Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Incentives Build More Affordable Homes Than Inclusionary Zoning: Opinion
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 2 years ago on
May 17, 2022

Share

 

California lacks an estimated 1.2 million units of housing affordable for those with lower incomes. One important approach to meeting this need is to induce developers to include affordable units in market-rate multifamily housing developments. Policies concerned with this outcome are commonly called “inclusionary zoning.”

Jason Ward portrait

Jason Ward

Opinion

Special to CalMatters

Such policies take two forms: mandates requiring the inclusion of such units (deed-restricted units that must be offered to eligible households at below-market rents, often for 55 years or more) in any new development, or voluntary incentives rewarding the inclusion of such units with increased density allowances (more apartments in a given development), reduced or eliminated parking requirements, and other offsets for the reduced revenue a project can generate when including affordable units.

Recent evidence from Los Angeles suggests that voluntary incentives foster increased production of affordable housing, while mandates alone increase the cost of producing housing, dampening both market-rate and affordable housing production. In 2016, Los Angeles created a natural experiment comparing these approaches when voters passed Measure JJJ, a ballot initiative that created two approval pathways for new housing developments:

Mandatory component: For projects using a zoning change or a general plan amendment, JJJ required specified shares of affordable units or an in-lieu payment of $50,000 to $100,000 per apartment.

Voluntary incentives component: JJJ’s voluntary component (called “transit-oriented communities”) targeted projects located near transit hubs, offering a menu of incentives that increased with the share of affordable units built. The most significant of these was a large increase in allowable density (up to 80%).

An additional goal of JJJ was to have developers hire locally and pay union-level wages. Again, the mandatory path required this, while the transit-oriented program rewarded developers for voluntarily adopting these measures.

Incentives vs. Inclusionary Zoning Results in LA

When JJJ was put before voters in November 2016, the mandatory component was spelled out, but the voluntary component was not finalized; these incentives would be settled on after the measure passed. In the six months before the election, developers rushed to apply for construction permits at three times the average rate of the past two years to avoid the mandatory requirements, according to a 2019 report.

When the transit-oriented program launched in 2017, it rapidly became the single-largest approval pathway for new housing. Last year, 33% of all proposed housing units citywide used the program, despite the fact that only around 9% of the city’s land is eligible for the maximum incentives. Another 23% followed a similar but less generous citywide voluntary incentive pathway (a density bonus program). Only 1% used the citywide pathways covered by the mandatory inclusionary zoning component.

And how many affordable units were produced? At the end of 2019 (the most recent data available from the city):

  • 294 affordable apartments were permitted under the transit-oriented program.
  • 219 using the density bonus program.
  • And, 11 units through inclusionary zoning.

Granted, these numbers are a drop in the bucket relative to Los Angeles’ staggering housing needs. Even turbocharged incentive programs may be insufficient to meet California’s need for affordable housing, but such an approach likely represents our best chance to move the needle.

Incentives Produce 4 Times as Much Affordable Housing in NY

New York City has had a similar experience. The city has two inclusionary zoning programs to foster affordable housing production: one a mandatory program introduced in 2016, and the other, a voluntary program already in place.

Between 2016 and 2019, around 2,000 affordable units were permitted through the mandatory program, primarily in lower-income neighborhoods and often requiring additional public subsidies.

Over roughly the same period, more than 8,000 units were permitted through the existing voluntary, incentive-based program across a much broader socioeconomic range of neighborhoods.

Despite this and other evidence, mandatory inclusionary zoning remains popular among policymakers. Mandatory policies are in place in San Francisco, San Diego, San Jose, and elsewhere in California. Four candidates for L.A. mayor have endorsed the idea of requiring all new housing developments to include affordable units. Los Angeles is studying the feasibility of an inclusionary zoning mandate citywide.

It is well past time to acknowledge the evidence and focus on the adoption of voluntary programs that incentivize the rapid creation of dense, infill housing available at both affordable and market rents. Both types of housing are sorely needed to ensure a livable and prosperous future for California.

About the Author

Jason Ward is an associate economist at the RAND Corporation and associate director of the RAND Center on Housing and Homelessness in Los Angeles.

About CalMatters

CalMatters is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom committed to explaining California policy and politics.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

A Fresno Edition of Monopoly? That’s Capitalism at Work, Baby!

DON'T MISS

California Officials Sue Huntington Beach Over Voter ID Law Passed at Polls

DON'T MISS

Indiana Fever Receives No. 1 Overall Draft Pick Caitlin Clark

DON'T MISS

Which Fresno Restaurants Are Best? The Pros Picked These Places.

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Historic Hush-Money Trial Gets Underway; 1st Day Ends Without Any Jurors Being Picked

DON'T MISS

Fresno-Madera United Way Launches National Search for New CEO

DON'T MISS

Justice Thomas Misses Supreme Court Session Monday With No Explanation

DON'T MISS

‘Civil War’ Declares Victory at the Box Office, Toppling ‘Godzilla X Kong’

DON'T MISS

Why Tortillas Sold in California May Be Forced to Add a New Ingredient

DON'T MISS

Costco Tries Again at City Council for Big NW Fresno Move

UP NEXT

Indiana Fever Receives No. 1 Overall Draft Pick Caitlin Clark

UP NEXT

Which Fresno Restaurants Are Best? The Pros Picked These Places.

UP NEXT

Fresno-Madera United Way Launches National Search for New CEO

UP NEXT

Justice Thomas Misses Supreme Court Session Monday With No Explanation

UP NEXT

‘Civil War’ Declares Victory at the Box Office, Toppling ‘Godzilla X Kong’

UP NEXT

Why Tortillas Sold in California May Be Forced to Add a New Ingredient

UP NEXT

Costco Tries Again at City Council for Big NW Fresno Move

UP NEXT

Scheffler Turns the Masters Into Another Sunday Yawner With a Dominating Win

UP NEXT

Ethiopia’s Lemma Wins, Fresno’s Albertson 7th in Boston Marathon. Kenya’s Obiri Retains Women Title.

UP NEXT

Vegas, US Tour and More Signings: Wrexham Has Plenty of Fun and Work Ahead After Latest Promotion

Which Fresno Restaurants Are Best? The Pros Picked These Places.

3 hours ago

Trump’s Historic Hush-Money Trial Gets Underway; 1st Day Ends Without Any Jurors Being Picked

3 hours ago

Fresno-Madera United Way Launches National Search for New CEO

Local /

4 hours ago

Justice Thomas Misses Supreme Court Session Monday With No Explanation

4 hours ago

‘Civil War’ Declares Victory at the Box Office, Toppling ‘Godzilla X Kong’

5 hours ago

Why Tortillas Sold in California May Be Forced to Add a New Ingredient

5 hours ago

Costco Tries Again at City Council for Big NW Fresno Move

6 hours ago

Scheffler Turns the Masters Into Another Sunday Yawner With a Dominating Win

6 hours ago

Ethiopia’s Lemma Wins, Fresno’s Albertson 7th in Boston Marathon. Kenya’s Obiri Retains Women Title.

6 hours ago

Vegas, US Tour and More Signings: Wrexham Has Plenty of Fun and Work Ahead After Latest Promotion

7 hours ago

A Fresno Edition of Monopoly? That’s Capitalism at Work, Baby!

Alright, cats and kittens, straphang onto your beanies because I’m about to lay a news flash on you that’s so whimsically wild it coul...

2 hours ago

Fresno Monopoly Edition
2 hours ago

A Fresno Edition of Monopoly? That’s Capitalism at Work, Baby!

2 hours ago

California Officials Sue Huntington Beach Over Voter ID Law Passed at Polls

2 hours ago

Indiana Fever Receives No. 1 Overall Draft Pick Caitlin Clark

3 hours ago

Which Fresno Restaurants Are Best? The Pros Picked These Places.

3 hours ago

Trump’s Historic Hush-Money Trial Gets Underway; 1st Day Ends Without Any Jurors Being Picked

Local /
4 hours ago

Fresno-Madera United Way Launches National Search for New CEO

4 hours ago

Justice Thomas Misses Supreme Court Session Monday With No Explanation

5 hours ago

‘Civil War’ Declares Victory at the Box Office, Toppling ‘Godzilla X Kong’

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend