Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Should – and Could – Gavin Newsom Be Recalled?
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 3 years ago on
July 7, 2021

Share

Does Gavin Newsom deserve to be recalled three years into his first term as governor of California?

Now that the recall election has an official date, Sept. 14, the low-powered — or at least poorly financed — campaign to oust Newsom will face the governor’s lavishly funded defense. That includes billions of taxpayer dollars he’s doling out and highlighting in campaign ads to ingratiate himself with the voting public.

Dan Walters

Opinion

Newsom’s Governorship During Pandemic

Back to the main question. Does Newsom deserve to be fired? Yes and no.

Certainly he’s guilty of blatant hypocrisy, such as attending, unmasked, a lavish birthday dinner for a lobbyist after admonishing Californians to avoid gatherings and wear masks to battle COVID-19. Or commiserating on national television with parents of children forced to remain at home in “Zoom school” while his own children were attending a tony private school.

Certainly, too, his insistence on taking one-man control of the pandemic and his very erratic, terminally confusing, decrees about what Californians could and could not do are fodder for legitimate criticism. His unwillingness to confront powerful school unions as they resisted reopening the schools for well over a year is another blemish on his record.

Finally, the blatantly self-serving legislation to speed up the recall election symbolizes the arrogance that has marked Newsom’s governorship.

Recall May Be a Waste of Money, ‘Destined to Fail’

However, do these and other flaws, such as his unilateral ban on capital punishment after voters specifically refused to end it, warrant a recall election that will cost more than $200 million? Since Newsom would be seeking reelection anyway just a year later, it seems to waste money better spent on California’s many serious issues.

Moreover, the recall campaign seems destined to fail, given Newsom’s relatively strong position in polling of voters, which is why he and the Legislature changed the rules for an earlier election. They didn’t want to risk that unforeseen events might damage him were the election to be held in October or November.

If recall proponents — Republicans, mostly — were to have a fighting chance of success, they would need to coalesce behind one well-known, well-financed candidate to succeed Newsom, as demonstrated by California’s first and only gubernatorial recall, that of Gray Davis in 2003.

Davis, who was more unpopular than Newsom is now, probably would have survived the recall had movie star Arnold Schwarzenegger not offered himself as a replacement. There were 135 would-be replacements on the 2003 ballot and we’re likely to have nearly 100 this year, but none has anywhere close to Schwarzenegger’s drawing power.

A very weak Republican Party, a late-blooming sponsor of the recall, can’t even settle on one challenger and voters will be disinclined to vote for Newsom’s ouster if they don’t see a viable alternative.

Recall Dependent on Voter Turnout

All in all, Newsom enters the official campaign phase of the recall is a very strong position to win, perhaps even by a landslide. However, it’s not a sure thing because of the election’s unique dynamics.

One factor will be how many voters will actually cast ballots, since California’s special elections are notorious for their low turnouts.

While polling consistently indicates Newsom’s strong position, “elections are ultimately determined by the voters who actually cast their ballots,” as the Public Policy Institute of California notes in a recent analysis.

PPIC’s polling has found that “likely voters who wanted to remove Governor Newsom were much more interested in the recall than those who wanted to keep him in office. If the governor’s supporters remain less engaged in the upcoming election, then the recall could end up being closer than the polls to date have indicated.”

CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=31]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Partners with High Performance Academy for Free Youth Sports Camps

DON'T MISS

Israeli Airstrikes Kill 26, Including 10 in a Gaza Humanitarian Zone

DON'T MISS

Tesla’s Annual Car Sales Slip for First Time as EV Competition Grows

DON'T MISS

What New California Laws Are Now in Effect?

DON'T MISS

Alzillion Hamilton Returns to Fresno State, Again. Another DB Enters Transfer Portal

DON'T MISS

Richardson Plans 15 Mile Walk to Work on First Day at City Hall

DON'T MISS

Garoppolo to Make Debut for Rams in Place of Stafford Against Seahawks

DON'T MISS

Trump Falsely Links Deadly New Orleans Terror Attack to Migrants

DON'T MISS

Oregon Sees Title Hopes Dashed With Early KO by Ohio State

DON'T MISS

Ágnes Keleti, Holocaust Survivor and Oldest Living Olympic Medal Winner, Dies at 103

UP NEXT

A History Buff? Take This New Year’s Day Quiz

UP NEXT

Jimmy Carter Deserved Our Thanks and Respect, Not Our Sneers

UP NEXT

Why Mountain Meadows Should Be a Priority for New CA Climate Bond

UP NEXT

What Sacramento Still Doesn’t Get About UC Merced

UP NEXT

Israeli ‘Earthquake’ Missile Strikes in Syria Register on the Richter Scale

UP NEXT

Why Are So Many Christians So Cruel?

UP NEXT

Welding is a Way Back to School for California Kids Who Regularly Ditch Classes

UP NEXT

Religion Has Been in Decline. This Christmas Seems Different.

UP NEXT

Opinion: Does Jesus Want Christians to Be Environmentalists?

UP NEXT

New Decisions Boost California’s Zero-Emission Vehicle Mandate, but Major Hurdles Remain

What New California Laws Are Now in Effect?

2 hours ago

Alzillion Hamilton Returns to Fresno State, Again. Another DB Enters Transfer Portal

3 hours ago

Richardson Plans 15 Mile Walk to Work on First Day at City Hall

3 hours ago

Garoppolo to Make Debut for Rams in Place of Stafford Against Seahawks

4 hours ago

Trump Falsely Links Deadly New Orleans Terror Attack to Migrants

4 hours ago

Oregon Sees Title Hopes Dashed With Early KO by Ohio State

4 hours ago

Ágnes Keleti, Holocaust Survivor and Oldest Living Olympic Medal Winner, Dies at 103

4 hours ago

US Army Soldier Dies in Tesla Cybertruck Explosion Outside Trump’s Las Vegas Hotel

5 hours ago

Pro Bowl Rosters Include 9 Ravens, 7 Lions, 6 Vikings and Eagles, and No Patrick Mahomes

5 hours ago

Wallace & Gromit Return for a Full-Length Film With a Familiar Foe

5 hours ago

Fresno State Partners with High Performance Academy for Free Youth Sports Camps

Fresno State and High Performance Academy announced on Thursday they’re partnering together to host youth sports camps at Valley Child...

26 minutes ago

26 minutes ago

Fresno State Partners with High Performance Academy for Free Youth Sports Camps

33 minutes ago

Israeli Airstrikes Kill 26, Including 10 in a Gaza Humanitarian Zone

Photo of Telsa logo
1 hour ago

Tesla’s Annual Car Sales Slip for First Time as EV Competition Grows

CA Shoplifting Crackdown
2 hours ago

What New California Laws Are Now in Effect?

3 hours ago

Alzillion Hamilton Returns to Fresno State, Again. Another DB Enters Transfer Portal

3 hours ago

Richardson Plans 15 Mile Walk to Work on First Day at City Hall

4 hours ago

Garoppolo to Make Debut for Rams in Place of Stafford Against Seahawks

President-elect Donald Trump arrives to speak at a meeting of the House GOP conference, followed by Rep. Elise Stefanik, R-N.Y., Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2024, in Washington. (AP/Alex Brandon)
4 hours ago

Trump Falsely Links Deadly New Orleans Terror Attack to Migrants

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend