Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Two Lawsuits Continue California’s Tax Wars
By admin
Published 2 years ago on
August 15, 2022

Share

 

When California voters passed Proposition 13, the state’s iconic property tax limit, in 1978, it was merely the opening salvo of a decades-long political war over curbing the ability of state and local governments to impose taxes.

The latest of many battles over tax limits occurred just two years ago, when voters rejected an effort to modify Proposition 13 by making it easier to raise taxes on commercial property.

As officials fashioned new ways to raise revenues without violating Proposition’s 13’s strictures, anti-tax groups countered with new ballot measures to prohibit or limit them and were largely successful.

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

One of the more important post-Proposition 13 clashes was over Proposition 218 in 1996, which sought to limit the ability of local governments to levy non-property taxes without voter approval and limit fees to the actual cost of services, rather than provide general revenue. Its limits on fees were later tightened up by Proposition 26 in 2010.

One Proposition 218 section required that taxes for special purposes be approved by two-thirds voter majorities, but the state Supreme Court recently ruled that special taxes proposed by initiative, rather than by governments themselves, require only a simple majority vote.

However, the rest of Proposition 218 remained intact and figures in two lawsuits, one decided last week by the state Supreme Court, that test the measure’s potency.

The Supreme Court case (Zolly vs. City of Oakland) involves franchises the city issued for the collection of trash and other materials. The suit alleges that Oakland collected unreasonably high franchise fees from waste haulers and the extra costs were passed on to consumers in the form of charges, thus violating Proposition 218 and Proposition 26 requirements that fees be strictly related to the cost of services.

The city won at the trial level but an appellate court ruled that the franchise fees are subject to constitutional limits and the Supreme Court upheld the appellate ruling, thus jeopardizing the validity of Oakland’s trash franchises and bolstering Proposition 218’s impact.

The second lawsuit involving Proposition 218 was filed this year against the City of Sacramento, alleging that an election to approve new fees for stormwater facilities was tainted because the city, in effect, stuffed the ballot box.

The election was limited to property owners who would pay the fees, rather than ordinary voters, and the city cast more than 2,000 ballots in favor of the fees on behalf of city-owned parcels while, the lawsuit alleges, limiting the ability of those who owned multiple properties to do the same.

“By casting votes on behalf of city-owned property in favor of a fee that will effectively be paid to the city, the city subverted Proposition 218’s goal of protecting taxpayers by limiting the methods by which local governments exact revenue from taxpayers without their consent,” the lawsuit, filed by commercial property owner Dessins LLC, declares.

The Sacramento case is not only another test of Proposition 218 but a new wrinkle in the recent phenomenon of local governments being more aggressive in promoting revenue and bond measures to voters.

As chronicled in this space and other venues, local officials often hire political consultants to design full-fledged campaigns for their measures under the guise of “information.” At one point, the Fair Political Practices Commission was starting to crack down on the deceptive and perhaps illegal practice of spending taxpayer money for political campaigns, but it continues.

It was once said, allegedly by Benjamin Franklin, that nothing is certain but death and taxes. In California, it’s also certain that we will continue to battle over tax limits.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

 

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Water News: Pact Secures Federal Money for Dam Raise, Promotions at Westlands

DON'T MISS

Israel’s Cabinet Approves Deal for Gaza Ceasefire, Hostage Release

DON'T MISS

Attorneys Say Utility May Have Destroyed Evidence of What Caused Deadly LA-Area Fire

DON'T MISS

Prized Japanese Pitcher Roki Sasaki Says He’ll Sign With Dodgers

DON'T MISS

Mayor Dyer and Valley Congressmen Will Attend Trump Inauguration

DON'T MISS

Walmart Breaks into Luxury Resale Market, Will Offer Chanel, Fendi, Prada, Other Brands

DON'T MISS

Voices for Justice: Diverse Figures Unite in Support of Palestine

DON'T MISS

Israel’s Full Cabinet Meets on Gaza Ceasefire Deal After Security Cabinet Recommends Approval

DON'T MISS

Merced County Leads California in Bird Flu Cases, Ranks Third Nationally

DON'T MISS

Serial Felon Gets 15 Years for Tulare County Catalytic Converter Thefts

UP NEXT

California Housing Crisis Will Get Worse as LA Fires Destroy Homes

UP NEXT

Gov. Newsom, Mayor Bass Targeted in Wildfire Witch Hunt

UP NEXT

As Crazy as It Sounds, Trump’s Approach to Foreign Policy Could Work

UP NEXT

The Biden Presidency: Four Illusions, Four Deceptions

UP NEXT

Can Democrats Be the Party of the Future Again?

UP NEXT

California’s Battle Over Taxing Multinational Corporations Heats Up Again

UP NEXT

Promises to Cut CA’s High Living Costs Clash With Progressive Policies

UP NEXT

If CA Wants to Lead on AI, It Can’t Let 3 Companies Hog the Infrastructure

UP NEXT

Even MAGA Needs Immigrants, It Seems

UP NEXT

Absent Reforms, Progressive Governance May Disappear Across the Globe

Prized Japanese Pitcher Roki Sasaki Says He’ll Sign With Dodgers

5 hours ago

Mayor Dyer and Valley Congressmen Will Attend Trump Inauguration

5 hours ago

Walmart Breaks into Luxury Resale Market, Will Offer Chanel, Fendi, Prada, Other Brands

6 hours ago

Voices for Justice: Diverse Figures Unite in Support of Palestine

6 hours ago

Israel’s Full Cabinet Meets on Gaza Ceasefire Deal After Security Cabinet Recommends Approval

6 hours ago

Merced County Leads California in Bird Flu Cases, Ranks Third Nationally

6 hours ago

Serial Felon Gets 15 Years for Tulare County Catalytic Converter Thefts

7 hours ago

Senate Advances Migrant Detention Bill That Could Be Trump’s First Law to Sign

9 hours ago

A Rebranded Women’s March Returns Before Trump’s Inauguration

9 hours ago

Pickleball Player? Sierra Pacific Docs Explain How to Stay Safe on the Court

9 hours ago

Water News: Pact Secures Federal Money for Dam Raise, Promotions at Westlands

As the federal government and the San Luis and Delta-Mendota Water Authority reached a cost-sharing agreement to raise the B.F. Sisk Dam, se...

4 hours ago

4 hours ago

Water News: Pact Secures Federal Money for Dam Raise, Promotions at Westlands

4 hours ago

Israel’s Cabinet Approves Deal for Gaza Ceasefire, Hostage Release

4 hours ago

Attorneys Say Utility May Have Destroyed Evidence of What Caused Deadly LA-Area Fire

Roki Sasaki Signs With Dodgers
5 hours ago

Prized Japanese Pitcher Roki Sasaki Says He’ll Sign With Dodgers

5 hours ago

Mayor Dyer and Valley Congressmen Will Attend Trump Inauguration

6 hours ago

Walmart Breaks into Luxury Resale Market, Will Offer Chanel, Fendi, Prada, Other Brands

6 hours ago

Voices for Justice: Diverse Figures Unite in Support of Palestine

6 hours ago

Israel’s Full Cabinet Meets on Gaza Ceasefire Deal After Security Cabinet Recommends Approval

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend