Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Why Billions More in CA School Spending Has Not Delivered Promised Results
By admin
Published 2 years ago on
May 21, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

When Jerry Brown returned to the governorship in 2011, a quarter-century after his first stint in California’s highest office ended, one of his early goals was changing how the state finances the education of nearly 6 million public school students.

Brown had a plan, adapted from the theory of Michael Kirst, a distinguished academic and Brown’s long-time education advisor, to concentrate more money on students who chronically trail in academic achievement, albeit those from poor families and/or don’t speak English at home.

Dan Walters with a serious expression

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Kirst called it a “weighted formula,” and the legislation he and Brown persuaded the Legislature to adopt a decade ago was called “Local Control Funding Formula,” or LCFF. It would give school districts with large numbers of at-risk students in those two categories extra funds on the assumption that they would improve achievement.

The legislation lubricated passage by also eliminating most “categorical aids” – money for specific education programs – and thus giving local school officials more flexibility in spending money from local property taxes and state budget appropriations.

Over the last decade, Brown, successor Gavin Newsom and the Legislature have allocated tens of billions of dollars to LCFF in hopes of closing what educators call the achievement gap between the kids deemed to need extra instructional help – about 60% of public school enrollment – and their more privileged peers.

Has it worked? Follow up studies indicate that there may have been a slight narrowing of the gap, but whatever LCFF achieved vanished during the COVID-19 pandemic. At-risk kids were profoundly affected by school closures, since they had less ability to engage in remote learning, dubbed “Zoom school,” and less access to tutoring than more affluent families.

Failed to Deliver Transformative Impact

Pandemic impacts aside, LCFF has not delivered on its promised transformative impact. Even if spending more money would have narrowed the gap – an unproven theory – many school districts, particularly those in urban areas dominated by hardball politics, often fail to concentrate the extra funds on at-risk kids.

Brown insisted that the funds go to districts, not the specific schools where the targeted kids were most numerous, saying he trusted local educators to spend the money wisely. He dubbed it “subsidiarity,” adapting the term from an obscure theological theory.

Education reform groups have criticized Brown’s hands-off approach, saying local school systems need more oversight to prevent them from diverting LCFF funds to other purposes. However, in a recent podcast interview marking the formula’s 10th anniversary, Brown complained that districts have not been given enough flexibility.

“We spend too much time on not anything to do with teaching. Its accountability, its finance, its compliance. This is really a noxious evolution,” Brown said during the interview. “I hope that legislators be aware they’ve gone overboard … we have to look for the wise path.”

Meanwhile, in a separate 10th anniversary interview, Kirst said he regrets that local districts did not use subsidiarity’s flexibility to become more creative in educating kids who fall behind.

“This was their chance to get beyond formulaic budgets and the budget complexity to create a three-year budget plan with clear priorities,” Kirst lamented. “And generally, my impression is that they have not.”

Neither of LCFF’s two fathers offered any appraisal of whether children it purports to help have, in fact, been helped. That lack may indicate that both know LCFF – as implemented, not as envisioned – has not been a roaring success.

California has doubled the amount of per-pupil spending on schooling in the last decade but in national tests of academic achievement, the state still trails other states that spend much less, while state testing tells us that the achievement gap remains unacceptably wide.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Trump Threatens to Impose Sweeping New Tariffs on Mexico, Canada and China

DON'T MISS

49ers QB Brock Purdy Resumes Throwing but Status for Bills Game Unknown

DON'T MISS

Madera Pharmacist Gets 7-Year Federal Sentence for Trafficking Opioids

DON'T MISS

Fresno Set to Roll Out Mental Health CARE Court. How Will It Work?

DON'T MISS

Stock Market Today: Dow Hits Another Record as Stocks Rise

DON'T MISS

Judge in LA Delays Until January Decision on Resentencing Menendez Brothers

DON'T MISS

CHP Launches Thanksgiving Maximum Enforcement to Promote Safe Driving

DON'T MISS

Workers at Charlotte Airport, an American Airlines Hub, Strike During Thanksgiving Travel Week

DON'T MISS

Judge Rejects Request to Sideline a San Jose State Volleyball Player on Grounds She’s Transgender

DON'T MISS

What to Know About the Fresno State Grad Who Is Trump’s Pick for Labor Secretary

UP NEXT

CHP Launches Thanksgiving Maximum Enforcement to Promote Safe Driving

UP NEXT

Judge Rejects Request to Sideline a San Jose State Volleyball Player on Grounds She’s Transgender

UP NEXT

Trump Victory Will Lead to New Battles in California’s ‘Water Wars’

UP NEXT

Californians Pay Sky-High Utility Rates While Subsidizing Out-of-State Residents

UP NEXT

Gov. Newsom: California Could Offer Electric Vehicle Rebates if Trump Eliminates Tax Credit

UP NEXT

Should Sex Abuse Evidence Set the Menendez Brothers Free? A Judge Will Decide

UP NEXT

After Fresno Visit, Newsom Announces $24.7M Taxpayer-Funded Apprenticeship Program

UP NEXT

As Atmospheric River Soaks California, Farmworkers Await Flood Aid Promised in 2023

UP NEXT

Sacramento Region Gained People but Flubbed Economic Opportunities Over 50 Years

UP NEXT

DOGE Is a Promising Step Toward Federal Efficiency: Fareed Zakaria

Fresno Set to Roll Out Mental Health CARE Court. How Will It Work?

11 hours ago

Stock Market Today: Dow Hits Another Record as Stocks Rise

11 hours ago

Judge in LA Delays Until January Decision on Resentencing Menendez Brothers

11 hours ago

CHP Launches Thanksgiving Maximum Enforcement to Promote Safe Driving

11 hours ago

Workers at Charlotte Airport, an American Airlines Hub, Strike During Thanksgiving Travel Week

12 hours ago

Judge Rejects Request to Sideline a San Jose State Volleyball Player on Grounds She’s Transgender

13 hours ago

What to Know About the Fresno State Grad Who Is Trump’s Pick for Labor Secretary

14 hours ago

Trump Victory Will Lead to New Battles in California’s ‘Water Wars’

14 hours ago

Madera Man Sentenced on Firearms Charges Following Jan. 6 Capitol Breach Conviction

14 hours ago

Community Unites at Fourth Annual One Table Fresno Event, Serving Thousands

15 hours ago

Trump Threatens to Impose Sweeping New Tariffs on Mexico, Canada and China

NEW YORK — President-elect Donald Trump is threatening to impose sweeping new tariffs on Mexico, Canada and China as soon as he takes office...

10 hours ago

10 hours ago

Trump Threatens to Impose Sweeping New Tariffs on Mexico, Canada and China

10 hours ago

49ers QB Brock Purdy Resumes Throwing but Status for Bills Game Unknown

Picture of Oxycodone bottles and pills
11 hours ago

Madera Pharmacist Gets 7-Year Federal Sentence for Trafficking Opioids

11 hours ago

Fresno Set to Roll Out Mental Health CARE Court. How Will It Work?

11 hours ago

Stock Market Today: Dow Hits Another Record as Stocks Rise

11 hours ago

Judge in LA Delays Until January Decision on Resentencing Menendez Brothers

11 hours ago

CHP Launches Thanksgiving Maximum Enforcement to Promote Safe Driving

An airplane arrives at Charlotte Douglas International Airport as airport workers strike in front of the Charlotte Douglas International Airport in Charlotte, N.C., Monday, Nov. 25, 2024. (AP/Nell Redmond)
12 hours ago

Workers at Charlotte Airport, an American Airlines Hub, Strike During Thanksgiving Travel Week

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend