Reality TV Couple Sues Los Angeles After Losing Home in Fires

By Associated Press

Published 4 months ago on

January 24, 2025

Reality TV stars join lawsuit against LA over water system failures during devastating wildfires. (Shutterstock)

Reality TV stars Heidi Montag and Spencer Pratt join lawsuit against Los Angeles over wildfire damage.
Lawsuit cites water system failures, including offline reservoir and inadequate water tanks for firefighting.
Plaintiffs invoke 'inverse condemnation' principle, similar to utility liability for wildfire damages.

LOS ANGELES — Reality TV couple Heidi Montag and Spencer Pratt are suing the city of Los Angeles after losing their Pacific Palisades home in the wildfires that have torn through Southern California in recent weeks.

The couple, who rose to stardom on “The Hills,” a spin-off of “Laguna Beach,” filed the lawsuit Tuesday along with more than 20 other property owners and residents who were affected by the Palisades Fire. The complaint blames Los Angeles and its municipal water department for the water issues that hampered firefighting efforts and says it ultimately led to the damage to their properties.

Devastating Fires Among California’s Most Destructive

The Eaton and Palisades fires, ignited by strong winds during one of the region’s driest years on record, have killed 28 people and destroyed more than 12,000 structures, putting them among the most destructive fires in California history.

There has been intense scrutiny over hydrants running dry and problems with water pressure, leading to a barrage of lawsuits against the city and the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. California Gov. Gavin Newsom has called for an independent investigation into the LA water utility over the issues.

Water System Failures Cited in Lawsuit

The complaint filed by the couple and others mentions that the Santa Ynez Reservoir, which services the Pacific Palisades neighborhood, was offline and had been out of commission since February 2024 while awaiting repairs. The hydrants in the neighborhood were connected to three tanks that held 1 million gallons (3.7 million liters) of water each and went dry within 12 hours, the complaint said, citing Janisse Quiñones, the water utility’s chief executive and chief engineer.

Without water from the reservoir, firefighters had to primarily rely on the water tanks, which were not designed to fight such a large fire, the complaint said.

The city and water utility did not immediately respond to emailed requests for comment.

Delayed Repairs and Legal Implications

While the repairs to the reservoir were requested in January 2024, the water utility told the Los Angeles Times they would not be completed until April or May 2025.

The lawsuit called the Palisades Fire an “inescapable and unavoidable consequence” of the water system operated by the city and water utility.

“The system necessarily failed, and this failure was a substantial factor in causing Plaintiffs to suffer the losses alleged in this complaint,” it said.

The plaintiffs cite the principle known as “inverse condemnation,” which is the same mechanism that requires utilities to pay for wildfire damages caused by their equipment.