Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
The Supreme Court Rules for Biden Administration in a Social Media Dispute with Conservative States
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 7 months ago on
June 26, 2024

In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court backed the Biden administration in a pivotal social media legal battle. (AP/Jose Luis Magana)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Wednesday sided with the Biden administration in a dispute with Republican-led states over how far the federal government can go to combat controversial social media posts on topics including COVID-19 and election security.

By a 6-3 vote, the justices threw out lower-court rulings that favored Louisiana, Missouri and other parties in their claims that officials in the Democratic administration leaned on the social media platforms to unconstitutionally squelch conservative points of view.

Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s Stand

Justice Amy Coney Barrett wrote for the court that the states and other parties did not have the legal right, or standing, to sue. Justices Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas dissented. The decision should not affect typical social media users or their posts.

The case is among several before the court this term that affect social media companies in the context of free speech. In February, the court heard arguments over Republican-passed laws in Florida and Texas that prohibit large social media companies from taking down posts because of the views they express. In March, the court laid out standards for when public officials can block their social media followers.

Complaints of Censoring Conservative Viewpoints

The cases over state laws and the one that was decided Wednesday are variations on the same theme, complaints that the platforms are censoring conservative viewpoints.

The states had argued that White House communications staffers, the surgeon general, the FBI and the U.S. cybersecurity agency are among those who applied “unrelenting pressure” to coerce changes in online content on social media platforms.

The justices appeared broadly skeptical of those claims during arguments in March and several worried that common interactions between government officials and the platforms could be affected by a ruling for the states.

The Biden administration underscored those concerns when it noted that the government would lose its ability to communicate with the social media companies about antisemitic and anti-Muslim posts, as well as on issues of national security, public health and election integrity.

Justices’ Decision on the Dispute

But the justices did not weigh in on the substance of the states’ claims or the administration’s response in their decision Wednesday.

“We begin — and end — with standing,” Barrett wrote. “At this stage, neither the individual nor the state plaintiffs have established standing to seek an injunction against any defendant. We therefore lack jurisdiction to reach the merits of the dispute.”

In dissent, Alito wrote that the states amply demonstrated their right to sue. “For months, high-ranking government officials placed unrelenting pressure on Facebook to suppress Americans’ free speech. Because the court unjustifiably refuses to address this serious threat to the First Amendment, I respectfully dissent,” he wrote for the three justices in the minority.

The Supreme Court had earlier acted to keep the lower-court rulings on hold. Alito, Gorsuch and Thomas would have allowed the restrictions on government contacts with the platforms to go into effect.

Free speech advocates had urged the court to use the case to draw an appropriate line between the government’s acceptable use of the bully pulpit and coercive threats to free speech.

A panel of three judges on the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had ruled earlier that the Biden administration had probably brought unconstitutional pressure on the media platforms. The appellate panel said officials cannot attempt to “coerce or significantly encourage” changes in online content. The panel had previously narrowed a more sweeping order from a federal judge, who wanted to include even more government officials and prohibit mere encouragement of content changes.

The decision was the sixth this term in which the court threw out rulings by the 5th Circuit, one of the nation’s most conservative appeals courts. Last week, the court upheld a gun restriction aimed at protecting domestic violence victims, overturning a 5th Circuit panel.

Earlier in June, the court unanimously ruled that anti-abortion doctors lacked standing to challenge Food and Drug Administration decisions to ease access to the abortion drug mifepristone.

The case is Murthy v. Missouri, 23-411.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Justin Verlander and Giants Agree to $15M, 1-Year Deal

DON'T MISS

A’s Ink Slugger Brent Rooker to $60M, 5-Year Deal

DON'T MISS

Los Angeles Officials Order 30,000 Residents to Evacuate as Fire Advances on Homes

DON'T MISS

The 49ers Fire Special Teams Coordinator Brian Schneider, AP Source Says

DON'T MISS

Elon Musk Helped Trump Win. Now He’s Looking at Europe, and Many Politicians Are Alarmed

DON'T MISS

Flying Taxis on the Horizon as Aviation Soars Into a New Frontier

DON'T MISS

Former CEO of Fresno EOC Is Returning to Head Troubled Agency

DON'T MISS

Northern Illinois Will Join Mountain West for Football Only in 2026

DON'T MISS

US Justice Department Accuses Six Major Landlords of Scheming to Keep Rents High

DON'T MISS

Trump Refuses to Rule Out Use of Military Force to Take Control of Greenland and the Panama Canal

UP NEXT

A’s Ink Slugger Brent Rooker to $60M, 5-Year Deal

UP NEXT

Los Angeles Officials Order 30,000 Residents to Evacuate as Fire Advances on Homes

UP NEXT

The 49ers Fire Special Teams Coordinator Brian Schneider, AP Source Says

UP NEXT

Elon Musk Helped Trump Win. Now He’s Looking at Europe, and Many Politicians Are Alarmed

UP NEXT

Flying Taxis on the Horizon as Aviation Soars Into a New Frontier

UP NEXT

Former CEO of Fresno EOC Is Returning to Head Troubled Agency

UP NEXT

Northern Illinois Will Join Mountain West for Football Only in 2026

UP NEXT

US Justice Department Accuses Six Major Landlords of Scheming to Keep Rents High

UP NEXT

Trump Refuses to Rule Out Use of Military Force to Take Control of Greenland and the Panama Canal

UP NEXT

Bredefeld Tries to ‘Shake up Good Ol’ Boys Club’ on Day One

The 49ers Fire Special Teams Coordinator Brian Schneider, AP Source Says

5 hours ago

Elon Musk Helped Trump Win. Now He’s Looking at Europe, and Many Politicians Are Alarmed

5 hours ago

Flying Taxis on the Horizon as Aviation Soars Into a New Frontier

5 hours ago

Former CEO of Fresno EOC Is Returning to Head Troubled Agency

5 hours ago

Northern Illinois Will Join Mountain West for Football Only in 2026

5 hours ago

US Justice Department Accuses Six Major Landlords of Scheming to Keep Rents High

5 hours ago

Trump Refuses to Rule Out Use of Military Force to Take Control of Greenland and the Panama Canal

7 hours ago

Bredefeld Tries to ‘Shake up Good Ol’ Boys Club’ on Day One

7 hours ago

Aubrey Plaza Responds to Husband Jeff Baena’s Death: ‘Unimaginable Tragedy’

7 hours ago

Washington Post Lays Off 4% of Its Workforce

7 hours ago

Justin Verlander and Giants Agree to $15M, 1-Year Deal

SAN FRANCISCO  — Justin Verlander and the San Francisco Giants have agreed to a $15 million, one-year contract, according to a person with d...

3 hours ago

Justin Verlander Will Join Giants
3 hours ago

Justin Verlander and Giants Agree to $15M, 1-Year Deal

5 hours ago

A’s Ink Slugger Brent Rooker to $60M, 5-Year Deal

Flames rise as the Palisades Fire advances on homes in the Pacific Palisades neighborhood of Los Angeles, Tuesday, Jan. 7, 2025. (AP/Ethan Swope)
5 hours ago

Los Angeles Officials Order 30,000 Residents to Evacuate as Fire Advances on Homes

5 hours ago

The 49ers Fire Special Teams Coordinator Brian Schneider, AP Source Says

5 hours ago

Elon Musk Helped Trump Win. Now He’s Looking at Europe, and Many Politicians Are Alarmed

5 hours ago

Flying Taxis on the Horizon as Aviation Soars Into a New Frontier

5 hours ago

Former CEO of Fresno EOC Is Returning to Head Troubled Agency

5 hours ago

Northern Illinois Will Join Mountain West for Football Only in 2026

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend