Raids

President Donald Trump speaks at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., June 12, 2025. (Reuters File)
4 hours ago

Trump Approval Steady at 42%, Support Weakens for His Immigration Policy, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

A person was rescued from a Fresno canal Monday, June 16, 2025, near Dakota and Ninth Street, marking the third such incident in recent days, officials said. (Fresno FD)
4 hours ago

Person Rescued from Fresno Canal, Third Incident in Recent Days

4 hours ago

Arias Dodges Questions About His False Fresno ICE Raid Claim

6 hours ago

Iranian State TV Halts Live Broadcast After Israeli Strike

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend