Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Commentary: Two Arcane Ballot Measures Show Need for Reform
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
October 11, 2018

Share

There’s a symbiotic relationship between two of the 11 statewide ballot measures facing voters next month, Propositions 8 and 11.
Both would have voters decide very narrow union-management conflicts in two relatively small medical service sectors — with sponsors of both claiming that passage would reduce health care costs. And both set a very dangerous precedent.


Opinion
by Dan Walters
CALmatters Columnist

Proposition 8, sponsored by unions, purports to limit profits in clinics that provide dialysis treatments to sufferers of kidney failure. The providers, of course, oppose the measure.
Proposition 11, sponsored by ambulance companies, would allow them to require ambulance crews to remain on call during meal and rest breaks. It draws opposition, not surprisingly, from unions.
Both are obviously important to the interests that support and oppose them. However, it’s foolish to expect November’s nine-plus million voters to make even semi-informed decisions about their provisions, much less understand how dialysis clinics and ambulance services operate, or should operate.

Petty Conflicts Don’t Belong on Ballot

The initiative process should be confined to matters of more widespread and fundamental importance to the welfare of 40 million people. We’ve had relatively petty conflicts in ballot measures before, but these two take it to another level.
They are there because any interest group with a few million bucks and an ax to grind can qualify a ballot measure, regardless of their merits. Placing measures on the 2018 ballot was especially easy because a record low voter turnout at the last gubernatorial election in 2014 lowered the threshold of required signatures on initiative petitions for this year’s election.
Turnout will be somewhat higher this year for a variety of reasons, so qualifying measures in the future will be a bit more difficult, or expensive. Nevertheless, Propositions 8 and 11 have now shown the way and voters can expect to see more similarly arcane proposals in years to come.
Gov. Jerry Brown rightfully vetoed a bill to ban initiative promoters from paying for signature-gathering by each name they collect. That’s not to say, however, that the initiative process couldn’t benefit from some judicious changes, such as raising the signature threshold.

Raising Required Petition Signatures Might Help

Currently, a statutory initiative must obtain signatures of registered voters equal to 5 percent of the total vote for governor in the previous election, or 8 percent if it’s a constitutional amendment.
For this year, that meant 365,880 valid names for a statutory initiative and 585,407 for a constitutional amendment. Those are pretty small numbers, given the state’s more than 19 million registered voters.
Raising the required percentages by half — perhaps 8 percent for statutes and 12 percent for constitutional amendments — might discourage the misuse of the system for issues that cannot be fairly and rationally decided by voters.
Toughening the signature requirements also is important because the Legislature – perhaps to its regret – recently decreed that sponsors of initiatives can pull them off the ballot even after they’ve qualified, giving them leverage to demand legislative “solutions” to their issues.
The genteel form of extortion allowed by the new rules happened for the first time this year and we’ll see more of it in the future. But if initiative sponsors want to game the newly revised system, they should face higher entry fees by being compelled to collect more signatures.
Perhaps we should have a two-tiered signature threshold, providing access to legislative leverage only to those who collect a much-higher number of signatures — pay to play, as it were.
CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

DON'T MISS

Hungarians Will Decide Whether Ukraine Can Join the European Union, Orbán Says

DON'T MISS

Wolfie the Handsome Pup Seeks Loving Home After Life in the Wild

DON'T MISS

National Park Service Restores Some Jobs of Those Fired, Will Hire 7,700 Seasonal Workers

DON'T MISS

Is That Legal? A Guide to Trump’s Big Moves So Far.

DON'T MISS

Hotels Are So Last Year – Why Everyone’s Sleeping in Castles, Caves and Cranes

DON'T MISS

With Trump’s Prostration to Putin, Expect a More Dangerous World

DON'T MISS

Trump Says He May Take Control of the US Postal Service. Here’s What to Know

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Halts Trump’s Bid to Fire Whistleblower Chief

DON'T MISS

ICE Official Reassigned Amid Frustrations Over Mass Deportation Effort

DON'T MISS

Pentagon Says It Will Cut 5,400 Probationary Workers Starting Next Week

UP NEXT

Should Fossil Fuel Companies Be Forced to Pay for Los Angeles Wildfire Losses?

UP NEXT

How California’s Wildfire Crisis Is Burning Through Your Wallet

UP NEXT

LA Wildfires Intensify Political Jousting Over Home Insurance Premiums

UP NEXT

Conflicting Studies Obscure Reality of California’s Fast Food Wage Battle

UP NEXT

Not Quite a Unified Theory of Trumpism, but Still an Alarming Pattern

UP NEXT

California’s Aging Population Will Test Whether Its Demography Is Destiny

UP NEXT

CA Schools Still Fall Behind Despite Big Increases in Spending

UP NEXT

Editorials of The Times: Now Is Not the Time to Tune Out

UP NEXT

Look Past Elon Musk’s Chaos. There’s Something More Sinister at Work.

UP NEXT

The Deadly Truth: Record Number of Journalists Killed in 2024

Is That Legal? A Guide to Trump’s Big Moves So Far.

3 hours ago

Hotels Are So Last Year – Why Everyone’s Sleeping in Castles, Caves and Cranes

3 hours ago

With Trump’s Prostration to Putin, Expect a More Dangerous World

3 hours ago

Trump Says He May Take Control of the US Postal Service. Here’s What to Know

16 hours ago

Supreme Court Halts Trump’s Bid to Fire Whistleblower Chief

16 hours ago

ICE Official Reassigned Amid Frustrations Over Mass Deportation Effort

17 hours ago

Pentagon Says It Will Cut 5,400 Probationary Workers Starting Next Week

18 hours ago

Federal Order to End DEI Policies Has Fresno Schools Scrambling for Answers

18 hours ago

Bannon Denies Nazi Salute Accusation at CPAC, Calls It ‘a Wave’

19 hours ago

Misty Her Calls for ‘Huge Mindset Shift’ at Fresno Unified as She Campaigns for Top Job

19 hours ago

Hungarians Will Decide Whether Ukraine Can Join the European Union, Orbán Says

KYIV, Ukraine — Hungary will be the one to decide whether Ukraine is able to achieve its hopes of joining the European Union in the future, ...

3 minutes ago

3 minutes ago

Hungarians Will Decide Whether Ukraine Can Join the European Union, Orbán Says

Wolfie, a 2-3-year-old Poodle-Labrador mix rescued from an open field, is now healthy, playful, and looking for a loving home. (Mell's Mutts)
47 minutes ago

Wolfie the Handsome Pup Seeks Loving Home After Life in the Wild

1 hour ago

National Park Service Restores Some Jobs of Those Fired, Will Hire 7,700 Seasonal Workers

3 hours ago

Is That Legal? A Guide to Trump’s Big Moves So Far.

3 hours ago

Hotels Are So Last Year – Why Everyone’s Sleeping in Castles, Caves and Cranes

AP picture of Vladimir Putin, left, and Donald Trump
3 hours ago

With Trump’s Prostration to Putin, Expect a More Dangerous World

16 hours ago

Trump Says He May Take Control of the US Postal Service. Here’s What to Know

16 hours ago

Supreme Court Halts Trump’s Bid to Fire Whistleblower Chief

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend