Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Newsom Scores Big Recall Win. What Now?
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 4 years ago on
September 15, 2021

Share

Well, that was one for the history books. In the space of two decades, California voters recalled one Democratic governor and refused to recall another.

Voting had scarcely ended at 8 p.m. Tuesday before major news organizations declared that Gov. Gavin Newsom had handily turned back what had once appeared to be a viable drive to oust him from office.

“We are enjoying an overwhelming ‘no’ vote tonight here in the state of California,” Newsom told cheering supporters in Sacramento. “But ‘no’ was not the only thing that was expressed tonight. I want to focus on what we said ‘yes’ to as a state. We said ‘yes’ to science, ‘yes’ to vaccines, we said ‘yes’ to ending this pandemic.”

“We said yes to diversity, we said yes to inclusion, we said yes to pluralism. We said yes to all those things that we hold dear as Californians, and I would argue, as Americans,” the governor added.

Newsom Wins With Large Margin Despite Earlier Polls

Dan Walters

Opinion

By early Wednesday, Newsom had drawn support from nearly 64% of those who voted, a couple of points higher than his landslide 2018 win. Republican talk show host Larry Elder easily bested the field of would-be replacements, which itself was a win of sorts for Newsom.

Just weeks earlier, polls had indicated that Newsom was in serious danger of losing due to scant interest among his fellow Democrats. However, Elder’s entry was a godsend, giving Newsom a polarizing rival he could use to boost Democratic turnout.

Suddenly, media coverage of the recall shifted from Newsom’s managerial headaches and his personal conduct — the infamous unmasked dinner in Napa, especially — to Elder’s unleavened opposition to just about every thing held dear by the state’s dominant Democrats.

The strategy, aided by tens of millions of dollars in campaign spending and drop-ins by national party figures, including President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris, worked brilliantly.

The Push to ‘Fix a Broken Recall System’

So what now?

Democratic legislative leaders immediately declared their “plans to fix a broken recall system,” which would mean making recalls more difficult, or perhaps nearly impossible, and thus protecting officeholders at all levels.

Such “reforms” would require a statewide vote to amend the constitution, either proposed by the Legislature or via initiative petition. Given the Democrats’ huge advantage in voter registration, changing the recall system is a strong possibility, perhaps as soon as next year’s November election.

Newsom himself will be up for re-election next year and his landslide win in the recall indicates he will have an easy time of it — unless, of course, he does something to undermine himself. He should keep in mind that his own conduct and demeanor were catalysts for the drive to oust him.

Newsom Still Has a Long Way to Go for His Critics

To many, he comes across as arrogant — the Napa dinner being a prime, but not isolated, example — and much too insistent on having his way “whether you like it or not.” He uttered those words when, as mayor of San Francisco, he brushed aside California law by issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples, claiming a larger moral imperative.

As governor, he continued that attitude by unilaterally suspending executions of murderers despite a clear statewide vote to retain the death penalty.

Newsom should remember that millions of Californians, especially those in the state’s outer ring of rural counties, think he’s a bad man who has been a bad governor. He can continue to ignore and alienate those in the outback or he can try to include them as he pursues his self-proclaimed “California for All” governorship.

A little genuine humility would serve Newsom — and the state — well.

CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

[activecampaign form=31]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

New CA Fire Maps Will Change How Some Valley Homes Are Built

DON'T MISS

Social Security Administration to Require In-Person Identity Checks for Recipients

DON'T MISS

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Jarrett Steven Huddleston

DON'T MISS

Legal Showdown as Justice Department Clashes with Judge Over Deportation Flight Details

DON'T MISS

Where Are Convicted Bitwise CEOs Serving Their Prison Terms?

DON'T MISS

Ohtani Hits Solo HR in Return to Japan as Dodgers Sweep Cubs

DON'T MISS

Violent Attacks on Tesla Dealerships Spike as Musk Joins Trump Administration

DON'T MISS

Judge Says Khalil’s Deportation Case Can Be Heard in New Jersey

DON'T MISS

Zelenskyy Disputes Putin’s Vow Not to Hit Ukraine’s Energy Infrastructure

DON'T MISS

Canada Bolsters Arctic Defenses as Trump Sets His Sights North

UP NEXT

Democracy Is on the Line in Israel and America Right Now

UP NEXT

Playing Political Whac-A-Mole As Issue Of Bond Measure Language Pops Up Again

UP NEXT

Don’t Listen to Critics. SJ River Conservancy Is Doing Its Job

UP NEXT

Trump Administration’s Attacks on Higher Education Threaten US Global Dominance in Science

UP NEXT

Starvation Is Not a Negotiating Tactic

UP NEXT

California Doesn’t Need DOGE, but There’s Plenty of Wasteful Spending and Bureaucracy to Cut

UP NEXT

Newsom Tacks Right to Oppose Transgender Athletes in Women’s Sports

UP NEXT

Study Tells CA Legislators to Declare War on Red Tape. Will They Do It?

UP NEXT

Editorial: City Attorney Janz Must Investigate Malicious Election Mailer

UP NEXT

California’s List of Failed Tech Projects Just Added an Agency

Legal Showdown as Justice Department Clashes with Judge Over Deportation Flight Details

38 minutes ago

Where Are Convicted Bitwise CEOs Serving Their Prison Terms?

44 minutes ago

Ohtani Hits Solo HR in Return to Japan as Dodgers Sweep Cubs

45 minutes ago

Violent Attacks on Tesla Dealerships Spike as Musk Joins Trump Administration

55 minutes ago

Judge Says Khalil’s Deportation Case Can Be Heard in New Jersey

2 hours ago

Zelenskyy Disputes Putin’s Vow Not to Hit Ukraine’s Energy Infrastructure

2 hours ago

Canada Bolsters Arctic Defenses as Trump Sets His Sights North

2 hours ago

A UN Worker Is Killed in a Strike in Gaza as Israel Warns of New Evacuation Orders

2 hours ago

Vang Appears En Route to Outright Special Fresno Council Election Win

13 hours ago

Previously Classified Files Related to JFK Assassination Released

17 hours ago

New CA Fire Maps Will Change How Some Valley Homes Are Built

When fires ravaged Chico and Paradise in 2018, most of the homes built there came before modern state mitigation standards, said Frank Bigel...

3 minutes ago

3 minutes ago

New CA Fire Maps Will Change How Some Valley Homes Are Built

20 minutes ago

Social Security Administration to Require In-Person Identity Checks for Recipients

Jarrett Steven Huddleston is Valley Crime Stoppers' Most Wanted Person of the Day for March 19, 2025. (Valley Crimes Stoppers)
29 minutes ago

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Jarrett Steven Huddleston

38 minutes ago

Legal Showdown as Justice Department Clashes with Judge Over Deportation Flight Details

44 minutes ago

Where Are Convicted Bitwise CEOs Serving Their Prison Terms?

45 minutes ago

Ohtani Hits Solo HR in Return to Japan as Dodgers Sweep Cubs

55 minutes ago

Violent Attacks on Tesla Dealerships Spike as Musk Joins Trump Administration

Mahmoud Khalil speaks during a press conference about students who were arrested and suspended for protesting at Columbia University, near the campus in New York, April 22, 2024. A New York federal judge on Wednesday transferred the case of a Columbia University graduate detained by the Trump administration this month to New Jersey, where his lawyers will continue their efforts to seek his release. (Bing Guan/The New York Times)
2 hours ago

Judge Says Khalil’s Deportation Case Can Be Heard in New Jersey

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend