Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
The Best Way California Can Prepare for Trump? Fix Its State Government
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 4 hours ago on
November 26, 2024

California urged to focus on effective governance rather than defensive "Trump-proofing" to address long-term challenges. (CalMatters/Larry Valenzuela)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

For a great many Americans, the November election results elicited an intense reaction. These responses, played out in real time on election newscasts and social media timelines, included everyday working people, media celebrities, television and movie stars, and even past and present politicians, including our own Gov. Gavin Newsom, who very quickly announced his plans to “Trump-proof” the state through all necessary legal and legislative means.

Author's Profile Picture
Bob Stonebrook

Special to CalMatters

Opinion

His plan would theoretically aim to shield California’s progressive policies from any federal manipulation by bolstering resources for the Attorney General’s office and other state agencies in preparation for long, drawn-out legal battles with the Trump administration. The problem is, this is an exclusively defensive approach to solving a grassroots problem that will outlast Trump’s second term.

A Proactive Approach to Governance

A far better and proactive approach — and one that would significantly increase the benefit to all Californians over the long haul — is to improve the effectiveness of our state government.

The results of this year’s elections have spoken volumes about what we have become as a nation and what is most important to our citizens.

Most Americans wake up before the sun rises every morning, toss back a cup of coffee and bust their tails for the next 45 years. They work tirelessly for their families, and they want to be treated fairly and objectively. They want to feel safe and accumulate a small measure of economic security for their children.

Basic governance creates the space for attaining those modest aspirations.

Overcoming Disenchantment Through Results

In 1969, Peter Drucker, the influential management consultant, author and educator, noted in the now-defunct Public Interest journal that the greatest factor in our “disenchantment” with government is that government has not performed.

California’s government is not achieving results, and our disenchantment manifested in the vote to overwhelmingly adopt Proposition 36, for example, which reclassifies some misdemeanor theft and drug crimes as felonies.

His remedy holds just as true today. Improvement in government requires “…the clear definition of the results a policy is expected to produce, and the ruthless examination of results against these expectations. This, in turn, demands that we spell out in considerable detail what results are expected rather than content ourselves with promises and manifestos.”

Overcoming disenchantment requires achieving results.

California’s government is not achieving results, and our disenchantment manifested in the vote to overwhelmingly adopt Proposition 36, for example, which reclassifies some misdemeanor theft and drug crimes as felonies. Public safety is a basic government function that is foundational to a thriving state.

And there are other basics that need attention: Fostering a thriving economy calls for addressing systemic challenges with balanced policies. Attracting businesses and promoting economic growth through supportive measures — rather than imposing burdensome regulations and legal obstacles — can prevent the exodus of businesses, preserve access to critical goods and services, and sustain entry-level job opportunities.

This approach offers a far less antagonistic pathway to reduce unemployment and bring California in line with national economic benchmarks.

And nothing requires a more “ruthless examination of results” than our state’s approach to its homeless population. California must finally put someone in charge of homelessness response to bring alignment and focus on achieving results that get and keep people off the streets.

Similarly, establishing systems to properly care for those with mental health and substance abuse issues, and creating programs to assimilate legal immigrants into our communities, would offer individuals a path towards a better life and provide a measure of hope for a brighter future.

These are building blocks that would help Californians trust that our political leaders have our best interests at heart. By recommitting to these governing basics, our state can set the stage to achieve much grander goals on clean air and climate. Each new measure builds a layer of protection against potential federal policy shifts and ensures that California’s underlying values and laws remain intact.

Government effectiveness means more than instituting barriers of prevention — it means setting clear goals and objectives that will achieve results for constituents and stamp our state as a model of proactive leadership for years to come.

About the Author

Bob Stonebrook is a small business owner based in Carlsbad.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to bmcewen@gvwire.com for consideration.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

‘Best Opening’ in a Decade: China Peak’s Ski Slopes Ready for Friday

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Resident Killed by Rabies Infection After Suspected Bat Bite in Merced County

DON'T MISS

Traffic Citations Against Dolphins’ Tyreek Hill Dismissed After Officers No-Show at Hearing

DON'T MISS

Biden Administration to Loan $6.6B to EV Maker Rivian to Build Georgia Factory

DON'T MISS

Israel Approves Proposed Ceasefire With Lebanon’s Hezbollah

DON'T MISS

Making Spirits Brighter: 31 Years of Community Supporting Children and Families

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Stole From His Company for Years. Now He’s Going to Prison.

DON'T MISS

Making ‘Queer’ Required Openness and Daniel Craig Was Ready

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Dairyman Responds to Raw Milk Recall After Avian Flu Detected

DON'T MISS

CBS News’ Costa Loves Fresno State and Valley Politics. He’s Coming Back.

UP NEXT

Fresno County Resident Killed by Rabies Infection After Suspected Bat Bite in Merced County

UP NEXT

Traffic Citations Against Dolphins’ Tyreek Hill Dismissed After Officers No-Show at Hearing

UP NEXT

Biden Administration to Loan $6.6B to EV Maker Rivian to Build Georgia Factory

UP NEXT

Israel Approves Proposed Ceasefire With Lebanon’s Hezbollah

UP NEXT

Making Spirits Brighter: 31 Years of Community Supporting Children and Families

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Stole From His Company for Years. Now He’s Going to Prison.

UP NEXT

Making ‘Queer’ Required Openness and Daniel Craig Was Ready

UP NEXT

Fresno County Dairyman Responds to Raw Milk Recall After Avian Flu Detected

UP NEXT

CBS News’ Costa Loves Fresno State and Valley Politics. He’s Coming Back.

UP NEXT

Kingsburg Firefighters Injured in Highway 99 Rollover Crash

Biden Administration to Loan $6.6B to EV Maker Rivian to Build Georgia Factory

48 minutes ago

Israel Approves Proposed Ceasefire With Lebanon’s Hezbollah

1 hour ago

Making Spirits Brighter: 31 Years of Community Supporting Children and Families

2 hours ago

Fresno Man Stole From His Company for Years. Now He’s Going to Prison.

2 hours ago

Making ‘Queer’ Required Openness and Daniel Craig Was Ready

3 hours ago

Fresno County Dairyman Responds to Raw Milk Recall After Avian Flu Detected

3 hours ago

CBS News’ Costa Loves Fresno State and Valley Politics. He’s Coming Back.

3 hours ago

Kingsburg Firefighters Injured in Highway 99 Rollover Crash

4 hours ago

Netanyahu Says He Supports Ceasefire Proposal With Lebanon’s Hezbollah

4 hours ago

Fresno Driver in Custody After Crash at Herndon and Fruit in Suspected DUI

4 hours ago

‘Best Opening’ in a Decade: China Peak’s Ski Slopes Ready for Friday

China Peak will open for the season on Friday, following a storm that dropped plenty of fresh snow on the runs, ownership says. Saying it wi...

10 minutes ago

10 minutes ago

‘Best Opening’ in a Decade: China Peak’s Ski Slopes Ready for Friday

27 minutes ago

Fresno County Resident Killed by Rabies Infection After Suspected Bat Bite in Merced County

46 minutes ago

Traffic Citations Against Dolphins’ Tyreek Hill Dismissed After Officers No-Show at Hearing

48 minutes ago

Biden Administration to Loan $6.6B to EV Maker Rivian to Build Georgia Factory

Smoke rises after an Israeli airstrike on Dahiyeh, in the southern suburb of Beirut, Lebanon, Monday, Nov. 25, 2024. (AP/Bilal Hussein)
1 hour ago

Israel Approves Proposed Ceasefire With Lebanon’s Hezbollah

2 hours ago

Making Spirits Brighter: 31 Years of Community Supporting Children and Families

Gabriel Ruiz De Chavez, 47, of Fresno, was sentenced to federal prison for embezzling over $1.5 million from his employer through a scheme involving fake invoices over nearly a decade. (Shutterstock)
2 hours ago

Fresno Man Stole From His Company for Years. Now He’s Going to Prison.

3 hours ago

Making ‘Queer’ Required Openness and Daniel Craig Was Ready

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend