Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Police Lineups Are Flawed. Can They Be Fixed?
GV-Wire-1
By gvwire
Published 7 years ago on
May 10, 2018

Share

Police lineups are a staple element of crime shows on TV and in the movies. An eyewitness, behind one-way glass, pointing out a criminal suspect among a group of four or five decoys standing along a wall at police headquarters makes for a highly dramatic moment on the screen.
But experts say police lineups are often unreliable. In many cases, innocent people have been wrongly convicted based on the outcome of a lineup, allowing those who are guilty to walk free.

California Lawmakers Seek Changes

Two state lawmakers are now looking to change the way police lineups are conducted in an effort to improve their accuracy. They’ve proposed a bill requiring California police and sheriff’s departments to follow new, research-based lineup procedures that have been adopted by federal law enforcement agencies.

Previous efforts to require changes to lineup practices across California have failed. In 2007, Former Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger vetoed a measure passed by the legislature, saying the policies should be decided by local agencies.
“A fair and equitable justice system must have the strongest policies in place to ensure that we correctly identify people who commit crimes,” said state Sen. Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco), co-author of the bill. “Requiring evidence-based standards for eyewitness identifications will help keep innocent people out of jail while still allowing public safety officials to do their jobs.”

Wrongly Convicted and Sent to Prison

BBC News recently posted a compelling video profiling the experiences of Uriah Courtney and Rafael Madrigal. Both men were wrongly identified in police line-ups and sentenced to long prison sentences for crimes they did not commit. They were both eventually freed through DNA evidence. Courtney had served seven years in while Madrigal had served nine years behind bars.
Among the requirements of the proposed law, police agencies would have to use a practice known as “blind administration” for live or photographic lineups. That means the lineup must be conducted by officers who don’t know the identity of the suspect to avoid the possibility of influencing an eyewitness.
Officers must also video record the process and inform witnesses that a suspect might not be in the lineup.

Other States Lead the Way

According to The Los Angeles Times, at least 19 states have adopted similar procedures for eyewitness identification.
“In California, counties such as Alameda, San Francisco, Contra Costa and Santa Clara have implemented them. But no statewide standards exist, even as mistaken identity has helped lead to convictions in 15 out of 23 cases in which people were later cleared by DNA evidence, according to the National Registry of Exonerations,” the Times reports.
Previous efforts to require changes to lineup practices across California have failed. In 2007, Former Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger vetoed a measure passed by the legislature, saying the policies should be decided by local agencies.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

US Job Openings Fall in March; Layoffs Decline

DON'T MISS

Trump’s First 100 Days: America First President Is Overturning World Order

DON'T MISS

California Senator Will Make Historic Appearance at Fresno City College Commencement

DON'T MISS

Gaza Ceasefire Talks in Cairo Near ‘Significant Breakthrough,’ Two Security Sources Say

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Farmer Sentenced to Prison in $650,000 Crop Insurance Fraud Case

DON'T MISS

Where Were the Most Car Crashes in Clovis? Police Release List

DON'T MISS

Protesters to Rally in Brooklyn After Pro-Israel Crowd Assaults Woman

DON'T MISS

Selma Teen’s Death May Be Tied to Fentanyl, Police Say

DON'T MISS

Blast Kills at Least 26 People in Nigeria’s Northeast, Residents Say

DON'T MISS

5-Year-Old Girl and Parents Among Those Dead in Vehicle Ramming in Vancouver

UP NEXT

Where Were the Most Car Crashes in Clovis? Police Release List

UP NEXT

Protesters to Rally in Brooklyn After Pro-Israel Crowd Assaults Woman

UP NEXT

Selma Teen’s Death May Be Tied to Fentanyl, Police Say

UP NEXT

Visalia Police Captain Charged With Embezzlement, Theft

UP NEXT

Autopsy Confirms Gene Hackman Died From Heart Disease

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Ejected, Killed in High-Speed Wreck Following Pursuit

UP NEXT

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Naomi Kaylynn Acker

UP NEXT

California Faces Automaker Backlash Over 2035 Gas Car Ban

UP NEXT

Trump Says Putin May Not Want Peace and May Need to Be ‘Dealt With Differently’

UP NEXT

Only About Half of Republicans Say Trump Has Focused on the Right Priorities

Gaza Ceasefire Talks in Cairo Near ‘Significant Breakthrough,’ Two Security Sources Say

16 hours ago

Fresno County Farmer Sentenced to Prison in $650,000 Crop Insurance Fraud Case

16 hours ago

Where Were the Most Car Crashes in Clovis? Police Release List

16 hours ago

Protesters to Rally in Brooklyn After Pro-Israel Crowd Assaults Woman

16 hours ago

Selma Teen’s Death May Be Tied to Fentanyl, Police Say

17 hours ago

Blast Kills at Least 26 People in Nigeria’s Northeast, Residents Say

17 hours ago

5-Year-Old Girl and Parents Among Those Dead in Vehicle Ramming in Vancouver

17 hours ago

Feds Again Bump Up Water Allocation for Many Fresno County Farmers

17 hours ago

Levi Strauss Shareholders Vote Against Proposal to End Diversity Programs

17 hours ago

US and Mexico Have Reached Agreement on New World Screwworm, Ag Secretary Rollins Says

18 hours ago

US Job Openings Fall in March; Layoffs Decline

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. job openings dropped sharply in March, but a decline in layoffs suggested that the labor market remained o...

2 minutes ago

A sign advertising job openings is seen outside of a Starbucks in Manhattan, New York City, New York, U.S., May 26, 2021. (REUTERS/Andrew Kelly/File photo)
2 minutes ago

US Job Openings Fall in March; Layoffs Decline

President Donald Trump meets with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., February 28, 2025. (REUTERS/Brian Snyder/File Photo/File Photo)
3 minutes ago

Trump’s First 100 Days: America First President Is Overturning World Order

15 hours ago

California Senator Will Make Historic Appearance at Fresno City College Commencement

Palestinians gather at the site of an Israeli strike on a house, in Jabalia, in the northern Gaza Strip April 28, 2025. (REUTERS/Mahmoud Issa)
16 hours ago

Gaza Ceasefire Talks in Cairo Near ‘Significant Breakthrough,’ Two Security Sources Say

16 hours ago

Fresno County Farmer Sentenced to Prison in $650,000 Crop Insurance Fraud Case

16 hours ago

Where Were the Most Car Crashes in Clovis? Police Release List

Officers with the New York Police Department outside the Chabad Lubavitch World Headquarters in the Crown Heights neighborhood of Brooklyn, on Monday, April 28, 2025. The Police Department said it was preparing for new protests in Brooklyn on Monday after a woman was verbally and physically assaulted by hundreds of pro-Israel demonstrators there last week. (Victor J. Blue/The New York Times)
16 hours ago

Protesters to Rally in Brooklyn After Pro-Israel Crowd Assaults Woman

17 hours ago

Selma Teen’s Death May Be Tied to Fentanyl, Police Say

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend