United States President Joe Biden addresses the 79th session of the United Nations General Assembly, Tuesday, Sept. 24, 2024, at UN headquarters. (AP/Manuel Balce Ceneta)
- The Biden administration has warned Israel to allow increased humanitarian aid into Gaza or risk suspension of military aid, citing U.S. law.
- Despite prior indications of Israel blocking aid, Biden has been criticized for continuing to supply weapons without leveraging them for humanitarian access.
- With over 3,100 children killed in Gaza, skepticism remains about whether Biden's recent ultimatum is genuine or merely a political maneuver ahead of the election.
Share
|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Nicholas Kristof
Opinion
With Israel clamping down on food shipments to the Gaza Strip, the Biden administration is finally warning Israel to ease up or risk a suspension of some military aid.
In a letter released Tuesday, the administration gave Israel 30 days to allow more humanitarian assistance to enter Gaza, or it would face consequences. That’s a welcome indication that President Joe Biden is belatedly enforcing U.S. law, which bars military assistance to countries that block American humanitarian aid.
Related Story: After Weeks of Silence, Netanyahu and Biden Speak by Phone
As a State Department official, Matthew Miller, put it: “It’s just a plain reading of U.S. law.” The problem is that until now Biden hasn’t seemed able to read the law plainly.
In April, the U.S. Agency for International Development and the State Department’s refugee bureau decided that Israel was blocking aid. Yet Biden somehow concluded that Israel was not in violation of the law, and weapons largely continued to flow to Israel, magnifying the devastation in Gaza.
More recently, Israel has dialed back the flow of food into Gaza even more sharply. The State Department says that the level of aid entering Gaza in September was lower than at any point since the Oct. 7 terror attacks by Hamas against Israel. There has been debate about whether Israel is pursuing one retired general’s proposed starvation strategy, particularly in northern Gaza.
Related Story: Supreme Court Will Hear a Challenge to a Biden Administration Rule on Ghost
I admire much of Biden’s foreign policy, but I have been very critical of his failure to use weapons shipments as leverage to force Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel to listen to Washington’s calls for restraint and a cease-fire. Without leverage, Biden has been reduced to pleading with Netanyahu and having his pleas humiliatingly rebuffed. Biden’s weakness has made the United States complicit in the resulting humanitarian tragedy.
So it’s a welcome indication that Biden may finally be willing to use leverage, instead of hugs, to influence Netanyahu. But the 30-day time period, which means nothing is likely to happen until after the election, makes one wonder if this isn’t more performative than substantive, meant to help Vice President Kamala Harris win Arab American votes in Michigan.
Related Story: Biden Sought Peace but Facilitated War
I hope Biden is finally serious — more than 3,100 children in Gaza under the age of 5 have been killed, according to Save the Children, and UNICEF has called Gaza the world’s most dangerous place to be a child. But after a year in which he has allowed Netanyahu to walk all over him, skepticism seems reasonable.
–
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
c. 2024 The New York Times Company
