Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Another Conflict Brewing Over Work Disability Costs
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
October 30, 2018

Share

Gavin Newsom loves high-concept, almost edgy, approaches to governance – not unlike a younger Jerry Brown during his first governorship four decades ago.


Opinion
by Dan Walters
CALmatters Columnist

Five major interest groups constantly joust over the system’s costs and benefits, both cash and medical treatment – employers, insurers, unions, medical care and rehabilitation providers, and lawyers who handle disability claims.
However, as Brown eventually learned and Newsom will discover if, as expected, he follows Brown into the Capitol’s corner office, much of governing is not pro-active and creative, but rather reactive, mediating complex, high-dollar conflicts.
One of those perpetual conflicts, virtually a cottage industry, is certain to land on Newsom’s doorstep. It’s the $20-plus billion a year system of compensating workers for job-related injuries and illnesses, financed by employers through insurance policies or self-managed funds.
Five major interest groups constantly joust over the system’s costs and benefits, both cash and medical treatment – employers, insurers, unions, medical care and rehabilitation providers, and lawyers who handle disability claims.
The system’s recent history has been that about once a decade, several of the five form a semi-secret coalition for changes that benefit them and penalize the others. The coalition then prevails upon politicians to ratify their agreement, which is dubbed “reform.”

A Sneak Attack in the Final Days of His First Governorship

Brown was a party to one such sneak attack in the final days of his first governorship in 1982 that preyed upon employers, raising their costs by $3 billion a year. Exactly 30 years later, he presided over another.
In 2012, employers and unions, with insurers’ neutrality, agreed to raise cash payments to workers with “permanent partial” disabilities, the most expensive payouts, and offset the cost by squeezing medical care and eligibility for benefits.
The deal was opposed by medical groups and lawyers, but was pushed through the Capitol in the dying days of the 2012 legislative session and signed by Brown.
From an employer standpoint, it was a roaring success. At the time, it was supposed to raise benefits by $740 million a year and reduce costs by a like amount. However, the Workers Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau, which monitors the system, reported last year that the “reform” reduced annual employer costs by $1.3 billion, more than offsetting the cash benefit boost.
Nevertheless, those costs remain very high relative to payrolls, and fuel the perennial search for a new coalition – meaning that if elected, Newsom will also face the issue.
Oregon’s workers compensation system is the go-to oracle on how costs vary from state to state. Its latest national survey, released this month, found that California, which long had the nation’s highest costs as a percentage of payroll, had dropped to No. 2 behind New York.

$7 Billion a Year in Higher California Employer Costs

California’s current rate in the survey, 2.87 percent, is down from 3.24 percent in the 2016 survey, but still two-thirds higher than the national median of 1.7 percent. That differential translates into about $7 billion a year in higher California employer costs.

California’s current rate in the survey, 2.87 percent, is down from 3.24 percent in the 2016 survey, but still two-thirds higher than the national median of 1.7 percent. That differential translates into about $7 billion a year in higher California employer costs.
Obviously, working in California is not inherently more dangerous than in other states and employer groups, such as the Workers Compensation Action Network, partially attribute higher costs to fraud by greedy lawyers and doctors who recruit workers to file spurious claims, especially for “cumulative trauma,” disabilities supposedly caused by years of work, not a single incident.
Data from the Workers Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau show that Los Angeles is the epicenter of such claims and while some fraudsters have been prosecuted, authorities believe that the practice is still widespread in the region.
It’s likely, therefore, that the next round of workers compensation politicking will focus on battling fraud and using savings to increase benefits, with employers, insurers and unions perhaps forming another powerful coalition and Newsom forced to referee.
CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

DON'T MISS

5 Reasons Early Voting Is Overwhelmed With Falsehoods

DON'T MISS

Christian McCaffrey Returns to Practice for the 49ers From Achilles Tendon Injury

DON'T MISS

California Sues LA Suburb for Temporary Ban of Homeless Shelters

DON'T MISS

You May Have Blocked Someone on X but Now They Can See Your Public Posts Anyway

DON'T MISS

Some Republican-Led States Refuse to Let Justice Department Monitors Into Polling Places

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect in Fatal NW Apartment Shooting

DON'T MISS

Fresno Murder Suspect Stopped in Las Vegas, Others Wanted

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Crowds Are Dwindling as His Campaign Winds Down

DON'T MISS

Trump Threatens 25% Tariff on Mexico to Curb Immigration

DON'T MISS

Music Legend Quincy Jones, Architect of Pop’s Greatest Hits, Dies at 91

UP NEXT

Let’s Keep Innovative Partnerships Crucial to Combating Climate Change: Fresno Dairy Manager

UP NEXT

No Matter the Outcome, We Are the True Losers of This Election

UP NEXT

California’s Transition Off Carbon Fuels Could Be a Monumental Disaster

UP NEXT

Don’t Let Liberal Purity Elect Trump

UP NEXT

Newsom Provides Welfare to the Wealthy, Skimps on Anti-Homelessness Programs

UP NEXT

Independent Gen Zers Will Decide Elections From Now On

UP NEXT

America’s Political Divide Shifts from Economics to Education: Fareed Zakaria

UP NEXT

Fresno Unified Reform Is a Must. Force It With a ‘No’ on Measure H.

UP NEXT

Trump’s Biggest Con: Pretending to Support American Workers

UP NEXT

Why Newsom Wants Taxpayers to Waste Millions on Big Hollywood Subsidies

You May Have Blocked Someone on X but Now They Can See Your Public Posts Anyway

53 mins ago

Some Republican-Led States Refuse to Let Justice Department Monitors Into Polling Places

59 mins ago

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect in Fatal NW Apartment Shooting

2 hours ago

Fresno Murder Suspect Stopped in Las Vegas, Others Wanted

2 hours ago

Trump’s Crowds Are Dwindling as His Campaign Winds Down

2 hours ago

Trump Threatens 25% Tariff on Mexico to Curb Immigration

3 hours ago

Music Legend Quincy Jones, Architect of Pop’s Greatest Hits, Dies at 91

3 hours ago

Big Pharma Backs Harris 6-to-1 Over Trump in Presidential Campaign Contributions

3 hours ago

Sanger Men Arrested in Connection with Slingshot Vandalism Spree at Businesses

3 hours ago

What Is Sierra Unified’s Plan to Boost Lagging Student Achievement?

4 hours ago

5 Reasons Early Voting Is Overwhelmed With Falsehoods

This year’s early voting period appears to be far more polluted with election misinformation than those in previous presidential races, acco...

27 mins ago

Voters cast their ballots at Desert Breeze Community Center in Las Vegas during the last day of in-person early voting in Nevada on Friday, Nov. 1, 2024. Nearly 75 million people have cast early ballots, making their voices heard amid worry about the process, the outcome and democracy itself. (Bridget Bennett/The New York Times)
27 mins ago

5 Reasons Early Voting Is Overwhelmed With Falsehoods

35 mins ago

Christian McCaffrey Returns to Practice for the 49ers From Achilles Tendon Injury

40 mins ago

California Sues LA Suburb for Temporary Ban of Homeless Shelters

53 mins ago

You May Have Blocked Someone on X but Now They Can See Your Public Posts Anyway

59 mins ago

Some Republican-Led States Refuse to Let Justice Department Monitors Into Polling Places

Gerrick Franklin (pictured), 34, was taken into custody Sunday in Madera County on suspicion of killing Tyler Hamon, 33. (Fresno PD)
2 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect in Fatal NW Apartment Shooting

2 hours ago

Fresno Murder Suspect Stopped in Las Vegas, Others Wanted

Former President Donald Trump, the Republican presidential nominee, on stage during a campaign rally in Lititz, Pa., on Sunday, Nov. 3, 2024. Trump told supporters on Sunday that he “shouldn’t have left” the White House at the end of his term during an end-of-campaign rally where he vented angrily about a spate of new public polls showing him losing ground to Vice President Kamala Harris and joked about reporters being shot at. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
2 hours ago

Trump’s Crowds Are Dwindling as His Campaign Winds Down

Search

Send this to a friend