Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
CA's Big Pension Funds Lost Billions in Stock Market Selloff. Can They Recover in Time?
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 3 days ago on
April 9, 2025

New tariffs triggered market volatility, causing significant losses for California's major public employee retirement systems, CalPERS and CalSTRS.

Share

This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.

The investment chief who’s responsible for the retirement plans of 1 million California educators saw foreboding signs when he spoke to the state’s teachers’ pension board last month.

By Adam Ashton

CalMatters

Scott Chan pointed to the torrent of executive orders and policy changes coming out of the new Trump administration and noted they “caused a tremendous amount of uncertainty in the marketplace” He warned of a recession, and a potential drop in stock markets of 20% or more.

“I would say that potential risks here are unprecedented. They are world changing,” said Chan, the chief investment officer at the California State Teachers’ Retirement System.

Two weeks later, President Donald Trump announced new tariffs against nearly every country, triggering a global financial shock that included the steepest stock market declines since the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic and wiped away trillions of dollars from investors’ portfolios.

The tariffs and the market plunge represent a new challenge for California’s underfunded pension plans, including Chan’s CalSTRS and the larger California Public Employees’ Retirement System. Combined, the two funds with headquarters on opposite banks of the Sacramento River hold more than $800 billion in assets and serve millions of beneficiaries.

CalPERS lost about $15 billion on Thursday and Friday, the first two days after Trump’s announcement. It held $516.5 billion on Monday morning. CalSTRS releases updates on its portfolio on a monthly basis. It likely recorded losses on a similar scale to CalPERS.

California’s retired teachers, cops, firefighters and other civil servants can count on their checks to keep coming. The threat of pension losses centers on government employers, such as cities and school districts, that would have to pay more money into the funds to make up for losses.

“It’s something we’re all bracing for and hoping there can be some course correction federally to allow us to steer the ship and recapture some of these losses,” said Dane Hutchings, whose firm, the California Public Policy Group, writes grants for and lobbies on behalf of California cities.

Terry Brennand, who watches CalPERS closely on behalf of the unions that represent public employees, likened the drop to the market crashes that followed the tech bubble of the 1990s and the housing downturn of the Great Recession.

“This one is not scam marketing or a bad market,” said Brennand of Service Employees International Union California, describing the economic conditions that preceded the downturns in 2000 and 2007. “We just turned the gun on ourselves and fired it.”

Trump has characterized the turmoil associated with the tariffs as a short-term pain that will ultimately make Americans wealthier by inducing companies to invest in domestic manufacturing. Members of his administration also have said the tariffs could prompt nations to seek new trading deals that would be more beneficial to the U.S.

“I don’t want anything to go down, but sometimes you have to take medicine to fix something,” Trump said to reporters on Sunday. “What’s going to happen to the markets, I can’t tell you. But our country is much stronger.”

What CalPERS and CalSTRS Have to Earn

But the tariffs carry the potential for a debilitating trade war, one of the risks that Chan highlighted to the CalSTRS board last month.

“It’s not so easy to say, ‘We’re going to assess tariffs on everybody else, but no one is going to assess tariffs on us,’” said California State Treasurer Fiona Ma, a Democrat. “We’re going to see a lot of anxiety and disruption, and we’re seeing that in the markets.”

Ma has a close look at the recent volatility from her seat on the boards overseeing CalPERS and CalSTRS. Her office also manages a mix of other public investments including bonds, college savings accounts and a kind of bank for local governments.

She said the stock market shock has not yet jeopardized other state and local finances. For instance, last week the state successfully sold creditors $2.6 billion in bonds — voter-approved loans that the state will pay down over time. And, local governments have not asked to pull money from their pooled investment fund.

Both big California public pension funds emphasize that they are long-term investors with diverse portfolios that do not rely solely on the stock market, but both are also under pressure to meet annual investment targets — 7% at CalSTRS and 6.8% at CalPERS. Their deadline to hit that sum comes every June 30.

Government agencies have to pay more to fund pensions when the funds miss those targets.

Looking for Opportunities in Market Decline

Coming up short also can have long-term consequences. Both CalPERS and CalSTRS are considered underfunded because their portfolios are worth less than what they owe cumulatively to their beneficiaries. That’s partly because state lawmakers boosted retirement benefits for public employees during the dot-com bubble. Both funds have plans to become fully funded, and government workers hired after 2013 receive less generous benefits than the employees who preceded them.

So far, the market crash that followed the COVID-19 pandemic cost CalPERS and CalSTRS more money, at least at first, than the current downturn. Each fund recorded historically high returns the following year, softening the blow.

Stephen Gilmore, chief investment officer at CalPERS, in a written statement said the fund is “well-positioned to weather unsettled times.” He pointed to potential opportunities that could emerge in the shakeup:

“There’s still a lot to learn about the nature of the governmental actions that have taken place, especially when it comes to the imposition of new tariffs and their impact on GDP and inflation. On the upside, market volatility can present opportunities to buy assets that may be oversold relative to their real value. Those purchases can boost our portfolio in the years to come.”

Correction: CalSTRS releases updates on the value of its portfolio on a monthly basis. An earlier version of this story included incorrect information about those updates.

This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

How to Ease Your Money Anxiety When the Economy Is Stressing You Out

DON'T MISS

U.S. Holds Talks With Iran Over Its Nuclear Program

DON'T MISS

Fear Shadows Many Children in Immigrant Families

DON'T MISS

Intellectually Disabled Teen Shot by Idaho Police Dies After Being Removed From Life Support

DON'T MISS

In South Carolina, a Once Thriving Textile Hub Is Baffled by Trump’s Tariffs

DON'T MISS

Israel Cuts Off Gaza’s Southern City of Rafah and Vows to ‘Vigorously’ Expand in the Territory

DON'T MISS

Judge Relaxes Ban on DOGE Access to Sensitive US Treasury Information

DON'T MISS

This Easy Crumble Has Peanut Butter-and-Jelly Vibes

DON'T MISS

Trump Administration Says It Will Exclude Some Electronics From ‘Reciprocal’ Tariffs

DON'T MISS

Maltipoo Rescued From Severe Tick Infestation Now Recovering, Ready for Adoption

UP NEXT

In South Carolina, a Once Thriving Textile Hub Is Baffled by Trump’s Tariffs

UP NEXT

How California Can Reduce High Concession Prices in Its Taxpayer-Funded Stadiums

UP NEXT

CA Insurance Commissioner Lara Used Campaign Funds for $30K in High-End Meals

UP NEXT

US Stocks Jump and the Bond Market Swings to Cap Wall Street’s Chaotic Week

UP NEXT

California May Add Bigfoot to List of State Symbols? States Battle Over Bread, Beasts and Beverages

UP NEXT

After a Rocky 90-Day Tenure, LA’s Recovery Czar Is Stepping Down

UP NEXT

Trump Canceled Millions in CA School Grants. The State Sues to Reclaim the Money

UP NEXT

Border Patrol to Retrain Hundreds of CA Agents on Complying With the Constitution

UP NEXT

Jury Finds Soulja Boy Liable for Sexual Assault of Ex-Assistant, Awards Over $4M

UP NEXT

China Hits Back at US and Will Raise Tariffs on American Goods From 84% to 125%

Intellectually Disabled Teen Shot by Idaho Police Dies After Being Removed From Life Support

2 hours ago

In South Carolina, a Once Thriving Textile Hub Is Baffled by Trump’s Tariffs

3 hours ago

Israel Cuts Off Gaza’s Southern City of Rafah and Vows to ‘Vigorously’ Expand in the Territory

9 hours ago

Judge Relaxes Ban on DOGE Access to Sensitive US Treasury Information

9 hours ago

This Easy Crumble Has Peanut Butter-and-Jelly Vibes

9 hours ago

Trump Administration Says It Will Exclude Some Electronics From ‘Reciprocal’ Tariffs

9 hours ago

Maltipoo Rescued From Severe Tick Infestation Now Recovering, Ready for Adoption

9 hours ago

How California Can Reduce High Concession Prices in Its Taxpayer-Funded Stadiums

10 hours ago

Passover Begins Soon. For Many Jews, the Celebrations Will Occur Amid Anxieties and Divisions

10 hours ago

Trump’s Approval Rating Sinks as Trade Policies Take Center Stage

1 day ago

How to Ease Your Money Anxiety When the Economy Is Stressing You Out

Even before this year’s economic turmoil hit, financial anxiety among Americans was running high. Really high. Four of 5 Americans in a surv...

1 hour ago

1 hour ago

How to Ease Your Money Anxiety When the Economy Is Stressing You Out

1 hour ago

U.S. Holds Talks With Iran Over Its Nuclear Program

1 hour ago

Fear Shadows Many Children in Immigrant Families

2 hours ago

Intellectually Disabled Teen Shot by Idaho Police Dies After Being Removed From Life Support

3 hours ago

In South Carolina, a Once Thriving Textile Hub Is Baffled by Trump’s Tariffs

9 hours ago

Israel Cuts Off Gaza’s Southern City of Rafah and Vows to ‘Vigorously’ Expand in the Territory

9 hours ago

Judge Relaxes Ban on DOGE Access to Sensitive US Treasury Information

9 hours ago

This Easy Crumble Has Peanut Butter-and-Jelly Vibes

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend