Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Housing Factions Use Two State Laws as Weapons
By admin
Published 2 years ago on
August 10, 2022

Share

 

Down in the trenches of California’s seemingly perpetual clashes over housing, warring factions are employing two decades-old state laws as weapons.

One is the famous — or infamous — California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), signed by then-Gov. Ronald Reagan in 1970, that requires authorities to determine whether proposed developments have environmental impacts that must be mitigated.

The other, much less known, is the California Housing Accountability Act (HAA), signed by Reagan’s successor, Jerry Brown, in 1982 to prevent local governments from rejecting housing projects without good reason.

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Those who oppose specific developments, particularly high-density apartments for low- and moderate-income families, often invoke CEQA, claiming they have negative impacts on the environments of their communities, such as increased traffic.

Construction unions also employ CEQA, threatening to use its provisions to delay or kill projects unless developers agree to use union labor.

In response, housing advocates, including project developers, invoke the HAA, accusing opponents of violating its pro-housing provisions, which have been strengthened in recent years, and filing lawsuits or complaining to the state housing agency.

The housing conflicts have been particularly sharp in San Francisco, whose left-of-center Democratic politicians are often starkly divided by housing issues. Last year, their incessant squabbling manifested itself in a confrontation over a 27-story, 495-unit apartment building proposed for a former department store parking lot.

After years of wrangling and modifications, the project at 469 Stevenson Street received CEQA clearance from the city’s planning commission, but San Francisco’s governing legislative body, the Board of Supervisors, voted 8-3 to overturn the commission action, agreeing with project opponents that it had potentially severe environmental impacts.

The state Department of Housing and Community Development took an immediate interest, opening an investigation and sending a letter to the city, saying the board’s rejection of the project for “various vague concerns” could put it in violation of the Housing Accountability Act.

The board’s reversal was particularly galling to San Francisco’s state legislators, who have been particularly aggressive advocates of pro-housing policies. “When San Francisco acts like this, it sends a very negative message to the rest of the region,” state Sen. Scott Wiener told the San Francisco Chronicle. “We have been pushing other cities to do their share, to be better, so when San Francisco does something like this, it puts the proverbial turd in the punch bowl.”

The dustup over 469 Stevenson had another impact. Assemblyman Phil Ting, a San Francisco Democrat, introduced legislation that, if enacted, would make it more difficult for opponents of projects to use CEQA and easier for proponents to invoke HAA.

The measure, Assembly Bill 2656, zipped through the Assembly on a strongly bipartisan vote and is awaiting action in the Senate. It also enjoys support from dozens of pro-housing organizations, while environmental groups and construction unions are opposed because it would make CEQA a less potent tool.

A Senate analysis of the bill frames its effect on the growing conflict between the two laws, saying it puts local governments between “a rock and a hard place” with “conflicting mandates to approve new housing under the HAA, but to simultaneously adequately account for the environmental impacts of housing under CEQA.”

That’s quite accurate, and it once again indicates that it’s high time for Gov. Gavin Newsom and the Legislature to comprehensively overhaul CEQA, whose original purpose of protecting natural resources has been distorted beyond recognition.

Former Gov. Jerry Brown once called CEQA reform “the Lord’s work,” but was never willing to undertake the heavy lifting it would require.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

 

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

As the Flag Drops at Le Mans, Remembering the 3 Americans Who Won in 1978

DON'T MISS

Paw-sitively Spikey: The Rise of a Supermutt!

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Deals Blow to Environmental Law Relied on by Housing Opponents

DON'T MISS

The Latest | Hezbollah Says Its Intensified Attacks Show Israel That All-out War Would Be Costly

DON'T MISS

Alex Jones’ Assets Sold to Pay Sandy Hook Debt as Infowars’ Fate Decided

DON'T MISS

California Senate Passes Ban on Schools Notifying Parents of Child’s Pronoun Changes

DON'T MISS

Cal State LA President Bars Pro-Palestinian Protesters After Building Takeover

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Overturns Trump-Era Bump Stock Ban, Reigniting Political Debate

DON'T MISS

Trump’s 78th Birthday Showcases Loyalty from Fans and Republicans

DON'T MISS

California Legislators Break with Gov. Newsom Over Loan to Keep Last Nuclear Plant Running

UP NEXT

What’s the Value of a Fresno Unified Diploma When These ‘Classes’ Are as Easy as A-B-C?

UP NEXT

As Californians’ Stance on Crime Hardens, Republicans Try to Regain Relevance

UP NEXT

What the Heck?! George Lopez’s Abrupt Exit Illuminates the Dark Side of Heckling

UP NEXT

California Restaurants Want an Exemption from State’s New Hidden Fees Law

UP NEXT

‘Boss’ Trump Should Go to Prison: Opinion

UP NEXT

High School Free Speech Controversy Jogs Memories of My Start in Journalism: Dan Walters

UP NEXT

California Seeks a More Resilient Water Supply as Familiar Sides Battle for Access

UP NEXT

Homelessness Funding on the Chopping Block. Will It Make the Final CA Budget?

UP NEXT

Summer Pro Wrestling Book List: ‘Six Pack’ and Jim Ross Bio

UP NEXT

Why California Regulators Have to Protect Both Consumers and Company Profits

The Latest | Hezbollah Says Its Intensified Attacks Show Israel That All-out War Would Be Costly

3 hours ago

Alex Jones’ Assets Sold to Pay Sandy Hook Debt as Infowars’ Fate Decided

4 hours ago

California Senate Passes Ban on Schools Notifying Parents of Child’s Pronoun Changes

4 hours ago

Cal State LA President Bars Pro-Palestinian Protesters After Building Takeover

5 hours ago

Supreme Court Overturns Trump-Era Bump Stock Ban, Reigniting Political Debate

5 hours ago

Trump’s 78th Birthday Showcases Loyalty from Fans and Republicans

5 hours ago

California Legislators Break with Gov. Newsom Over Loan to Keep Last Nuclear Plant Running

5 hours ago

After Bitwise: Many Employees Need to Enhance Skills to Match Their Old Salaries

5 hours ago

California’s Manure-to-Fuel Solution Grows, Critics Warn of Community Risks

5 hours ago

QB Trevor Lawrence and the Jaguars Agree to a 5-Year, $275M Contract Extension

5 hours ago

As the Flag Drops at Le Mans, Remembering the 3 Americans Who Won in 1978

OK, let’s set the way-back machine to 1978. The disco ball was still spinning, Star Wars was blowing our minds, and in the quiet town of Sar...

7 mins ago

1978 Le Mans: 3 Americans in France
7 mins ago

As the Flag Drops at Le Mans, Remembering the 3 Americans Who Won in 1978

2 hours ago

Paw-sitively Spikey: The Rise of a Supermutt!

3 hours ago

Supreme Court Deals Blow to Environmental Law Relied on by Housing Opponents

3 hours ago

The Latest | Hezbollah Says Its Intensified Attacks Show Israel That All-out War Would Be Costly

4 hours ago

Alex Jones’ Assets Sold to Pay Sandy Hook Debt as Infowars’ Fate Decided

4 hours ago

California Senate Passes Ban on Schools Notifying Parents of Child’s Pronoun Changes

5 hours ago

Cal State LA President Bars Pro-Palestinian Protesters After Building Takeover

5 hours ago

Supreme Court Overturns Trump-Era Bump Stock Ban, Reigniting Political Debate

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend