Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Is a Cross OK on Public Land? Supreme Court Will Decide.
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 6 years ago on
February 27, 2019

Share

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court sounds as though it will allow a 40-foot cross-shaped war memorial to remain on public land in Maryland, but shy away from a sweeping ruling.
The justices are hearing arguments Wednesday in a closely watched case about the place of religious symbols in public life. The nearly 100-year-old cross was built in a Washington, D.C., suburb as a memorial to area residents who died in World War I.

Several conservative justices sounded skeptical of the broadest approach, advocated by the lawyer for the American Legion. The veterans’ organization raised money for the cross and completed it in 1925.
Some of the liberal justices suggested in their questioning of lawyers defending the cross that they could join a narrow ruling upholding its display, even though they talked about the cross as a major symbol of Christianity.
The bigger question might be whether there are enough votes to rule in a way that would allow governments to erect more religious symbols on public property.
Several conservative justices sounded skeptical of the broadest approach, advocated by the lawyer for the American Legion. The veterans’ organization raised money for the cross and completed it in 1925.
Those challenging the presence of the cross say that if the court allows it to stand on public land, the ruling could make it easier for government officials to defend support for religion. On the other side, supporters of the cross say a ruling against them could spell the “doom of hundreds of war memorials that use crosses to commemorate the fallen.”
The cross’s challengers include three area residents and the District of Columbia-based American Humanist Association, a group that includes atheists and agnostics. They argue that the cross’s location on public land violates the First Amendment’s establishment clause, which prohibits the government from favoring one religion over others. They say the cross should be moved to private property or modified into a nonreligious monument such as a slab or obelisk. The group lost the first round in court, but in 2017 an appeals court ruled the cross unconstitutional.

Officials Say That the Cross Doesn’t Violate the Constitution

In addition to the American Legion, Maryland officials who took over maintenance of the cross nearly 60 years ago to preserve it and address traffic safety concerns are arguing that it should be left where it is. Maryland officials say that the cross doesn’t violate the Constitution because it has a secular purpose and meaning.

The memorial’s supporters, including the Trump administration, would seem more likely to win based on the court’s decision to take the case and the court’s conservative makeup, seen as more likely to uphold such displays.
The memorial’s supporters, including the Trump administration, would seem more likely to win based on the court’s decision to take the case and the court’s conservative makeup, seen as more likely to uphold such displays. But observers will also be watching during arguments to see how broadly the justices seem inclined to rule.
The Supreme Court has been criticized for being less than clear in explaining how to analyze monuments so-called passive displays, like Maryland’s cross, that are challenged as violating the Constitution’s establishment clause. In 1971 the court announced a test for use in such cases, which asks whether the government’s action has a secular purpose, advances or inhibits religion or fosters “an excessive government entanglement with religion.” But in the decades since, the court hasn’t always followed that test, and several former and current justices have criticized it.
Monuments that are similar to Maryland’s cross, meanwhile, have met with a mixed fate at the high court. For example, on the same day in 2005 the court upheld a Ten Commandments monument on the grounds of the Texas state Capitol while striking down Ten Commandments displays in Kentucky courthouses. Justice Stephen Breyer, whose vote made the difference in the outcome in both cases, said the Texas display had a primarily nonreligious purpose while the history of the Kentucky courthouse displays demonstrated a government effort to promote religion.
A decision in the Maryland case is expected by the end of June.

DON'T MISS

Flores Homers, Matos and Wade Also Go Deep to Help Giants Cap Sweep of Astros

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Authorities Need Help Finding Family of Alejandro Solis

DON'T MISS

Lilly Is a Young Terrier Who Loves Dogs, Cats, and People

DON'T MISS

After Briefly Disappearing, TikTok Went Back to Normal. Or Did It?

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Head-On Crash Sends Two to the Hospital

DON'T MISS

Israeli Strikes on Gaza Overnight Leaves More Than 50 Palestinians Dead

DON'T MISS

Clovis Police Seek Three Suspects in Credit Card Fraud Case

DON'T MISS

Ohtani’s Walk-off Homer Boosts Dodgers to 8-0 With Another Comeback Win

DON'T MISS

Colorado Man Charged with Pointing Laser at Fresno Sheriff Helicopter

DON'T MISS

Hungary to Exit ICC as Netanyahu Visits Amid Arrest Warrant Dispute

UP NEXT

Trump Proposes Tax Deduction for Auto Loan Interest on US-Made Cars

UP NEXT

Western US Sees Sharp Increase in Extreme Weather Impact

UP NEXT

7-Year-Old Girl Was Killed by a Falling Boulder at a Lake Tahoe Ski Resort

UP NEXT

Elon Musk Reclaims Top Spot on Forbes’ Billionaires List

UP NEXT

Lakers Hold Off Rockets With 6 3-Pointers Apiece From Dorian Finney-Smith, Gabe Vincent

UP NEXT

Athletics Bat Boy Stewart Thalblum Takes Down Drone in Left Field

UP NEXT

NFL Postpones Tush Push Decision but Passes Other Rule Changes, AP Source Says

UP NEXT

March Madness: It’s South Carolina vs. Texas and UCLA vs. UConn in Women’s Final Four

UP NEXT

Major Layoffs Begin at Health Agencies That Track Disease and Regulate Food

UP NEXT

U.S. Bank Executive Terry Dolan Dies in Plane Crash Near Minneapolis

After Briefly Disappearing, TikTok Went Back to Normal. Or Did It?

14 minutes ago

Fresno County Head-On Crash Sends Two to the Hospital

28 minutes ago

Israeli Strikes on Gaza Overnight Leaves More Than 50 Palestinians Dead

38 minutes ago

Clovis Police Seek Three Suspects in Credit Card Fraud Case

45 minutes ago

Ohtani’s Walk-off Homer Boosts Dodgers to 8-0 With Another Comeback Win

51 minutes ago

Colorado Man Charged with Pointing Laser at Fresno Sheriff Helicopter

57 minutes ago

Hungary to Exit ICC as Netanyahu Visits Amid Arrest Warrant Dispute

1 hour ago

Rubio Visits NATO Amid European Alarm Over Trump’s Agenda

1 hour ago

Dow Drops 1,200 as US Stock Market Leads a Worldwide Sell-off Following Trump’s Tariff Shock

1 hour ago

Senate Rebukes Trump’s Tariffs as Some Republicans Vote to Halt Taxes on Canadian Imports

14 hours ago

Flores Homers, Matos and Wade Also Go Deep to Help Giants Cap Sweep of Astros

HOUSTON — Wilmer Flores homered again and Luis Matos and LaMonte Wade Jr. also went deep to lead the San Francisco Giants to a 6-3 win over ...

2 minutes ago

2 minutes ago

Flores Homers, Matos and Wade Also Go Deep to Help Giants Cap Sweep of Astros

The Fresno County Sheriff – Coroner’s Office is seeking public assistance in locating the family of Alejandro Solis, 67, who passed away on March 26, 2025, in order to release his body for a proper burial. Note: Photo shown is not current. (Fresno County SO)
3 minutes ago

Fresno County Authorities Need Help Finding Family of Alejandro Solis

Lilly the Terrier
9 minutes ago

Lilly Is a Young Terrier Who Loves Dogs, Cats, and People

14 minutes ago

After Briefly Disappearing, TikTok Went Back to Normal. Or Did It?

28 minutes ago

Fresno County Head-On Crash Sends Two to the Hospital

Yamama Jundia, 13, injured in an Israeli airstrike, grieves alongside others over the bodies of their relatives, who were killed in the same strike, at the Baptist Hospital in Gaza City on Thursday, April 3, 2025. (AP/Jehad Alshrafi)
38 minutes ago

Israeli Strikes on Gaza Overnight Leaves More Than 50 Palestinians Dead

Clovis police are seeking public help in identifying three suspects involved in a credit card fraud case after a stolen card was used at Best Buy and Target. (Clovis PD)
45 minutes ago

Clovis Police Seek Three Suspects in Credit Card Fraud Case

Los Angeles Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani hits a walk-off solo home run against as Atlanta Braves catcher Atlanta Braves' Chadwick Tromp looks on during the ninth inning of a baseball game Wednesday, April 2, 2025, in Los Angeles. (AP/Kevork Djansezian)
51 minutes ago

Ohtani’s Walk-off Homer Boosts Dodgers to 8-0 With Another Comeback Win

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend