Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: A Union Pot Calls a Union Kettle Black
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 4 years ago on
July 12, 2021

Share

“The pot calling the kettle black” is an old saying about hypocrisy, applied to someone who does something while criticizing someone else for doing the same thing.

The Capitol saw a classic political example of the syndrome last week during a long and otherwise tedious committee hearing on a lengthy and complicated state budget “trailer bill.”

We should all know by now that such trailer bills, which receive fast track approval because of their supposed connection to the state budget, have morphed into political Christmas trees with ornaments of special favors to those with political pull.

Bill Provision Would Virtually Eliminate U.C. Outsourcing

The measure in question, Senate Bill 132, is this year’s higher education omnibus bill containing dozens of provisions affecting the state’s colleges and universities and Section 67 is a favor to the unions that represent tens of thousands of non-faculty employees of the University of California.

Dan Walters

Opinion

It would, in essence, block all construction at UC campuses until an ad hoc assortment of union-friendly state officials had certified that the university had maximized its employment of unionized non-faculty workers and minimized – in fact virtually eliminated – outside contractors for support activities.

The issue has been percolating for years and the unions, principally AFSCME Local 3299, have obtained other favorable legislative decrees, but imposing mandates on the constitutionally independent UC system is legally difficult.

“For the past six years, we have worked with the Legislature on three bills, three budget language provisions and the constitutional amendment,” Local 3299 Kathryn Lybarger told the Assembly Budget Committee last week. “We’ve gone through policy and fiscal committees dozens of times and earned hundreds of yes votes. And yet, UC still insists on outsourcing, janitors who clean their toilets, groundskeepers who mow their grass, and cooks who prepare their food.”

Section 67 is the unions’ neutron bomb. They hope a threat to shut down construction will finally compel UC to end outsourcing.

Union vs. Union Conflict

UC officials obviously oppose it, saying that it would seriously impede campus improvements, including those affecting health and safety, while simultaneously declaring that they are honoring the previous decrees from the Legislature.

However, the threat of halting billions of dollars in construction work has drawn sharp opposition from another group of unions with oodles of political clout, led by the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, whose members’ jobs would be affected.

Dozens of union representatives expressed their implacable opposition to Section 67 during the hearing, complaining that it was unfair that one union bloc would pursue its goals at the expense of another.

Hypocrisy in Political Infighting

The hypocritical aspect of the construction unions’ opposition to the UC unions’ efforts to legislate job security for their members is that the “the trades,” as they are called in the Capitol, have been doing exactly the same thing.

They have insisted that virtually every legislative bill to increase the supply of housing contain language that, in effect, requires the use of union construction workers, even though it sharply increases costs. The boilerplate language that the trades insist be included refers to a “skilled and trained” workforce that includes apprenticeship training administered by the unions.

“You cannot address poverty and housing by driving construction workers and our families into poverty,” said Robbie Hunter, the Trades Council president, told CalMatters recently. “It just doesn’t work.”

Whether UC unions or construction unions should rely on legislative mandates to bolster their memberships is certainly debatable.

However, there’s no uncertainty that the political infighting over Senate Bill 132 and Section 67 is hypocrisy in its rankest form.

CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=31]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

UP NEXT

California’s Stubborn Problems Keep Thwarting Its Ballooning Budget

Kennedy Overhauls US CDC Vaccine Panel, Replacing All 17 Members

1 hour ago

Health Care Is a Lifeline. The Central Valley Deserves Better.

3 hours ago

Hundreds Peacefully Protest ICE Raids in Downtown Fresno

While Los Angeles rioted, hundreds of protesters gathered peacefully in downtown Fresno, protesting immigration raids in California. With ch...

17 minutes ago

18 minutes ago

Hundreds Peacefully Protest ICE Raids in Downtown Fresno

The site of the Trump hotel project, a bombed-out building that serves as an icon to Serbians’ suffering during the 199 conflict, in Belgrade, June 3, 2025. A group of preservationists has thrown a wrench in the plans for a Trump-branded hotel complex to be built by the president’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, in Belgrade. (Vladimir Zivojinovic/The New York Times)
53 minutes ago

A Trump Family Project Spurs Resignations and a Criminal Charge in Serbia

Sly Stone performs at the Coachella Valley Music Festival in Indio, Calif., on April 18, 2010. Stone, the influential, eccentric and preternaturally rhythmic singer, songwriter, multi-instrumentalist and producer whose run of hits in the late 1960s and early ’70s with his band the Family Stone could be dance anthems, political documents or both, has died. He was 82. (Josh Haner/The New York Times)
1 hour ago

Sly Stone, Maestro of a Multifaceted, Hitmaking Band, Dies at 82

Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. testifies before the Senate Committee on Appropriations hearing on the Department of Health and Human Services budget, on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 20, 2025. REUTERS/Ken Cedeno/File Photo
1 hour ago

Kennedy Overhauls US CDC Vaccine Panel, Replacing All 17 Members

3 hours ago

Health Care Is a Lifeline. The Central Valley Deserves Better.

Protesters hold placards as they gather around the Los Angeles Federal Building following multiple detentions by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), in downtown Los Angeles, California, U.S., June 6, 2025. REUTERS/Daniel Cole
3 hours ago

‘Everybody Stood up’: Why a Union Leader’s Arrest Galvanized California Democrats on Immigration

A Fresno man already jailed, Michael Fitch (pictured), 35, for a 2021 homicide has been charged in the 2022 shooting death of Ursolo “Frank” Sermeno after DNA evidence linked him to the crime, police said. (Fresno PD)
4 hours ago

Fresno Inmate Charged in 2022 Killing More Than Three Years After Crime

Fresno police arrested a woman wanted for a 2023 homicide and identified two additional suspects, including one still at large. (Fresno PD)
4 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Woman Wanted in 2023 Homicide, One Still at-Large

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend