Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Poor Performing Fresno Unified Has Some Nerve Asking Us to Take on $1 Billion in New Taxes
Opinion
By Opinion
Published 1 month ago on
October 15, 2024

GV Wire Publisher Darius Assemi, left, and Fresno City Councilmember Mike Karbassi opine that FUSD's $500 million Measure H bond on the Nov. 5 ballot is premature because the district has yet to name a superintendent and the project list fails the "equity" test. (GV Wire Composite/Paul Marshall).

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

While six of the seven Fresno Unified School Board trustees try to put a happy face on the district’s new $500 million Measure H bond, voters deserve the ugly truth behind the facade.

Darius Assemi

Mike Karbassi portrait

Mike Karbassi

Opinion

For starters, what’s advertised as a $500 million bond will cost property owners more than $1 billion over the 40-year life of the bond. Forty years for a school bond is highly unusual. Finance experts tell us that school bonds normally are for 25 to 30 years.

In addition, the School Board is asking the public to pass this bond before it hires a permanent successor to retired Superintendent Bob Nelson. Yes, Fresno Unified has many old schools that need updating and renovation. But why should voters invest their hard-earned dollars without knowing who the next superintendent is and the plan for turning around one of the nation’s worst-performing districts for student achievement?

This is why we support past School Board President Brooke Ashjian’s and current Board President Susan Wittrup’s efforts to ensure the search for a new superintendent is fully transparent and nationwide. We also support their  opposition to Measure H.

Bond Backers Fail Their Own ‘Equity’ Test

We note that some of the bond’s biggest backers are those groups that will reap the biggest financial benefits from the bond’s construction projects. It’s also clear to us that the media outlets cheerleading for the bond’s passage include those that stood silent over the decades while Fresno Unified’s academic performance plummeted.

While the bond’s backers talked up “equity” in determining the measure’s project list, the reality is that the Bullard High region is designated to receive just $34 million, or 6.8%, of the bond money while Bullard area residents are projected to contribute nearly $150 million, or 30% to the bond’s repayment — a number that will double over 40 years. This is the very definition of  inequitable.

In addition, the district’s own assessment of regional facilities needs ranks the Bullard area squarely in the middle of the pack — Roosevelt, McLane, and Fresno High above; Hoover, Sunnyside, and Edison below. Clearly, this bond doesn’t meet the equity criteria trumpeted by a supermajority of School Board trustees.

Return in Two Years With a Permanent Superintendent and a Vetted, Right-Sized Bond

Fresno Unified has the worst math and English learning results of any school district in our county. We should not reward a district with these results with a $500 million bond that would cost $1 billion-plus and create the highest property tax rate in Fresno County. Especially when homeowners 30 years old today will still be paying for the bond when they’re 70. Renters wouldn’t be spared this burden either as landlords will raise their rents to absorb the higher tax rate.

We can’t let politics by a few board members shoot down the opportunity to hire the best superintendent. Once we have the new superintendent in place, then she or he should guide the process for a new facilities bond. One that is transparent, open to the public, right-sized to meet the district’s needs, and vetted by a community bond oversight committee before going to the ballot.

This is about the future of our kids and the future of our community. We should not pass a bond hastily concocted amid the obvious uncertainty and politics clouding the district’s future leadership team. The wisest course is to do this right way and bring a new bond back in two years.

About the Authors

Darius Assemi of Fresno is a builder, farmer, and philanthropist. He is the president/CEO of Granville Homes and publisher of the award-winning GV Wire.

Small businessman Mike Karbassi represents northwest Fresno on the Fresno City Council.

 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Trump Promised to ‘End’ Offshore Wind. What Will That Mean for California’s Big Bet?

DON'T MISS

Tulsi Gabbard: A Controversial Nominee for National Intelligence Director

DON'T MISS

What Is Saving Grace for Embattled Valley Farmers? People Always Need Food

DON'T MISS

A Project 2025 Leader’s Exile Ends

DON'T MISS

What Makes Walking So Great for Your Health and What Else You Need to Do

DON'T MISS

Did Merced City Schools Board Stifle Free Speech? Legal Group Seeks Changes

DON'T MISS

Budget-Friendly Hacks for a Friendsgiving Feast to Remember

DON'T MISS

How the Trump Administration Could Ease or Expand California’s Housing Crisis

DON'T MISS

Clovis Measure A Gets Breathing Room. Lead Widens in Clovis Trustee Race. Measure Q Tops 55% for First Time.

DON'T MISS

Richardson Close to Finishing Massive NE Fresno Council Upset

UP NEXT

Tulsi Gabbard: A Controversial Nominee for National Intelligence Director

UP NEXT

What Is Saving Grace for Embattled Valley Farmers? People Always Need Food

UP NEXT

A Project 2025 Leader’s Exile Ends

UP NEXT

What Makes Walking So Great for Your Health and What Else You Need to Do

UP NEXT

Did Merced City Schools Board Stifle Free Speech? Legal Group Seeks Changes

UP NEXT

Budget-Friendly Hacks for a Friendsgiving Feast to Remember

UP NEXT

How the Trump Administration Could Ease or Expand California’s Housing Crisis

UP NEXT

Clovis Measure A Gets Breathing Room. Lead Widens in Clovis Trustee Race. Measure Q Tops 55% for First Time.

UP NEXT

Richardson Close to Finishing Massive NE Fresno Council Upset

UP NEXT

Democrat Josh Harder Wins Reelection to U.S. House in California’s 9th Congressional District

A Project 2025 Leader’s Exile Ends

2 days ago

What Makes Walking So Great for Your Health and What Else You Need to Do

2 days ago

Did Merced City Schools Board Stifle Free Speech? Legal Group Seeks Changes

2 days ago

Budget-Friendly Hacks for a Friendsgiving Feast to Remember

2 days ago

How the Trump Administration Could Ease or Expand California’s Housing Crisis

2 days ago

Clovis Measure A Gets Breathing Room. Lead Widens in Clovis Trustee Race. Measure Q Tops 55% for First Time.

2 days ago

Richardson Close to Finishing Massive NE Fresno Council Upset

2 days ago

Democrat Josh Harder Wins Reelection to U.S. House in California’s 9th Congressional District

2 days ago

California Will Rename Places to Remove Racist Term for a Native American Woman

2 days ago

Trump Pentagon Pick Had Been Flagged by Fellow Service Member as Possible ‘Insider Threat’

2 days ago

Trump Promised to ‘End’ Offshore Wind. What Will That Mean for California’s Big Bet?

California’s offshore wind industry could be a casualty if President-elect Donald Trump makes good on his promise to sign an executive...

17 hours ago

17 hours ago

Trump Promised to ‘End’ Offshore Wind. What Will That Mean for California’s Big Bet?

19 hours ago

Tulsi Gabbard: A Controversial Nominee for National Intelligence Director

19 hours ago

What Is Saving Grace for Embattled Valley Farmers? People Always Need Food

2 days ago

A Project 2025 Leader’s Exile Ends

2 days ago

What Makes Walking So Great for Your Health and What Else You Need to Do

2 days ago

Did Merced City Schools Board Stifle Free Speech? Legal Group Seeks Changes

2 days ago

Budget-Friendly Hacks for a Friendsgiving Feast to Remember

2 days ago

How the Trump Administration Could Ease or Expand California’s Housing Crisis

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend