Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Gene-Edited Baby Claim by Chinese Scientist Sparks Outrage
By admin
Published 6 years ago on
November 26, 2018

Share

HONG KONG — Scientists and bioethics experts reacted with shock, anger and alarm Monday to a Chinese researcher’s claim that he helped make the world’s first genetically edited babies.

He Jiankui of Southern University of Science and Technology of China said he altered the DNA of twin girls born earlier this month to try to help them resist possible future infection with the AIDS virus — a dubious goal, ethically and scientifically.

There is no independent confirmation of what He says he did, and it has not been published in a journal where other experts could review it. He revealed it Monday in Hong Kong where a gene editing conference is getting underway, and previously in exclusive interviews with The Associated Press.

Reaction to the claim was swift and harsh.

More than 100 scientists signed a petition calling for greater oversight on gene editing experiments.

University Will Hire Experts to Investigate

The university where He is based said it will hire experts to investigate, saying the work “seriously violated academic ethics and standards.”

“Regardless of where it was conducted, this work as described in press reports violates scientific conduct guidelines and is inconsistent with ethical norms of the scientific community and Rice University.” — Rice University statement

A spokesman for He said he has been on leave from teaching since early this year but remains on the faculty and has a lab at the university.

Authorities in Shenzhen, the city where He’s lab is situated, also launched an investigation.

And Rice University in the United States said it will investigate the involvement of physics professor Michael Deem. This sort of gene editing is banned in the U.S., though Deem said he worked with He on the project in China.

“Regardless of where it was conducted, this work as described in press reports violates scientific conduct guidelines and is inconsistent with ethical norms of the scientific community and Rice University,” the school said in a statement.

Rewriting the Code of Life

Gene editing is a way to rewrite DNA, the code of life, to try to supply a missing gene that is needed or disable one that is causing problems. It has only recently been tried in adults to treat serious diseases.

Editing eggs, sperm or embryos is different, because it makes permanent changes that can pass to future generations. Its risks are unknown, and leading scientists have called for a moratorium on its use except in lab studies until more is learned.

They include Feng Zhang and Jennifer Doudna, inventors of a powerful but simple new tool called CRISPR-cas9 that reportedly was used on the Chinese babies during fertility treatments when they were conceived.

“Not only do I see this as risky, but I am also deeply concerned about the lack of transparency” around the work, Zhang, a scientist at MIT’s Broad Institute, said in a statement. Medical advances need to be openly discussed with patients, doctors, scientists and society, he said.

Doudna, a scientist at the University of California, Berkeley and one of the Hong Kong conference organizers, said that He met with her Monday to tell her of his work, and that she and others plan to let him speak at the conference Wednesday as originally planned.

Hashing out Important Issues

“None of the reported work has gone through the peer review process,” and the conference is aimed at hashing out important issues such as whether and when gene editing is appropriate, she said.

“No matter how well intentioned, this intervention is dangerous, unethical, and represents a perilous new moment in human history. These children, and their children’s children, have had their futures irrevocably changed without consent, ethical review or meaningful deliberation.” — Notre Dame Law School professor O. Carter Snead

Doudna is paid by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute and Zhang receives grant support from the organization, which also supports AP’s Health & Science Department.

Another conference leader, Harvard Medical School dean Dr. George Daley, said he worries about other scientists trying this in the absence of regulations or a ban.

“I would be concerned if this initial report opened the floodgates to broader practice,” Daley said.

Notre Dame Law School professor O. Carter Snead, a former presidential adviser on bioethics, called the report “deeply troubling, if true.”

“No matter how well intentioned, this intervention is dangerous, unethical, and represents a perilous new moment in human history,” he wrote in an email. “These children, and their children’s children, have had their futures irrevocably changed without consent, ethical review or meaningful deliberation.”

Concerns Have Been Raised

Concerns have been raised about how He says he proceeded, and whether participants truly understood the potential risks and benefits before signing up to attempt pregnancy with edited embryos. He says he began the work in 2017, but he only gave notice of it earlier this month on a Chinese registry of clinical trials.

The secrecy concerns have been compounded by lack of proof for his claims. He has said the parents involved declined to be identified or interviewed, and he would not say where they live or where the work was done.

One independent expert even questioned whether the claim could be a hoax. Deem, the Rice scientist who says he took part in the work, called that ridiculous.

“Of course the work occurred,” Deem said. “I met the parents. I was there for the informed consent of the parents.”

DON'T MISS

Fresno Suspect Arrested for DUI, Firearm Possession at Olive and Blackstone

DON'T MISS

Smoke Shop Ordinance Eludes Divided Fresno City Council

DON'T MISS

Khalil Sues Columbia and Lawmakers to Keep Activists’ Names Secret

DON'T MISS

Judge Orders Musk and His Team to Turn Over Records and Answer Questions

DON'T MISS

Peach Pits? No Name for SE Fresno Sports Complex for Now

DON'T MISS

Johns Hopkins to Cut More Than 2,000 Workers Funded by Federal Aid

DON'T MISS

Starvation Is Not a Negotiating Tactic

DON'T MISS

Atmospheric River Soaks Fresno With 1.5 Inches of Rain and More Ahead

DON'T MISS

March Megastorm May Bring Blizzards, Tornadoes, Flooding and Even Fires Across Much of US

DON'T MISS

Democratic Rep. Raúl M. Grijalva Dies From Complications From Cancer Treatment

UP NEXT

Starvation Is Not a Negotiating Tactic

UP NEXT

Democratic Rep. Raúl M. Grijalva Dies From Complications From Cancer Treatment

UP NEXT

Tesla Owners Struggle with Brand Loyalty Amid Musk’s DOGE Controversies

UP NEXT

Kuwait Frees a Group of Jailed Americans, Including Contractors Held on Drug Charges

UP NEXT

Trump’s EPA Plans to Close All Environmental Justice Offices

UP NEXT

How and When to Watch Thursday Night’s Blood Moon Total Eclipse

UP NEXT

Anti-Zionist Synagogue Breaks From Mainstream Jewish Stance

UP NEXT

President Trump’s Many Golf Trips Are Costing Taxpayers Millions Per Outing

UP NEXT

Lake Superior Shipwreck From 1892 Finally Discovered

UP NEXT

US-Ukraine Deal Highlights Ukraine’s Wealth of Critical Minerals

Judge Orders Musk and His Team to Turn Over Records and Answer Questions

7 hours ago

Peach Pits? No Name for SE Fresno Sports Complex for Now

7 hours ago

Johns Hopkins to Cut More Than 2,000 Workers Funded by Federal Aid

7 hours ago

Starvation Is Not a Negotiating Tactic

7 hours ago

Atmospheric River Soaks Fresno With 1.5 Inches of Rain and More Ahead

8 hours ago

March Megastorm May Bring Blizzards, Tornadoes, Flooding and Even Fires Across Much of US

9 hours ago

Democratic Rep. Raúl M. Grijalva Dies From Complications From Cancer Treatment

9 hours ago

Country Star Clint Black Brings ‘Back on the Blacktop’ Tour to Chukchansi

9 hours ago

State Labor Board Hands Another Defeat to Clovis Unified

9 hours ago

Wired Wednesday: Chief Casto and Keeping Fresno Safe

10 hours ago

Fresno Suspect Arrested for DUI, Firearm Possession at Olive and Blackstone

A driver was arrested on multiple charges after allegedly brandishing a firearm and driving recklessly near Olive and Blackstone avenues, au...

7 hours ago

A driver with a prior felony conviction was arrested near Olive and Blackstone avenues for DUI and firearm possession after allegedly brandishing a gun and driving recklessly. (Fresno PD)
7 hours ago

Fresno Suspect Arrested for DUI, Firearm Possession at Olive and Blackstone

7 hours ago

Smoke Shop Ordinance Eludes Divided Fresno City Council

Demonstrators rally with the flag of Palestine outside the federal courthouse in lower Manhattan to protest the detention and potential deportation of Mahmoud Khalil in New York, Wednesday, March 12, 2025. Mahmoud, 30, a pro-Palestinian student activist at Columbia University, was detained by immigration agents at Columbia student housing, despite his status as a legal resident of the United States. (Juan Arredondo/The New York Times)
7 hours ago

Khalil Sues Columbia and Lawmakers to Keep Activists’ Names Secret

President Donald Trump walks with Elon Musk and his son X AE A-Xii, after looking at Tesla vehicles on the South Grounds of the White House in Washington, March 11, 2025. A federal judge in Washington ordered Musk and operatives involved with his Department of Government Efficiency to hand over an assortment of documents and written answers addressing its role in the government, a perch from which the unit has effected mass firings of federal workers and a dramatic dismantling of federal programs. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
7 hours ago

Judge Orders Musk and His Team to Turn Over Records and Answer Questions

7 hours ago

Peach Pits? No Name for SE Fresno Sports Complex for Now

The campus of Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Nov. 1, 2017. Johns Hopkins University, a leader in scientific research, has been hard hit by the Trump administration’s spending cuts, which will slash at least $800 million from its budget. (Andrew Mangum/The New York Times)
7 hours ago

Johns Hopkins to Cut More Than 2,000 Workers Funded by Federal Aid

Food is passed out to residents in Beit Lahia, north of the Gaza Strip on March 10, 2025. (Saher Alghorra/The New York Times)
7 hours ago

Starvation Is Not a Negotiating Tactic

8 hours ago

Atmospheric River Soaks Fresno With 1.5 Inches of Rain and More Ahead

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend