Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California’s Messier, but Fairer, Redistricting Process
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 3 years ago on
November 15, 2021

Share

For many decades, the decennial chore of redrawing California’s congressional and legislative districts was relatively simple.

Dan Walters

Opinion

Every 10 years, following the census, legislative and congressional leaders would hire some knowledgeable number-crunchers and privately divvy up the districts for purely political purposes.

If one party controlled both the Legislature and the governorship, it would maximize its ability to remain in power. The maps that the dominant Democrats drew up after the 1980 census was the last time California saw a blatantly partisan gerrymander.

Republicans howled and persuaded voters to overturn the plan via a referendum, but the state Supreme Court ordered that the rejected maps be used anyway for the 1982 elections, in which Democrats retained their control of the Legislature and the congressional delegation.

Assembly Speaker Willie Brown publicly thanked “Sister Rose and the Supremes” for helping his party overcome the referendum, referring to Chief Justice Rose Bird. It fueled a successful drive to oust Bird and two other justices when they stood for re-election four years later.

Redrawn Districts Favored Democrats

After the 1982 election, Democrats enacted a slightly altered version of the gerrymander and then-Gov. Jerry Brown signed it just before leaving office. The congressional map was particularly slanted toward Democrats and its primary creator, San Francisco Congressman Phil Burton, laconically called it “my contribution to modern art.”

Control of redistricting was the primary, if unspoken, issue of the 1990 campaign for governor, and after Republican Pete Wilson won he vetoed a new set of maps drawn by Democrats, throwing the issue into the state Supreme Court. The court generated maps of its own that allowed the Republicans to make some gains in the 1992 and 1994 elections.

Democrats once again controlled the Legislature and the governorship after the 2000 census, but a partisan gerrymander was blunted by other factors, including an implicit threat of intervention by the U.S. Department of Justice under President George W. Bush.

The upshot was a bipartisan gerrymander aimed at protecting all incumbents and preserving the partisan status quo in both the Legislature and Congress, while ignoring dramatic demographic shifts, including a big surge in Latino population.

Independent Commission Created

Overt gerrymandering ended a decade later, after voters approved two initiatives — hated by leaders of both parties — to shift the decennial mapmaking to an independent commission that would ignore partisan considerations, draw districts to follow, where possible, city and county boundaries and preserve “communities of interest.”

On the whole, the commission was faithful to its mission, but nevertheless, Democrats made big gains in congressional and legislative seats — eventually winning three-fourths of both as GOP voter strengthen plummeted.

With data from a new census — much delayed due to the COVID-19 pandemic — a new commission is working on new maps under a very tight deadline. It’s been a rather messy process — a “hot mess,” in the recent words of one commission member. Drafts of the new maps were released last week and it’s apparent that they are likely to change quite a bit before the Dec. 27 deadline.

That said, it’s obvious that Democrats will retain their overwhelming legislative and congressional supermajorities and could gain a few more seats simply because demographic trends continue to run their way.

Most of the uncertainty is in the 52 congressional districts — one fewer than before due to California’s slow population growth. Democrats are struggling to retain their paper-thin control of Congress, and a handful of toss-up seats in California could be the difference.

However, until the final maps are filed six weeks hence, no one can truly predict who will survive and whose careers will end.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of them working for California newspapers. He now writes for CalMatters, a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters.  For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Who Is Making a Difference in Fresno? Explore This List of 2024’s Shining Stars

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Tossed by Northern Illinois in Idaho Potato Bowl

DON'T MISS

2 Rescued After Santa Cruz Wharf Partially Collapses Due to Heavy Surf From Major Pacific Storm

DON'T MISS

Spain Faces Threats of Terrorism and Unrest, US Warns in Travel Advisory

DON'T MISS

Bill Clinton Is Hospitalized With a Fever but in Good Spirits, Spokesperson Says

DON'T MISS

Media Relations Expert Leaves City Hall for Valley Children’s Hospital

DON'T MISS

Amar Augillard Departs the Fresno State Basketball Team

DON'T MISS

Former Bulldog QB Mikey Keene Commits to Michigan

DON'T MISS

Thunderstorms on Christmas Eve? They’re in the Fresno Forecast

DON'T MISS

SE Fresno Voters Have Their Pick of Familiar Candidates to Succeed Chavez

UP NEXT

The Surprising Sexual Politics of Nicole Kidman’s Kinky ‘Babygirl’

UP NEXT

Tax Loopholes Cost California and Its Cities $107 Billion but Get Little Scrutiny

UP NEXT

24 for 24

UP NEXT

Did You Know Fresno County Doesn’t Have a Tax Assessor?

UP NEXT

Congress Can Give Us Clean Affordable Energy in 2025

UP NEXT

He Has Prison in His Past. Now He Hopes Law School Is in His Future

UP NEXT

Can New State Regs Resolve California’s Property Insurance Crisis?

UP NEXT

The First New Foreign Policy Challenge for Trump Just Became Clear

UP NEXT

Brian Thompson, Not Luigi Mangione, Is the Real Working-Class Hero

UP NEXT

Why CA Needs to Double-Down on Its Apprenticeship Programs

Spain Faces Threats of Terrorism and Unrest, US Warns in Travel Advisory

1 hour ago

Bill Clinton Is Hospitalized With a Fever but in Good Spirits, Spokesperson Says

1 hour ago

Media Relations Expert Leaves City Hall for Valley Children’s Hospital

2 hours ago

Amar Augillard Departs the Fresno State Basketball Team

2 hours ago

Former Bulldog QB Mikey Keene Commits to Michigan

3 hours ago

Thunderstorms on Christmas Eve? They’re in the Fresno Forecast

3 hours ago

SE Fresno Voters Have Their Pick of Familiar Candidates to Succeed Chavez

4 hours ago

Fresno Residents Will Get an Extra Day to Put Out the Trash

4 hours ago

Top Arab Diplomats, in Syria Visits, Aim to Build Ties With New Leadership

4 hours ago

Middle East Latest: Israeli Airstrikes on Gaza Kill at Least 20 People, Palestinian Medics Say

4 hours ago

Who Is Making a Difference in Fresno? Explore This List of 2024’s Shining Stars

Two of the biggest challenges facing our city are domestic violence and the decades-long struggles to improve student achievement in Fresno ...

6 minutes ago

6 minutes ago

Who Is Making a Difference in Fresno? Explore This List of 2024’s Shining Stars

10 minutes ago

Fresno State Tossed by Northern Illinois in Idaho Potato Bowl

A closed wharf is seen in Santa Cruz, Calif., Monday, Dec. 23, 2024, after the pier partially collapsed and fell into the ocean. (AP/Martha Mendoza)
39 minutes ago

2 Rescued After Santa Cruz Wharf Partially Collapses Due to Heavy Surf From Major Pacific Storm

1 hour ago

Spain Faces Threats of Terrorism and Unrest, US Warns in Travel Advisory

1 hour ago

Bill Clinton Is Hospitalized With a Fever but in Good Spirits, Spokesperson Says

2 hours ago

Media Relations Expert Leaves City Hall for Valley Children’s Hospital

2 hours ago

Amar Augillard Departs the Fresno State Basketball Team

3 hours ago

Former Bulldog QB Mikey Keene Commits to Michigan

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend