Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Harvey Weinstein’s 2020 Rape Conviction Overturned by NY Appeals Court
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 1 month ago on
April 25, 2024

New York's highest court overturns Harvey Weinstein's 2020 rape conviction, reopening a painful chapter in America's reckoning with sexual misconduct by powerful figures. (AP File)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

NEW YORK — New York’s highest court on Thursday overturned Harvey Weinstein’s 2020 rape conviction, reversing a landmark ruling of the #MeToo era in determining the trial judge improperly allowed women to testify about allegations against the ex-movie mogul that weren’t part of the case.

Weinstein, 72, will remain imprisoned because he was convicted in Los Angeles in 2022 of another rape. But the New York ruling reopens a painful chapter in America’s reckoning with sexual misconduct by powerful figures — an era that began in 2017 with a flood of allegations against Weinstein.

Retrial on the Horizon

The Manhattan district attorney’s office signaled its intention to retry Weinstein, and his accusers could again be forced to retell their stories on the witness stand.

The state Court of Appeals overturned Weinstein’s 23-year sentence in a 4-3 decision, finding that “the trial court erroneously admitted testimony of uncharged, alleged prior sexual acts against persons other than the complainants of the underlying crimes.” The court’s majority called this “an abuse of judicial discretion.”

In a stinging dissent, Judge Madeline Singas wrote that the Court of Appeals was continuing a “disturbing trend of overturning juries’ guilty verdicts in cases involving sexual violence.”

Impact on the #MeToo Movement

Weinstein has been in a New York prison since his conviction on charges of criminal sex acts for forcibly performing oral sex on a TV and film production assistant in 2006 and rape in the third degree for an attack on an aspiring actress in 2013. He was sentenced to 16 years in prison in the Los Angeles case.

Weinstein lawyer Arthur Aidala called the Court of Appeals ruling “a tremendous victory for every criminal defendant in the state of New York.”

The Manhattan district attorney’s office said in a statement it would “do everything in our power to retry this case.”

Attorney Douglas H. Wigdor, who has represented eight Harvey Weinstein accusers including two witnesses at the New York criminal trial, called the ruling “a major step back in holding those accountable for acts of sexual violence.”

“Courts routinely admit evidence of other uncharged acts where they assist juries in understanding issues concerning the intent, modus operandi or scheme of the defendant. The jury was instructed on the relevance of this testimony and overturning the verdict is tragic in that it will require the victims to endure yet another trial,” Wigdor said in a statement.

Debra Katz, the prominent civil rights and #MeToo attorney who represented several Weinstein accusers, said her clients are “feeling gutted” by the ruling, but that she believed – and was telling them – that their testimony had changed the world.

“People continue to come forward, people continue to support other victims who’ve reported sexual assault and violence, and I truly believe there’s no going back from that,” Katz said, predicting that Weinstein would be convicted again at a retrial.

She said accusers feel great comfort that Weinstein will remain behind bars.

The reversal of Weinstein’s conviction is the second major #MeToo setback in the last two years, after the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear an appeal of a Pennsylvania court decision to throw out Bill Cosby’s sexual assault conviction.

Weinstein’s conviction stood for more than four years, heralded by activists and advocates as a milestone achievement, but dissected just as quickly by his lawyers and, later, the Court of Appeals when it heard arguments on the matter in February.

Allegations against Weinstein, the once powerful and feared studio boss behind such Oscar winners as “Pulp Fiction” and “Shakespeare in Love,” ushered in the #MeToo movement. Dozens of women came forward to accuse Weinstein, including famous actresses such as Ashley Judd and Uma Thurman. His New York trial drew intense publicity, with protesters chanting “rapist” outside the courthouse.

Weinstein is incarcerated in New York at the Mohawk Correctional Facility, about 100 miles (160 kilometers) northwest of Albany.

He maintains his innocence. He contends any sexual activity was consensual.

Aidala argued before the appeals court in February that Burke swayed the trial by allowing three women to testify about allegations that weren’t part of the case and by giving prosecutors permission to confront Weinstein, if he had testified, about his long history of brutish behavior.

Aidala argued the extra testimony went beyond the normally allowable details about motive, opportunity, intent or a common scheme or plan, and essentially put Weinstein on trial for crimes he wasn’t charged with.

Weinstein wanted to testify, but opted not to because Burke’s ruling would’ve meant answering questions about more than two-dozen alleged acts of misbehavior dating back four decades, Aidala said. They included fighting with his movie producer brother, flipping over a table in anger and snapping at waiters and yelling at his assistants.

A lawyer for the Manhattan district attorney’s office, which prosecuted the case, argued that the judge‘s rulings were proper and that the extra evidence and testimony he allowed was important to provide jurors context about Weinstein’s behavior and the way he interacted with women.

Appellate Chief Steven Wu said Weinstein’s acquittal on the most serious charges — two counts of predatory sexual assault and a first-degree rape charge involving actor Annabella Sciorra’s allegations of a mid-1990s rape — showed jurors were paying attention and they were not confused or overwhelmed by the additional testimony.

The Associated Press does not generally identify people alleging sexual assault unless they consent to be named; Sciorra has spoken publicly about her allegations.

The Court of Appeals agreed last year to take Weinstein’s case after an intermediate appeals court upheld his conviction. Prior to their ruling, judges on the lower appellate court had raised doubts about Burke’s conduct during oral arguments. One observed that Burke had let prosecutors pile on with “incredibly prejudicial testimony” from additional witnesses.

Burke’s term expired at the end of 2022. He was not reappointed and is no longer a judge.

In appealing, Weinstein’s lawyers sought a new trial, but only for the criminal sexual act charge. They argued the rape charge could not be retried because it involves alleged conduct outside the statute of limitations.

 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Former Fresno Farm Water Manager Pleads Guilty to Federal Water Theft Conspiracy

DON'T MISS

Local Dealership Family Buys Fresno Infiniti. Where Is It Going?

DON'T MISS

California Bill Would End ‘Gender Police’ Reports From Public Schools to Parents

DON'T MISS

Councilmembers Want Answers on Lawsuit. We Have Them.

DON'T MISS

Fresno Toddler Receives Support With a Donated Mobility Ramp

DON'T MISS

Fresno Catholic Diocese Will File Bankruptcy Because of Sexual Abuse Claims: Bishop Brennan

DON'T MISS

Storm Damage Forces Removal of US-Built Gaza Pier for Repairs

DON'T MISS

Lexi Thompson, a 15-Time Winner on the LPGA Tour, Is Retiring From Full-Time Golf at 29

DON'T MISS

Trump Prosecutor Emphasizes ‘Cover-Up’ in Closing Arguments; Defense Targets Key Witness

DON'T MISS

Clovis Detectives Quickly Arrest Suspects in Construction Equipment Theft at Church

UP NEXT

Local Dealership Family Buys Fresno Infiniti. Where Is It Going?

UP NEXT

Councilmembers Want Answers on Lawsuit. We Have Them.

UP NEXT

Fresno Toddler Receives Support With a Donated Mobility Ramp

UP NEXT

Fresno Catholic Diocese Will File Bankruptcy Because of Sexual Abuse Claims: Bishop Brennan

UP NEXT

Storm Damage Forces Removal of US-Built Gaza Pier for Repairs

UP NEXT

Lexi Thompson, a 15-Time Winner on the LPGA Tour, Is Retiring From Full-Time Golf at 29

UP NEXT

Trump Prosecutor Emphasizes ‘Cover-Up’ in Closing Arguments; Defense Targets Key Witness

UP NEXT

Clovis Detectives Quickly Arrest Suspects in Construction Equipment Theft at Church

UP NEXT

Albert Ruddy, Oscar-Winning Producer of ‘the Godfather’ and ‘Million Dollar Baby,’ Dies at 94

UP NEXT

Who Bears Some Blame for High CA Gas Prices? Look in the Mirror

Councilmembers Want Answers on Lawsuit. We Have Them.

9 hours ago

Fresno Toddler Receives Support With a Donated Mobility Ramp

10 hours ago

Fresno Catholic Diocese Will File Bankruptcy Because of Sexual Abuse Claims: Bishop Brennan

10 hours ago

Storm Damage Forces Removal of US-Built Gaza Pier for Repairs

11 hours ago

Lexi Thompson, a 15-Time Winner on the LPGA Tour, Is Retiring From Full-Time Golf at 29

12 hours ago

Trump Prosecutor Emphasizes ‘Cover-Up’ in Closing Arguments; Defense Targets Key Witness

12 hours ago

Clovis Detectives Quickly Arrest Suspects in Construction Equipment Theft at Church

12 hours ago

Fresno ‘Flirts’ with Hot Weather. When Will Triple Digits Arrive?

13 hours ago

Albert Ruddy, Oscar-Winning Producer of ‘the Godfather’ and ‘Million Dollar Baby,’ Dies at 94

13 hours ago

Who Bears Some Blame for High CA Gas Prices? Look in the Mirror

13 hours ago

Former Fresno Farm Water Manager Pleads Guilty to Federal Water Theft Conspiracy

Dennis Falaschi — indicted two years ago in an alleged $25 million federal water theft — pleaded guilty to a single count of conspiring to s...

7 hours ago

7 hours ago

Former Fresno Farm Water Manager Pleads Guilty to Federal Water Theft Conspiracy

8 hours ago

Local Dealership Family Buys Fresno Infiniti. Where Is It Going?

9 hours ago

California Bill Would End ‘Gender Police’ Reports From Public Schools to Parents

9 hours ago

Councilmembers Want Answers on Lawsuit. We Have Them.

10 hours ago

Fresno Toddler Receives Support With a Donated Mobility Ramp

10 hours ago

Fresno Catholic Diocese Will File Bankruptcy Because of Sexual Abuse Claims: Bishop Brennan

11 hours ago

Storm Damage Forces Removal of US-Built Gaza Pier for Repairs

12 hours ago

Lexi Thompson, a 15-Time Winner on the LPGA Tour, Is Retiring From Full-Time Golf at 29

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend