Share
GREENBELT, Md. — A federal trial began Tuesday for lawsuits challenging the Trump administration’s addition of a citizenship question to the 2020 census, a plan that a different court blocked last week.
Former U.S. Census Bureau director John Thompson, the first plaintiffs’ witness for the bench trial in Maryland, testified Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross disregarded “long established” Census Bureau protocols in adding the citizenship question. Thompson, who oversaw the bureau from 2013 through June 2017, said he doesn’t think officials properly tested the question for the 2020 census.
“It’s very problematic for me,” Thompson said of Ross’ decision.
The trial before U.S. District Judge George Hazel in Greenbelt, Maryland, began one week after a federal judge in New York barred the Trump administration from adding a citizenship question to the census for the first time since 1950. The Justice Department is appealing that ruling by U.S. District Judge Jesse M. Furman, who concluded Ross acted in an “arbitrary and capricious” manner before deciding to add the citizenship question.
‘Racial Animus Against Non-White Immigrants’
A trial for a separate suit over the same issue, filed by the state of California, began in San Francisco on Jan. 7. A judge finished hearing testimony in that case on Jan. 14 and is scheduled to hear closing arguments Feb. 15.
In a court filing, plaintiffs’ attorneys say Ross communicated with former White House Chief Strategist Steve Bannon, former Attorney General Jeff Sessions and other administration officials before issuing the March 2018 directive “to further the unconstitutional goal of diluting the political power of non-white immigrant communities.” The Census Bureau’s own analysis shows the citizenship question would lead to a lower response rate to the 2020 census by households with at least one non-citizen member, the lawyer said.
“Consistent with numerous other statements and actions of President Trump and Trump Administration officials, these efforts were driven by racial animus against non-white immigrants,” they wrote.
The Census Bureau began collecting citizenship data through the annual American Community Survey in 2005. Ross decided to use the same wording from that “well-tested question” on the ACS for the citizenship question on the 2020 census, government lawyers said in a court filing.
The Clock Is Ticking for All of the Cases
“Secretary Ross carefully considered, but was ultimately unpersuaded by, concerns that including a citizenship question would reduce the self-response rate for non-citizens,” they wrote.
Denise Hulett, an attorney for the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, said the Los Angeles-based group’s lawsuit is the only one to allege that the citizenship question on the 2020 census is a “product of a conspiracy that began in the early days of the Trump administration.”
“It allows us to talk about the motives of a large group of people instead of the motives of just Secretary Ross,” she said during a break in the trial.
RELATED TOPICS:
The 49ers Add Florida Receiver Ricky Pearsall With the 30th Draft Pick
1 hour ago
Political Stunt, Egg on His Face, Personal Vendetta. Who’s Fresno DA Talking About?
2 hours ago
LA Judge Deals a Blow to Law Allowing Duplexes in Single-Family Tracts
4 hours ago
US Announces New Patriot Missiles for Ukraine as Part of New $6 Billion Aid Package
4 hours ago
Andy Reid and Taylor Swift Agree: Fresno’s Xavier Worthy Is a Great 1st-Round Draft Pick
5 hours ago
Egypt Sends Delegation to Israel, Its Latest Effort to Broker a Cease-Fire Between Israel and Hamas
6 hours ago
Jose Ramirez: ‘I Want to Make a Statement and Put on a Show’