Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Kavanaugh's Views of Presidential Power Drawing Questions
bill-new-mug-002
By Bill McEwen, News Director
Published 6 years ago on
July 11, 2018

Share

WASHINGTON — Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh’s past writings that a president should not be distracted by lawsuits and investigations could become a flashpoint in what’s already shaping up to be a contentious confirmation battle.
With special counsel Robert Mueller investigating whether President Donald Trump obstructed justice, questions about whether a chief executive can be subpoenaed or indicted could potentially reach the Supreme Court.
Though there’s no indication at this point that will happen, it’s sure to be a major topic of questioning at Kavanaugh’s confirmation hearing as the Senate weighs whether to confirm him to replace retiring Justice Anthony Kennedy.
Democrats opposing Kavanaugh are already weighing in, saying the past writings — particularly a legal article he wrote on the separation of powers in 2009 — suggest he would be inclined to side with Trump.
Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer said Tuesday that he “seems exactly like the kind of man President Trump would want on the Supreme Court if legal issues from the Mueller probe arise.”
A look at Kavanaugh’s past statements on presidential powers:

Investigations and Lawsuits Involving the President

Kavanaugh was a key player in the investigation that led to President Bill Clinton’s impeachment, but a decade later he wrote that the experience, coupled with his time working for President George W. Bush, had persuaded him that presidents should not have to face criminal investigations, including indictments, or civil lawsuits while they are in office. He said Congress should pass a law temporarily protecting presidents from such distractions in office.
Clinton, for example, “could have focused on Osama bin Laden without being distracted by the Paula Jones sexual harassment case and its criminal investigation offshoots,” Kavanaugh wrote in the 2009 Minnesota Law Review article.
If applied on the court somehow, those opinions could have a direct impact on Trump, who has also been dogged by allegations of sexual harassment.
In the Russia probe, it’s theoretically possible the court could have to weigh in on the question of whether a president is immune from criminal prosecution. The Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, which provides guidance to executive branch agencies, has said sitting presidents cannot be prosecuted while in office.

Subpoena For the President

In addition to indictment, another issue tied to the Mueller investigation that has not been fully resolved in the courts is whether a sitting president must respond to a subpoena from investigators.
In the 2009 article, Kavanaugh wrote that Congress should also exempt the president from questioning by criminal prosecutors or defense counsel.
“Even the lesser burdens of a criminal investigation — including preparing for questioning by criminal investigators — are time-consuming and distracting,” he wrote, adding that a president concerned about an ongoing criminal investigation “is almost inevitably going to do a worse job as president.”
Mueller hasn’t indicated that he will move to subpoena the president, though his team raised the prospect with Trump’s legal team in March and may do so if the president’s lawyers refuse to make Trump available for an interview.
Clinton was subpoenaed in 1998 during the independent counsel’s Whitewater investigation, though the subpoena was later withdrawn when Clinton agreed to voluntarily testify before the grand jury.
The Supreme Court has never definitively ruled on the question of whether a president can be forced to testify, though the justices in 1974 did rule that President Richard Nixon had to produce recordings and documents that had been subpoenaed.

Firing the Special Counsel

Trump has repeatedly criticized Mueller and the investigation on Twitter, raising concerns in Congress that he will move to fire the special counsel. The White House has asserted that Trump has the authority to fire Mueller, but only Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein has the power to fire him under current regulations. Rosenstein appointed Mueller in May 2017 after Trump fired FBI Director James Comey.
In a 1998 article in the Georgetown Law Journal, Kavanaugh wrote that Congress should give the president the ability to fire special counsels, an opinion that Democrats have highlighted in the hours since he was nominated Monday evening.
Kavanaugh’s reasoning, however, was not to protect presidents but to make them more accountable. He wrote that presidents can complain that independent counsels are politically motivated while implying they are powerless to do anything about it. Giving the president firing power would “force the president and his surrogates to put up or shut up.”
Noting Nixon’s resignation after firing Justice Department officials, Kavanaugh wrote that “history clearly demonstrates that the president will pay an enormous political price if he does not have a persuasive justification for dismissing a special counsel.”

Playing Politics

Harvard Law professor Noah Feldman, who specializes in constitutional studies, on Tuesday warned Democrats not to overstate or misinterpret Kavanaugh’s words. He argues that because Kavanaugh is suggesting Congress make new laws to exempt presidents from investigations or lawsuits, it’s not the same thing as saying the courts should step in. Feldman suggests that Kavanaugh could even be implying that a president can be indicted, since he believes there should be a law preventing it.
“It’s a mistake for Democrats to make this their main line of criticism,” Feldman said.
Democrats showed little sign of heeding that advice Tuesday.
Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J., said the Senate shouldn’t consider Kavanaugh’s nomination until the Mueller probe is finished.
“The president of the United States should not be beyond criminal investigations,” Booker said.
But South Dakota Sen. John Thune, the Senate’s No. 3 Republican, chalked the opposition up to “Democrat paranoia.”
“It’s part of their obsession with Russia, and the president,” Thune said, noting that Kavanaugh wrote the article proposing presidential exemptions from lawsuits and investigations when President Barack Obama was in office.

DON'T MISS

Savannah Bananas Dominate Social Media, Sell Out Stadiums Nationwide Including Fresno

DON'T MISS

Biden is Off on Details of His Uncle’s WWII Death as He Calls Trump Unfit to Lead the Military

DON'T MISS

Big Names in Rap, Christian Music, and Comedy Headline Must-See Weekend Entertainment

DON'T MISS

US and UK Issue New Sanctions on Iran in Response to Tehran’s Weekend Attack on Israel

DON'T MISS

Will State AG Rob Bonta Jump Into 2026 Race for CA Governor?

DON'T MISS

Biden Scores Endorsements from Kennedy Family, Looking to Shore Up Support Against Trump and RFK Jr.

DON'T MISS

CJ Abrams’ Leadoff Homer Lifts Nationals Over Dodgers 2-0

DON'T MISS

See the Fully Equipped House Homeless People Built on LA Freeway Strip

DON'T MISS

Juror Dismissed From Trump Hush Money Trial. Prosecutors Seek to Hold Former President in Contempt

DON'T MISS

Keaton Winn Throws Six Solid Innings as Giants Take Series From Marlins

UP NEXT

Juror Dismissed From Trump Hush Money Trial. Prosecutors Seek to Hold Former President in Contempt

UP NEXT

Biden Backs House’s Aid Package for Ukraine, Israel While Speaker Johnson Battles to Retain Position

UP NEXT

Senate Dismissed Two Articles of Impeachment, Ending Trial on Mayorkas

UP NEXT

Biden Pledges to Block Japanese Takeover of US Steel and Promises Tariffs on Chinese Steel

UP NEXT

Myanmar’s Ousted Leader Suu Kyi Moved From Prison to House Arrest Due to Heat, Military Says

UP NEXT

NPR Editor Suspended Over Claims of Network’s ‘Progressive Worldview’

UP NEXT

Senate Will Convene the Mayorkas Impeachment Trial as Democrats Plot a Quick Dismissal

UP NEXT

Bob Graham, Former US Senator and Governor of Florida, Passes Away at 87

UP NEXT

Coalition: CA Lawmakers Need to Roll Back Proposed ‘Utility Tax’

UP NEXT

Wall Street’s Mixed Trading Day

Bill McEwen,
News Director
Bill McEwen is news director and columnist for GV Wire. He joined GV Wire in August 2017 after 37 years at The Fresno Bee. With The Bee, he served as Opinion Editor, City Hall reporter, Metro columnist, sports columnist and sports editor through the years. His work has been frequently honored by the California Newspapers Publishers Association, including authoring first-place editorials in 2015 and 2016. Bill and his wife, Karen, are proud parents of two adult sons, and they have two grandsons. You can contact Bill at 559-492-4031 or at Send an Email

US and UK Issue New Sanctions on Iran in Response to Tehran’s Weekend Attack on Israel

2 hours ago

Will State AG Rob Bonta Jump Into 2026 Race for CA Governor?

2 hours ago

Biden Scores Endorsements from Kennedy Family, Looking to Shore Up Support Against Trump and RFK Jr.

2 hours ago

CJ Abrams’ Leadoff Homer Lifts Nationals Over Dodgers 2-0

Sports /

2 hours ago

See the Fully Equipped House Homeless People Built on LA Freeway Strip

3 hours ago

Juror Dismissed From Trump Hush Money Trial. Prosecutors Seek to Hold Former President in Contempt

3 hours ago

Keaton Winn Throws Six Solid Innings as Giants Take Series From Marlins

3 hours ago

Attorney Suing Fresno Grizzlies for $5 Million Is No Stranger to ‘Ladies Night’ Cases

4 hours ago

Hagrid Has a Bit of a Playful Side, but the Heart of a Giant. And He’s Ready for Adoption

Animals /

8 hours ago

Biden Backs House’s Aid Package for Ukraine, Israel While Speaker Johnson Battles to Retain Position

20 hours ago

Savannah Bananas Dominate Social Media, Sell Out Stadiums Nationwide Including Fresno

When it comes to social media and baseball, the Savannah Bananas have no peers. Not even the Los Angeles Dodgers, whose lineup includes inte...

52 mins ago

52 mins ago

Savannah Bananas Dominate Social Media, Sell Out Stadiums Nationwide Including Fresno

2 hours ago

Biden is Off on Details of His Uncle’s WWII Death as He Calls Trump Unfit to Lead the Military

2 hours ago

Big Names in Rap, Christian Music, and Comedy Headline Must-See Weekend Entertainment

2 hours ago

US and UK Issue New Sanctions on Iran in Response to Tehran’s Weekend Attack on Israel

2 hours ago

Will State AG Rob Bonta Jump Into 2026 Race for CA Governor?

2 hours ago

Biden Scores Endorsements from Kennedy Family, Looking to Shore Up Support Against Trump and RFK Jr.

Sports /
2 hours ago

CJ Abrams’ Leadoff Homer Lifts Nationals Over Dodgers 2-0

3 hours ago

See the Fully Equipped House Homeless People Built on LA Freeway Strip

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend