Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Will California Buy Out Farmers to Save Water? Lawmakers Mull the Possibility
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 2 years ago on
June 6, 2022

Share

 

SACRAMENTO— After decades of fighting farmers in court over how much water they can take out of California’s rivers and streams, some state lawmakers want to try something different: use taxpayer money to buy out farmers.

Tom Birmingham Westlands

The idea “makes an awful lot of sense” because “it is a means by which conflict can be avoided.” — Tom Birmingham, general manager of Westlands Water District

A proposal in the state Senate would spend up to $1.5 billion to buy “senior water rights” that allow farmers to take as much water as needed from the state’s rivers and streams to grow their crops. If state officials owned those rights, they could leave the water in the rivers to benefit endangered species of salmon and other fish.

California has been mired in drought for most of the last two decades, prompting intense scrutiny of the state’s complex water system and how it might be modified to ensure steady supplies during exceptionally dry periods — including a separate state proposal that would pay farmers to grow fewer crops to save water.

98% of the State Is in Severe Drought

Current readings show about 98% of the state has severe drought conditions as California heads into summer months that rarely produce any significant precipitation. Many areas have begun restricting water use for homeowners, largely by reducing outdoor use such as lawn irrigation. And farmers have had their allocation from the two major state-owned water systems reduced — in some cases down to zero.

Legally, all of the water in California is the property of the government. But farmers have “water rights” that let them take water for agriculture. Farmers have used those rights — governed by a complicated system based on seniority and other factors — to turn California’s Central Valley into an agricultural powerhouse that provides much of the nation’s fruits, nuts, and vegetables.

But siphoning off all that water also has disrupted the fragile ecosystem of the San Joaquin/Sacramento river delta, the largest estuary on the West Coast and home to endangered salmon and other fish. Environmental groups and farmers have battled for years over state and federal rules governing just how much water can be diverted for agriculture, which uses far more water than any other sector of the economy.

Democrats Pitch Spending $1.5 Billion to Buy Water Rights

Now, with California having a record budget surplus of nearly $100 billion, Democrats in the state Senate have proposed using up to $1.5 billion to buy senior water rights — by either buying the land associated with the rights, buying just the right itself, or putting an easement on the land that requires the water to be used for fish and other fauna and flora.

The proposal is part of budget negotiations between lawmakers and Gov. Gavin Newsom’s administration that should wrap up by the end of this month.

“It’s like we’re taking a page from corporate America and we’re buying back stock,” said state Sen. Bob Wieckowski, a Democrat who represents the San Francisco Bay Area and is chair of a budget subcommittee overseeing environmental spending.

While $1.5 billion sounds like a lot of money, it wouldn’t buy that much water. Regulators measure water by “acre-foot,” defined as enough water to cover 1 acre of land to a depth of 1 foot. That’s the equivalent of 325,851 gallons.

A typical household uses 1 acre-foot of water each year. Farmers collectively use up to 35 million acre-feet of water each year, according to the Water Education Foundation.

Westlands CEO Says Proposal Makes Sense

The $1.5 billion would be enough to buy about 200,000-acre feet of water, based on an average price of $7,500 per acre-foot, according to Tom Birmingham, general manager of Westlands Water District, the largest agricultural water district in the country.

Still, Birmingham says the idea “makes an awful lot of sense” because “it is a means by which conflict can be avoided.”

Right now, the only way to get more water flowing in rivers and streams is to get state and federal regulators to change the rules. They can do that by requiring more water be left in rivers and streams, but that means less water for farmers. Those rule changes often prompt lawsuits, which can take a decade or longer to resolve, said Lester Snow, a former secretary of the California Natural Resources Agency and regional director of the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation.

“We need a way to take much quicker action. And I think acquiring water rights for that purpose is one of the ways to do that,” he said. “With climate change, we just don’t have that kind of time.”

Selling Water Rights Would Be Voluntary

For this to work, farmers would have to voluntarily sell their valuable water rights — something Birmingham says shouldn’t be a problem. Lots of farmers try to sell their water rights to Westlands Water District every year, Birmingham said.

“For many farmers … their children simply are not interested in continuing to farm,” Birmingham said.

But state Sen. Brian Dahle, a Republican running for governor whose family has been farming in California for 92 years, said the only reason farmers would be willing to sell is because state officials are driving them out of business with burdensome regulations.

“This makes my blood boil. It’s ridiculous,” Dahle told his colleagues during a legislative hearing on the proposal. “You are forcing them into a corner where they have no other option.”

‘Devil Is in the Details’

John McManus, executive director of the Golden State Salmon Association, said as with any legislative proposal “the devil will be in the details.” He said he’d want to see rules that make sure any additional water purchased by the state will remain in the rivers and not be removed by someone else with water rights farther downstream.

But he is hopeful the program will work because he said there are about six native fish species that are “on life support right now because we don’t have enough water flowing through the Delta.”

“So anything that can be done to address that problem is appreciated,” he said.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Fresno Has Plan and a Firm to Pick New Police Chief. Public Input Sought.

DON'T MISS

Sanger Police Investigate Fatal Shooting

DON'T MISS

California Pledged $500 Million to Help Tenants Preserve Affordable Housing. They Didn’t Get a Dime.

DON'T MISS

Damage To Tropicana Field After Hurricane Milton

DON'T MISS

Israeli Strikes in Beirut Leave 22 Dead, Targeted Hezbollah Official Escapes

DON'T MISS

Tropicana Field Shredded by Hurricane Milton Is the Latest Sports Venue Damaged by Weather

DON'T MISS

22 People Killed and 117 Wounded in Israeli Airstrikes in Beirut, Lebanon Says

DON'T MISS

$20K Reward Offered After Sea Lion Found With Fatal Gunshot Wound on California Beach

DON'T MISS

TD Bank to Pay $3 Billion in Historic Money-Laundering Settlement With the Justice Department

DON'T MISS

Darius Assemi Says No to New $500 Million Tax

UP NEXT

Sanger Police Investigate Fatal Shooting

UP NEXT

California Pledged $500 Million to Help Tenants Preserve Affordable Housing. They Didn’t Get a Dime.

UP NEXT

Damage To Tropicana Field After Hurricane Milton

UP NEXT

Israeli Strikes in Beirut Leave 22 Dead, Targeted Hezbollah Official Escapes

UP NEXT

Tropicana Field Shredded by Hurricane Milton Is the Latest Sports Venue Damaged by Weather

UP NEXT

22 People Killed and 117 Wounded in Israeli Airstrikes in Beirut, Lebanon Says

UP NEXT

$20K Reward Offered After Sea Lion Found With Fatal Gunshot Wound on California Beach

UP NEXT

TD Bank to Pay $3 Billion in Historic Money-Laundering Settlement With the Justice Department

UP NEXT

Darius Assemi Says No to New $500 Million Tax

UP NEXT

City Will Plant New Trees Free of Charge for Fresno Residents

Damage To Tropicana Field After Hurricane Milton

11 hours ago

Israeli Strikes in Beirut Leave 22 Dead, Targeted Hezbollah Official Escapes

11 hours ago

Tropicana Field Shredded by Hurricane Milton Is the Latest Sports Venue Damaged by Weather

11 hours ago

22 People Killed and 117 Wounded in Israeli Airstrikes in Beirut, Lebanon Says

11 hours ago

$20K Reward Offered After Sea Lion Found With Fatal Gunshot Wound on California Beach

11 hours ago

TD Bank to Pay $3 Billion in Historic Money-Laundering Settlement With the Justice Department

11 hours ago

Darius Assemi Says No to New $500 Million Tax

12 hours ago

City Will Plant New Trees Free of Charge for Fresno Residents

12 hours ago

After UNLV Blowout Loss, Skipper Says Bulldogs Are ‘Playing for Ourselves’

13 hours ago

Tulare County Man Arrested for Drive-by Shooting

14 hours ago

Fresno Has Plan and a Firm to Pick New Police Chief. Public Input Sought.

The city of Fresno has found a firm to conduct its search for the next police chief, and it will soon reach out to the public for input. Se...

9 hours ago

9 hours ago

Fresno Has Plan and a Firm to Pick New Police Chief. Public Input Sought.

10 hours ago

Sanger Police Investigate Fatal Shooting

11 hours ago

California Pledged $500 Million to Help Tenants Preserve Affordable Housing. They Didn’t Get a Dime.

11 hours ago

Damage To Tropicana Field After Hurricane Milton

11 hours ago

Israeli Strikes in Beirut Leave 22 Dead, Targeted Hezbollah Official Escapes

11 hours ago

Tropicana Field Shredded by Hurricane Milton Is the Latest Sports Venue Damaged by Weather

11 hours ago

22 People Killed and 117 Wounded in Israeli Airstrikes in Beirut, Lebanon Says

11 hours ago

$20K Reward Offered After Sea Lion Found With Fatal Gunshot Wound on California Beach

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend