Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
1 Woman's Story of Rape Convinced All Weinstein Trial Jurors
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 2 years ago on
December 21, 2022

Share

Most of the jurors at Harvey Weinstein’s Los Angeles trial were ready to convict him of crimes related to three of the four women he was charged with raping or sexually assaulting.

Yet after weeks of deliberation the eight men and four women voted unanimously to convict him of crimes against only one: a Russian-born model and actor known as Jane Doe 1. She lived in Rome and was visiting California for a film festival at age 34 in 2013, when she said the now-disgraced film mogul appeared uninvited at her Los Angeles hotel room door in the middle of the night.

The jurors were released from service and allowed to talk publicly after more than two months Tuesday, when they could not reach a unanimous decision on two aggravating factors that might have made for a higher sentence. Their deliberations took nine days spanning more than two weeks, but those who spoke to reporters said the talks were never contentious.

Weinstein was found guilty of one count of rape and two counts of sexual assault against Jane Doe 1. He now faces up to 18 years in prison in California to go with a 23-year sentence for a rape and sexual assault conviction in New York.

Jurors said that Jane Doe 1’s composure, and the fact that she did not contact Weinstein after he raped her, allowed the divided group to reach consensus on her accusations.

“I thought Jane Doe 1 was very convincing in her story,” said one juror, a 62-year-old man who works in banking and only provided his first name, Michael, because he sought to maintain privacy amid the publicity surrounding the case.

The physical and technical evidence surrounding Jane Doe 1 was some of the thinnest at the trial, but jurors were told that under the law, if they found an accuser’s story credible, that alone could be enough to convict.

They acquitted Weinstein on a count of sexual battery against a massage therapist. They were deadlocked, with 10 of 12 voting for guilt, on a count of sexual battery against model Lauren Young; and voting 8-4 in favor of conviction on rape and sexual assault counts involving Jennifer Siebel Newsom, a documentary filmmaker and wife of California Gov. Gavin Newsom.

The Associated Press does not name people who have said they were sexually abused, unless they come forward publicly or have given consent through their attorneys, as Young and Siebel Newsom have.

Jane Doe 1 only one among them who had no further direct dealings with Weinstein or his representatives after the incident. She testified she had barely known who he was, having been introduced only briefly at the film festival, and wanted nothing from him. Others, including Siebel Newsom, had friendly email exchanges with Weinstein or sought out future meetings after their incidents, a point the defense pounded in their cross-examinations and closing arguments.

That resonated with some jurors.

Michael said he voted to convict on the Jane Doe 1 counts, but reluctantly voted to acquit on the counts involving Siebel Newsom. The difference, he said, was the women’s “subsequent action.”

“In a 2 ½ year period she had sent Mr. Weinstein over 35 emails,” he said of Siebel Newsom. “She wanted access to Harvey Weinstein. It sounded like she wanted access to a lot of his resources. It raised a reasonable doubt in my mind.”

Weinstein has repeatedly denied engaging in any non-consensual sex. His lawyers called some of the encounters in the charges consensual and others flat-out fabricated, including the story told by Jane Doe 1. They pointed out that prosecutors had not even produced independent evidence to place Weinstein at her hotel.

“Jane Doe 1 is lying. Period,” Weinstein lawyer Alan Jackson said in his closing argument.

One juror suggested that the broad statement was undermined by defense arguments that engaged with the details of Jane Doe 1’s account.

“I think Jackson’s last comment where Harvey just wasn’t there, hurt him,” said the juror, Arnold Esqueda, who works as director of security for the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. “They were defending all these things, and then they just say he’s not there. Well they should have just said he’s not there.”

He said he and other jurors made that point to a “very old school” man on the jury who who “decided that he was going vote guilty on that one. He stayed pretty much not guilty on the rest.”

While tearful at times, Jane Doe 1’s testimony was restrained and straightforward in comparison to some that followed. She spoke slowly with a Russian accent, and made nearly no use of a translator on hand.

Esqueda said the intensely emotional testimony of Siebel Newsom, who was screaming through tears at times during her testimony, might have been too much for some fellow jurors. The panel was divided 6-6 on the counts involving her when he suggested getting a read-back of her testimony from the court reporter.

“She had a little drama,” Esqueda said. “So I suggested let’s re-read it, and I think after we read it it switched a couple of people in her favor, without the drama.”

Changes over time in the massage therapist’s story helped lead jurors to acquit on that count, Michael said.

Judge Lisa Lench tentatively scheduled Weinstein’s sentencing for Jan. 9 after his attorneys asked that it be done promptly.

But Lench said it might not happen so quickly given the issues surrounding the case, including prosecutors’ pending decision on whether or not to retry the deadlocked counts.

“We’ll need to consult the victims first and foremost,” Deputy District Attorney Paul Thompson said.

He asked the judge if other Weinstein accusers, including some who testified against him at trial but were not part of the charges, and the women whose counts were deadlocked, might give victim impact statements at the sentencing.

Lench promptly rejected the idea.

“I’m not going to make this an open forum on all of the allegations that were presented in this trial,” she said.

“So it’ll just be Jane Doe 1 then,” Thompson replied.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

‘Who’s Running the White House?’ Trump Brings Back ICE Raids on Farms, Restaurants

DON'T MISS

Granite Park Eviction Lawsuit Heads Toward Trial

DON'T MISS

Missing Clovis Man Found Dead. No Foul Play Suspected

DON'T MISS

Kings County Sheriff Announces Retirement After Nearly 30 Years in Law Enforcement

DON'T MISS

General Mills to Remove Artificial Colors From All Its US Cereals and Foods

DON'T MISS

US FDA to Shorten Review Time for Drug Developers Under New Voucher Program

DON'T MISS

Physician Warns Fresno County Supervisors About Jail’s Medical Provider, Private Equity Co.

DON'T MISS

Houthi Official Says Group Will Intervene to Support Iran Against Israel

DON'T MISS

How Trump Shifted on Iran Under Pressure From Israel

DON'T MISS

Trump Calls for Iran’s ‘Unconditional Surrender’ as Israel-Iran Air War Rages On

UP NEXT

Suspect in Minnesota Lawmaker Killing Visited Other Legislators’ Homes, Prosecutors Say

UP NEXT

Tulare County Authorities Arrest Man in Dinuba Shooting

UP NEXT

Fresno Murder Suspect Arrested in Madera County Following Shooting

UP NEXT

Fresno Stabbing Leads to 7-Hour SWAT Standoff and Arrest, Suspect Identified

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Make DUI Arrest, Cite 135 Drivers in Distracted Driving Crackdown

UP NEXT

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Norman James Walker

UP NEXT

Visalia Stabbing Leaves Man Hospitalized, Suspect Sought

UP NEXT

Suspect in Shooting of Minnesota Lawmakers to Appear in Court on Murder Charges

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Arrested in Fatal DUI Crash on Trimmer Springs Road

UP NEXT

Manhunt for Gunman Who Shot Two Minnesota Lawmakers Enters Second Day

Fed Keeps Rates Steady but Pencils in Two Cuts by End of 2025, Warns of Inflation Ahead

4 hours ago

Putin Says He Does Not Want to Discuss the Possible Israeli-US Killing of Iran’s Supreme Leader

4 hours ago

A Little Coffee With Your Whiskey? Downtown Fresno Gets New Craft Cocktail Lounge

5 hours ago

‘Any Illegal Immigrants?’ Trump Quizzes Workers at the White House

5 hours ago

What Is Juneteenth and When Did It Become a US Federal Holiday?

6 hours ago

US B-2 Bombers, Bunker-Busters and Alternatives

6 hours ago

US Social Security, Medicare to Run Short of Funds in 2033, Trustees Say

6 hours ago

Buss Family to Sell Lakers, Report Says

6 hours ago

Trump Administration Resuming Student Visa Appointments, Official Says

6 hours ago

Teen Girl Accused as Getaway Driver in Caleb Quick Murder Appears in Court

7 hours ago

Trump Faces Uproar From MAGA Base Over Possible Iran Strike

WASHINGTON – The prospect of a U.S. strike against Iran has exposed divisions in the coalition of supporters that brought President Do...

4 hours ago

U.S. President Donald Trump holds a 'Make America Great Again' (MAGA) hat as he attends the commencement ceremony at West Point Military Academy in West Point, New York, U.S., May 24, 2025. REUTERS/Eduardo Munoz/File Photo
4 hours ago

Trump Faces Uproar From MAGA Base Over Possible Iran Strike

4 hours ago

Iran Would Accept Trump’s Offer to Meet Soon, New York Times Reports

4 hours ago

Meta in Talks to Hire Former GitHub CEO Nat Friedman to Join AI Efforts, The Information Reports

4 hours ago

Fed Keeps Rates Steady but Pencils in Two Cuts by End of 2025, Warns of Inflation Ahead

Russian President Vladimir Putin chairs a meeting with members of the Security Council via a video link at the Novo-Ogaryovo state residence outside Moscow, Russia June 10, 2025. (Reuters File)
4 hours ago

Putin Says He Does Not Want to Discuss the Possible Israeli-US Killing of Iran’s Supreme Leader

5 hours ago

A Little Coffee With Your Whiskey? Downtown Fresno Gets New Craft Cocktail Lounge

President Donald Trump talks about the new flag pole being installed on the South Lawn of the White House, in Washington, Wednesday, June, 18, 2025. President Trump decided to check the immigration status of a work crew installing a new flagpole at the White House. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
5 hours ago

‘Any Illegal Immigrants?’ Trump Quizzes Workers at the White House

6 hours ago

What Is Juneteenth and When Did It Become a US Federal Holiday?

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend