Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Google Loses Massive Antitrust Case Over Its Search Dominance
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 months ago on
August 5, 2024

In this Nov. 5, 2018 file photo, a woman walks past the logo for Google at the China International Import Expo in Shanghai. Google is dropping plans to eliminate cookies from its Chrome web browser, making a sudden U-turn on four years of work to phase out the technology that tracks users for ad purposes. (AP/Ng Han Guan, File)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

WASHINGTON — A judge on Monday ruled that Google’s ubiquitous search engine has been illegally exploiting its dominance to squash competition and stifle innovation in a seismic decision that could shake up the internet and hobble one of the world’s best-known companies.

The highly anticipated decision issued by U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta comes nearly a year after the start of a trial pitting the U.S. Justice Department against Google in the country’s biggest antitrust showdown in a quarter century.

After reviewing reams of evidence that included testimony from top executives at Google, Microsoft and Apple during last year’s 10-week trial, Mehta issued his potentially market-shifting decision three months after the two sides presented their closing arguments in early May.

It represents a major setback for Google and its parent, Alphabet Inc., which had steadfastly argued that its popularity stemmed from consumers’ overwhelming desire to use a search engine so good at what it does that it has become synonymous with looking things up online. Google’s search engine currently processes an estimated 8.5 billion queries per day worldwide, nearly doubling its daily volume from 12 years ago, according to a recent study released by the investment firm BOND.

Google Almost Certainly Will Appeal

Google almost certainly will appeal the decision in a process that ultimately may land in the U..S. Supreme Court.

For now, the decision vindicates antitrust regulators at the Justice Department, which filed its lawsuit nearly four years ago while Donald Trump was still president, and has been escalating it efforts to rein in Big Tech’s power during President Joe Biden’s administration.

The case depicted Google as a technological bully that methodically has thwarted competition to protect a search engine that has become the centerpiece of a digital advertising machine that generated nearly $240 billion in revenue last year. Justice Department lawyers argued that Google’s monopoly enabled it to charge advertisers artificially high prices while also enjoying the luxury of having to invest more time and money into improving the quality of its search engine — a lax approach that hurt consumers.

Google ridiculed those allegations, noting that consumers have historically changed search engines when they become disillusioned with the results they were getting. For instance, Yahoo — now a minor player on the internet — was the most popular search engine during the 1990s before Google came along.

Mehta’s conclusion that Google has been running an illegal monopoly sets up another legal phase to determine what sorts of changes or penalties should be imposed to reverse the damage done and restore a more competitive landscape.

Outcome Could Have Google Dismantle Some Pillars

The potential outcome could result in a wide-ranging order requiring Google to dismantle some of the pillars of its internet empire or prevent it from shelling out more than $20 billion annually to ensure its search engine automatically answers queries on the iPhone and other internet-connected devices. After the next phase, the judge could conclude only modest changes are required to level the playing field.

If there is a significant shakeup, it could turn out to be a coup for Microsoft, whose own power was undermined during the late 1990s when the Justice Department targeted the software maker in an antitrust lawsuit accusing it of abusing the dominance of its Windows operating system on personal computers to lock out competition.

That Microsoft case mirrored the one brought against Google in several ways and now the result could also echo similarly. Just as Microsoft’s bruising antitrust battle created distractions and obstacles that opened up more opportunities for Google after its 1998 inception, the decision against Google could be a boon for Microsoft, which already has a market value of more than $3 trillion. At one time, Alphabet was worth more than Microsoft, but now trails its rival with a market value of about $2 trillion.

Besides boosting Microsoft’s Bing search engine, the outcome could hurt Google at a critical pivot point that is tilting technology in the age of artificial intelligence. Both Microsoft and Google are among the early leaders in AI in a battle that now could be affected by Mehta’s market-rattling decision.

Microsoft CEO Was a Star Witness

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella was one of the Justice Department’s star witnesses during the testimony that covered his frustration with Google deals with the likes of Apple that made it nearly impossible for the Bing search engine to make any headway, even as Microsoft poured more than $100 billion in improvements since 2009.

“You get up in the morning, you brush your teeth and you search on Google,” Nadella said at one point in his testimony. “Everybody talks about the open web, but there is really the Google web.”

Nadella also expressed fear that it might take an antitrust crackdown to ensure the situation didn’t get worse as AI becomes a bigger force in search.

“Despite my enthusiasm that there is a new angle with A.I., I worry a lot that this vicious cycle that I’m trapped in could get even more vicious,” Nadella said on the stand.

Google still faces other legal threats besides this one, both in the U.S. and abroad. any antitrust lawsuits brought against Google domestically and abroad. In September, a federal trial is scheduled to begin in Virginia over the Justice Department’s allegations that Google’s advertising technology constitutes an illegal monopoly.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

SEC Sues Elon Musk, Saying He Didn’t Disclose Twitter Ownership on Time Before Buying It

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Man Faces Murder Charges in Crash That Killed Four

DON'T MISS

An Important Reservoir Was Offline When California Fires Began

DON'T MISS

Freshman Congressman Adam Gray Lands on Ag, Natural Resources Committees

DON'T MISS

Biden Moves to Lift State Sponsor of Terrorism Designation for Cuba, Part of Deal to Free Prisoners

DON'T MISS

Capital One Sued by US Watchdog Alleging Bank Cheated Customers Out of $2 Billion

DON'T MISS

Millions Under Extreme Fire Weather Alert as Strong Winds Lash Southern California

DON'T MISS

How the CIA Director Helps the US Navigate a World of Spies, Threats and Geopolitical Turbulence

DON'T MISS

Gov. Newsom, Mayor Bass Targeted in Wildfire Witch Hunt

DON'T MISS

Clovis Police Officer Injured While Responding to Suspected DUI Call

UP NEXT

Fresno County Man Faces Murder Charges in Crash That Killed Four

UP NEXT

An Important Reservoir Was Offline When California Fires Began

UP NEXT

Biden Moves to Lift State Sponsor of Terrorism Designation for Cuba, Part of Deal to Free Prisoners

UP NEXT

Capital One Sued by US Watchdog Alleging Bank Cheated Customers Out of $2 Billion

UP NEXT

Millions Under Extreme Fire Weather Alert as Strong Winds Lash Southern California

UP NEXT

How the CIA Director Helps the US Navigate a World of Spies, Threats and Geopolitical Turbulence

UP NEXT

Gov. Newsom, Mayor Bass Targeted in Wildfire Witch Hunt

UP NEXT

Clovis Police Officer Injured While Responding to Suspected DUI Call

UP NEXT

A Possible TikTok Ban Is Just Days Away. A List of Other Apps Available

UP NEXT

Karen Bass Faces Growing Backlash Over Handling of LA Fires. Will She Resign?

Freshman Congressman Adam Gray Lands on Ag, Natural Resources Committees

14 hours ago

Biden Moves to Lift State Sponsor of Terrorism Designation for Cuba, Part of Deal to Free Prisoners

14 hours ago

Capital One Sued by US Watchdog Alleging Bank Cheated Customers Out of $2 Billion

14 hours ago

Millions Under Extreme Fire Weather Alert as Strong Winds Lash Southern California

14 hours ago

How the CIA Director Helps the US Navigate a World of Spies, Threats and Geopolitical Turbulence

15 hours ago

Gov. Newsom, Mayor Bass Targeted in Wildfire Witch Hunt

15 hours ago

Clovis Police Officer Injured While Responding to Suspected DUI Call

15 hours ago

A Possible TikTok Ban Is Just Days Away. A List of Other Apps Available

16 hours ago

Karen Bass Faces Growing Backlash Over Handling of LA Fires. Will She Resign?

17 hours ago

Before Taking Office, LA’s Mayor Said She Would Not Go Abroad

17 hours ago

SEC Sues Elon Musk, Saying He Didn’t Disclose Twitter Ownership on Time Before Buying It

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has sued billionaire Elon Musk, saying he failed to disclose his ownership of Twitter stock in a...

11 hours ago

11 hours ago

SEC Sues Elon Musk, Saying He Didn’t Disclose Twitter Ownership on Time Before Buying It

11 hours ago

Fresno County Man Faces Murder Charges in Crash That Killed Four

The smoldering wreckage of beachfront structures destroyed by the Palisade Fire in Malibu, Calif., on Thursday, Jan. 9, 2025. The threat of more fires propelled by blistering Santa Ana winds hung over southern California on Friday as firefighters battled to contain the raging blazes that have killed at least 10 people and destroyed thousands of structures. (Loren Elliott/The New York Times)
13 hours ago

An Important Reservoir Was Offline When California Fires Began

14 hours ago

Freshman Congressman Adam Gray Lands on Ag, Natural Resources Committees

14 hours ago

Biden Moves to Lift State Sponsor of Terrorism Designation for Cuba, Part of Deal to Free Prisoners

14 hours ago

Capital One Sued by US Watchdog Alleging Bank Cheated Customers Out of $2 Billion

14 hours ago

Millions Under Extreme Fire Weather Alert as Strong Winds Lash Southern California

15 hours ago

How the CIA Director Helps the US Navigate a World of Spies, Threats and Geopolitical Turbulence

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend