Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Both Abortion Factions Try to Silence Opponents
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
March 11, 2019

Share

Abortion is a divisive moral and political issue that generates ceaseless heated debate, as it should.

However, it also entices those who feel passionately about it, one way or the other, to use politics to shut down the other side.

Opinion

Dan Walters
CALmatters Commentary

The Democratic supporters of the 2015 “Reproductive Fact Act” tried to justify it as supporting women’s reproductive rights, but it was a very clear violation of constitutional free speech rights, as the U.S. Supreme Court declared last year.

We saw a prime example of that in the California Legislature’s self-righteous efforts to compel clinics offering non-abortion services to pregnant women to post notices telling them about the availability of abortions.

The Democratic supporters of the 2015 “Reproductive Fact Act” tried to justify it as supporting women’s reproductive rights, but it was a very clear violation of constitutional free speech rights, as the U.S. Supreme Court declared last year.

“By compelling petitioners to speak a particular message, it alters the content of (their) speech” and thus violates a previously enunciated judicial principle, the majority opinion declared. “For example, one of the state-sponsored services that the licensed notice requires petitioners to advertise is abortion – the very practice that petitioners are devoted to opposing.”

The 5-4 decision took a slap at the California-centered 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, known for its tilt to the liberal side of issues, for its willingness to abridge free speech.

Just as Guilty of Trying to Shut Down the Pro-Abortion Faction

“Although the licensed notice is content-based,” it continued, “the 9th Circuit did not apply strict scrutiny because it concluded that the notice regulates ‘professional speech.’ But this court has never recognized ‘professional speech’ as a separate category of speech subject to different rules. Speech is not unprotected merely because it is uttered by professionals.”

That’s also an important point, because clearly the legislators and then-Gov. Jerry Brown had painfully attempted to avoid the free speech issue in the legislation by portraying it as just a consumer protection measure.

While the Supreme Court’s ruling cheered those on the anti-abortion side of the debate, they are just as guilty of trying to shut down the pro-abortion faction.

The flip side of the unconstitutional California law is that 18 states require that women contemplating abortions be given counseling either about a purported, but unproven, link between abortion and breast cancer, the ability of the fetus to feel pain and/or long-term mental health consequences of abortion.

That attitude – that women should be manipulated – is also evident in new regulations promulgated by the Trump administration prohibiting clinics receiving federal family planning funds from offering abortions or referring women to abortion services.

An Attack on Women Everywhere

Last week, California Attorney General Xavier Becerra filed a lawsuit challenging the new rules.

“The Trump-Pence administration has doubled down on its attacks on women’s health. This illegal Title X rule denies patients access to critical healthcare services and prevents doctors from providing comprehensive and accurate information about medical care.” – California Attorney General Xavier Becerra

“The Trump-Pence administration has doubled down on its attacks on women’s health,”  Becerra said. “This illegal Title X rule denies patients access to critical healthcare services and prevents doctors from providing comprehensive and accurate information about medical care.”

Becerra’s Capitol news conference announcing the suit was joined by some 20 women lawmakers, as well as Gov. Gavin Newsom’s wife, Jennifer Siebel Newsom.

“This gag rule is an attack on women everywhere,” Siebel Newsom said.

Yes, it is a gag rule that abridges free speech, just as the California law did, although the rule may be on slightly firmer constitutional ground since it involves the expenditure of funds and wouldn’t affect clinics that don’t receive those funds.

Regardless, one either believes in free speech as a constitutional right or one doesn’t. And it’s important that the principle be upheld no matter how heated the debate or divisive the issue.

CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

[activecampaign form=19]

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

US to Give $30 Million to Gaza Aid Operation Despite Violence Concerns

DON'T MISS

US Senate Adjusting Rooftop Solar Language in Budget Bill, Senator Says

DON'T MISS

Early US Intel Assessment Suggests Strikes on Iran Did Not Destroy Nuclear Sites, CNN Reports

DON'T MISS

US Cities Face Record High Temperatures on Worst Day of Heat Wave

DON'T MISS

Yemen’s Houthis Likely to Be Persistent Problem for US, Senior Military Official Says

DON'T MISS

US Investor Strikes $1 Billion Merger to Create Bitcoin Treasury Company

DON'T MISS

Trump Casts Doubt on Mutual Defense as He Flies to Europe for NATO Summit

DON'T MISS

US Tests Radar That Could Link Into Golden Dome to Detect China, Russia Threats

DON'T MISS

Trump Pressures Congress on His ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ as Debate Clouds Path Forward

DON'T MISS

Fresno EOC Eyes 4 Finalists in CEO Search

UP NEXT

Trump’s Courageous and Correct Decision to Bomb Iran

UP NEXT

How the Attacks on Iran Are Part of a Much Bigger Global Struggle

UP NEXT

Groceries Are Now a Luxury. So Is Breathing.

UP NEXT

California Politicians Agree on School Money, but Poor Test Scores Need Attention

UP NEXT

Sen. Alex Padilla: This Is How an Administration Acts When It’s Afraid

UP NEXT

Bay Area Transit Systems Want More Money. But Their Payrolls Soared as Ridership Declined

UP NEXT

History Suggests the GOP Will Pay a Political Price for Its Immigration Tactics in California

UP NEXT

Only Nonviolence Will Beat Trump

UP NEXT

Gavin Newsom Finally Admits He’s Contemplating a Run for President

UP NEXT

Israel’s War of Choice With Iran Puts Trump in a Bind

US Cities Face Record High Temperatures on Worst Day of Heat Wave

1 hour ago

Yemen’s Houthis Likely to Be Persistent Problem for US, Senior Military Official Says

1 hour ago

US Investor Strikes $1 Billion Merger to Create Bitcoin Treasury Company

1 hour ago

Trump Casts Doubt on Mutual Defense as He Flies to Europe for NATO Summit

1 hour ago

US Tests Radar That Could Link Into Golden Dome to Detect China, Russia Threats

2 hours ago

Trump Pressures Congress on His ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ as Debate Clouds Path Forward

2 hours ago

Fresno EOC Eyes 4 Finalists in CEO Search

2 hours ago

Clovis Man Sentenced to 8 Years in Federal Prison in Deadly Fentanyl Case

3 hours ago

In New York Mayoral Primary, Progressive Upstart Aims to Spoil Cuomo’s Comeback Bid

3 hours ago

California Politicians Ignore Ag’s Troubles, but Boost Movie Business

3 hours ago

US to Give $30 Million to Gaza Aid Operation Despite Violence Concerns

WASHINGTON  – The United States is giving $30 million to a controversial humanitarian group delivering aid in war-torn Gaza despite co...

5 minutes ago

Boxes of aid are stacked as Gaza Humanitarian Foundation said it has commenced operations to begin distribution of aid, in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip, May 26, 2025. (Reuters File)
5 minutes ago

US to Give $30 Million to Gaza Aid Operation Despite Violence Concerns

U.S. Senator Kevin Cramer (R-ND) speaks during a television interview on Capitol Hill in Washington, U.S., March 31, 2022. (Reuters File)
49 minutes ago

US Senate Adjusting Rooftop Solar Language in Budget Bill, Senator Says

A satellite view shows an overview of Fordow underground complex, before the U.S. struck the underground nuclear facility, near Qom, Iran June 20, 2025. MAXAR TECHNOLOGIES/Handout via REUTERS/File Photo
55 minutes ago

Early US Intel Assessment Suggests Strikes on Iran Did Not Destroy Nuclear Sites, CNN Reports

A woman shades her self with an umbrella at the World War II Memorial, amid a dangerous heat wave afflicting the eastern half of the United States, in Washington, U.S., June 24, 2025. (Reuters/Evelyn Hockstein)
1 hour ago

US Cities Face Record High Temperatures on Worst Day of Heat Wave

U.S. Air Force Lieutenant General Alexus Grynkewich, nominated to be commander of United States European Command and Supreme Allied Commander Europe, testifies before a Senate Armed Services Committee confirmation hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C., U.S., June 24, 2025. REUTERS/Kevin Mohatt
1 hour ago

Yemen’s Houthis Likely to Be Persistent Problem for US, Senior Military Official Says

Representations of cryptocurrency Bitcoin are seen in this illustration taken November 25, 2024. (Reuters File)
1 hour ago

US Investor Strikes $1 Billion Merger to Create Bitcoin Treasury Company

President Donald Trump walks with Air Force Commander Colonel Angela Ochoa after stepping off Marine One to board Air Force One to depart for the NATO summit in The Hague, Netherlands, at Joint Base Andrews, Maryland, U.S., June 24, 2025. (Reuters/Brian Snyder)
1 hour ago

Trump Casts Doubt on Mutual Defense as He Flies to Europe for NATO Summit

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth speaks about the Golden Dome missile defense shield, in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 20, 2025. (Reuters File)
2 hours ago

US Tests Radar That Could Link Into Golden Dome to Detect China, Russia Threats

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend