Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Stockton's Lesson: Investing in People Improves Impoverished Cities
Joe-Mathews
By Joe Mathews
Published 2 years ago on
May 25, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

If California wants to curb poverty, its local governments must become richer.

Photo of Joe Mathews

Joe Mathews

Opinion

That’s one lesson from Stockton’s recent history, as recounted by Stanford Law School professor Michelle Wilde Anderson in her Zócalo Book Prize-winning book, The Fight to Save the Town. Anderson carefully connects the dots between the poverty of people and the poverty of local governments.

Anderson shows the human impacts of deep, decades-long declines in federal and state support for local governments. Between 1979 and 2016, she notes, federal funding to neighborhood development decreased 80 percent.  Local governments responded by taking on debt, reducing services, selling land, and raising taxes and fees.

“When local governments are populated mostly by low-income people, there is typically much less money for public services,” Anderson writes. “Weak, broke local governments make it harder for residents to lead decent lives on low incomes or get their families out of poverty. Entire towns become poverty traps.”

One poverty trap is Stockton, pop. 322,000, which Anderson depicts both before and after its 2012 bankruptcy. She shows how segregation, drug trafficking, police violence, and long commutes (to Bay Area jobs), have impoverished neighborhoods, and made Stockton a “city of orphans.”

As Stockton’s mayor, Michael Tubbs launched one of the country’s first guaranteed income programs in 2018 with the help of private donations. (AP File)

Stockton’s local government wasn’t up to the challenges. Instead of investing in existing residents, the city subsidized real estate developers in pursuit of new developments that were supposed to attract new residents, tourists, and tax revenues. The Great Recession exposed the folly of these projects, which were often financed, as well as the city’s unsustainable retiree benefit promises to its employees. The results? Layoffs, huge program cuts, and bankruptcy.

Anderson’s book is deeply interested in how community groups, nonprofits, and young officials, led by city councilmember-turned-mayor Michael Tubbs, responded after the bankruptcy. The story she tells is at once encouraging — people and officials made progress in the most difficult of circumstances — and also sobering, because the progress was so tenuous.

Here Is What Worked in Stockton

What worked best were intense, multifaceted efforts to empower residents to solve problems in South Stockton neighborhoods after decades of stigma and disinvestment.

Working together, local officials, nonprofits, and community groups listened to residents and pursued their priorities. This work, mostly by people involved in the REINVENT South Stockton Coalition, started with cleaning up and reclaiming public spaces—first shoring up a park, then shuttering an open-air drug market near a liquor store. Community members opened a clinic that offered mental health resources. And Tubbs and other allies led the way in taking a series of small and large steps focused on treating and reducing the trauma local residents felt.

Poor cities, the scholar concludes, often cut everything except emergency services and public safety, leaving them without the fundamental ingredients that fight poverty: mental health resources, a sense of personal safety, access to living-wage jobs, and secure housing.  “Our theory of change,” one REINVENT leader tells Anderson, “is investing in people. We have to shift the language from people’s problems to their assets.”

South Stockton, and the city as a whole, saw significant gains from this work, though it’s far from clear if the progress can be sustained. Tubbs and his allies lost their re-election bids in 2020. The pandemic undermined local systems and community projects. The founder of one important group, Fathers & Families, was arrested, undermining trauma recovery work.

Anderson is clear-eyed about the need to change the very structure and organization of local government. One of her suggestions for places like Stockton is “changing jurisdictions,” which could mean moving around municipal lines or combining cities into regional units. She also argues that we need new ways of thinking and talking about troubled cities—not as “hellholes” that are “dying” but as places that, with the right resources and new structures for residents, can make poor residents wealthier.

Brown, Newsom Strip Cities of the Power to Solve Their Own Problems

In California, I’d go even further than Anderson and suggests that empowering cities requires restructuring the state itself. California, since the passage of Prop 13 in 1978, has become heavily centralized, with tax policies and resource allocations for localities mostly decided at the state level. Returning power to local governments would require so many different changes to existing policies and budgeting that the best path forward would be a new constitution.

Our last two governors, Jerry Brown and Gavin Newsom, have both championed local government and fighting poverty, at least rhetorically. Meanwhile, both men centralized more power in their offices, and eschewed constitutional reform. Fighting poverty in this state requires politicians at the state level to do the very opposite—and place more resources and power in the hands of people, their communities, and their local governments.

About the Author

Joe Mathews writes the Connecting California column for Zócalo Public Square, which hosts Michelle Wilde Anderson at a free, public event June 15 at 7:00 p.m., both online and in-person in Los Angeles.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

CA Electricity Bills Could Soar Even Higher as Big Tech Builds More Data Centers

DON'T MISS

Small Businesses Drive the Economy. Yet Their Funding Is at Risk Under Trump.

DON'T MISS

‘Poet Warrior’ Joy Harjo Is Wednesday’s Speaker at Town Hall

DON'T MISS

College Student Stuns NBA Star, Wins $100K in 3-Point Contest

DON'T MISS

Aryan Brotherhood Members Convicted of Murder, Racketeering in Federal Trial

DON'T MISS

KMJ’s Iconic ‘Voice of Fresno,’ Al Smith, Dies at Age 86

DON'T MISS

Trump to Sign Executive Orders as Joint Interview with Musk Airs

DON'T MISS

Death of South Korean Actor at 24 Sparks Discussion About Social Media

DON'T MISS

Timeline of a Cultlike Group Tied to the Killing of a Border Patrol Agent

DON'T MISS

‘Life-threatening Cold’ Hits Parts of US Following Deadly Weekend Flooding

UP NEXT

CA Schools Still Fall Behind Despite Big Increases in Spending

UP NEXT

City Center Unveils Real Solutions for Fresno Homelessness

UP NEXT

Editorials of The Times: Now Is Not the Time to Tune Out

UP NEXT

Look Past Elon Musk’s Chaos. There’s Something More Sinister at Work.

UP NEXT

The Deadly Truth: Record Number of Journalists Killed in 2024

UP NEXT

Will ‘Too Many Cooks’ Complicate LA’s Recovery From Deadly Fires?

UP NEXT

I Miss the Old Kanye, Not This Antisemitic Crashout

UP NEXT

This Isn’t the Donald Trump America Elected

UP NEXT

Trump Targets Troubled CA Bullet Train Project. Will He Kill It, Too?

UP NEXT

CA School Test Scores Trail Those of States Newsom Considers Culturally Backward

College Student Stuns NBA Star, Wins $100K in 3-Point Contest

39 minutes ago

Aryan Brotherhood Members Convicted of Murder, Racketeering in Federal Trial

1 hour ago

KMJ’s Iconic ‘Voice of Fresno,’ Al Smith, Dies at Age 86

1 hour ago

Trump to Sign Executive Orders as Joint Interview with Musk Airs

2 hours ago

Death of South Korean Actor at 24 Sparks Discussion About Social Media

2 hours ago

Timeline of a Cultlike Group Tied to the Killing of a Border Patrol Agent

2 hours ago

‘Life-threatening Cold’ Hits Parts of US Following Deadly Weekend Flooding

3 hours ago

Blink-182 Bassist’s $6M Banksy Painting Heads to Auction for Charity

3 hours ago

Trump Admin Gives Schools Deadline to End DEI Programs or Lose Federal Funding

3 hours ago

US and Russia Hold Historic Talks to End Ukraine War

3 hours ago

CA Electricity Bills Could Soar Even Higher as Big Tech Builds More Data Centers

California residents now pay the highest price for electricity in the continental U.S., state analysts reported last month. Costs have been ...

3 minutes ago

3 minutes ago

CA Electricity Bills Could Soar Even Higher as Big Tech Builds More Data Centers

23 minutes ago

Small Businesses Drive the Economy. Yet Their Funding Is at Risk Under Trump.

33 minutes ago

‘Poet Warrior’ Joy Harjo Is Wednesday’s Speaker at Town Hall

39 minutes ago

College Student Stuns NBA Star, Wins $100K in 3-Point Contest

1 hour ago

Aryan Brotherhood Members Convicted of Murder, Racketeering in Federal Trial

1 hour ago

KMJ’s Iconic ‘Voice of Fresno,’ Al Smith, Dies at Age 86

2 hours ago

Trump to Sign Executive Orders as Joint Interview with Musk Airs

2 hours ago

Death of South Korean Actor at 24 Sparks Discussion About Social Media

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend