Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
High Court Moves Away from Leniency for Minors who Murder
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 3 years ago on
April 22, 2021

Share

WASHINGTON — After more than a decade in which the Supreme Court moved gradually toward more leniency for minors convicted of murder, the justices on Thursday moved the other way.

The high court ruled 6-3 along liberal-conservative lines against a Mississippi inmate sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for fatally stabbing his grandfather when the defendant was 15 years old. The case is important because it marks a break with the court’s previous rulings and is evidence of the impact of a newly more conservative court.

Minors Sentenced Differently from Adults

The case before the justices has to do with sentencing juveniles to life in prison without the possibility of parole. The Supreme Court had previously said that those sentences should be rare. The question the justices were answering in this case concerned what courts must do before deciding to impose one of those sentences.

The “argument that the sentencer must make a finding of permanent incorrigibility is inconsistent with the Court’s precedents,” Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote for the majority.

Beginning in 2005, the Supreme Court had concluded in a series of cases that minors should be treated differently from adults, in part because of minors’ lack of maturity. That year, the court eliminated the death penalty for juveniles. Five years later, it later barred life-without-parole sentences for juveniles except in cases of murder. In 2012 and 2016 the court again sided with minors. The court said life-without-parole sentences should reserved “for all but the rarest of juvenile offenders, those whose crimes reflect permanent incorrigibility.”

Shift with Presence of More Conservative Justices

Since that time, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Justice Anthony Kennedy, whose votes were key to those decisions, have been replaced by more conservative justices.

The current case asked the justices whether a minor has to be found to be “permanently incorrigible,” incapable of being rehabilitated, before being sentenced to life without parole.

The specific case before the justices involved Mississippi inmate Brett Jones, who was 15 and living with his grandparents when he fatally stabbed his grandfather. The two had a fight in the home’s kitchen after Bertis Jones found his grandson’s girlfriend in his grandson’s bedroom. Brett Jones, who was using a knife to make a sandwich before the fight, stabbed his grandfather first with that knife and then, when it broke, with a different knife. He was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Brett Jones had argued he is not “permanently incorrigible” and should therefore be eligible for parole. Mississippi says the Eighth Amendment doesn’t require that Jones be found to be permanently incorrigible to receive a life-without-parole sentence, just that Jones’ status as a minor when he committed his crime be considered.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Investigators Have Name & Face for Suspected Arsonist Who Left Notes at Fresno Homes

DON'T MISS

Gavin Newsom and Top Democrats Are Deciding California’s Budget Behind Closed Doors

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Is 1 of Carnegie Foundation’s 25 Leadership for Public Purpose Colleges

DON'T MISS

As the Flag Drops at Le Mans, Remembering the 3 Americans Who Won in 1978

DON'T MISS

Paw-sitively Spikey: The Rise of a Supermutt!

DON'T MISS

Supreme Court Deals Blow to Environmental Law Relied on by Housing Opponents

DON'T MISS

The Latest | Hezbollah Says Its Intensified Attacks Show Israel That All-out War Would Be Costly

DON'T MISS

Alex Jones’ Assets Sold to Pay Sandy Hook Debt as Infowars’ Fate Decided

DON'T MISS

California Senate Passes Ban on Schools Notifying Parents of Child’s Pronoun Changes

DON'T MISS

Cal State LA President Bars Pro-Palestinian Protesters After Building Takeover

UP NEXT

Supreme Court Rules California Man Can’t Trademark ‘Trump Too Small’

UP NEXT

Rep. Costa Blasts GOP House For Holding AG Merrick Garland in Contempt

UP NEXT

AP Sources: 8 Individuals Possibly Linked to Islamic State Arrested in US

UP NEXT

Justice Alito Questions Possibility of Political Compromise in Secret Recording

UP NEXT

Blinken Calls on Hamas to Accept Gaza Cease-Fire Plan After UN Security Council Strongly Endorses It

UP NEXT

Trump Urges Anti-Abortion Group to Defend ‘Innocent Life’

UP NEXT

Pew Poll: Most Black Americans See Conspiracy by US Institutions

UP NEXT

Southern Baptists Are Poised to Ban Churches with Women Pastors. Some Are Urging Them to Reconsider

UP NEXT

Trump Ally Steve Bannon Must Surrender to Prison by July 1 to Start Contempt Sentence, Judge Says

UP NEXT

Clooney Defends Wife’s Work on Israeli Warrants in Call to White House

As the Flag Drops at Le Mans, Remembering the 3 Americans Who Won in 1978

13 hours ago

Paw-sitively Spikey: The Rise of a Supermutt!

15 hours ago

Supreme Court Deals Blow to Environmental Law Relied on by Housing Opponents

15 hours ago

The Latest | Hezbollah Says Its Intensified Attacks Show Israel That All-out War Would Be Costly

16 hours ago

Alex Jones’ Assets Sold to Pay Sandy Hook Debt as Infowars’ Fate Decided

17 hours ago

California Senate Passes Ban on Schools Notifying Parents of Child’s Pronoun Changes

17 hours ago

Cal State LA President Bars Pro-Palestinian Protesters After Building Takeover

17 hours ago

Supreme Court Overturns Trump-Era Bump Stock Ban, Reigniting Political Debate

17 hours ago

Trump’s 78th Birthday Showcases Loyalty from Fans and Republicans

17 hours ago

California Legislators Break with Gov. Newsom Over Loan to Keep Last Nuclear Plant Running

18 hours ago

Investigators Have Name & Face for Suspected Arsonist Who Left Notes at Fresno Homes

Fresno Fire Department investigators have identified a woman whom they think left handwritten notes at homes before lighting them on fire. F...

11 hours ago

11 hours ago

Investigators Have Name & Face for Suspected Arsonist Who Left Notes at Fresno Homes

12 hours ago

Gavin Newsom and Top Democrats Are Deciding California’s Budget Behind Closed Doors

12 hours ago

Fresno State Is 1 of Carnegie Foundation’s 25 Leadership for Public Purpose Colleges

1978 Le Mans: 3 Americans in France
13 hours ago

As the Flag Drops at Le Mans, Remembering the 3 Americans Who Won in 1978

15 hours ago

Paw-sitively Spikey: The Rise of a Supermutt!

15 hours ago

Supreme Court Deals Blow to Environmental Law Relied on by Housing Opponents

16 hours ago

The Latest | Hezbollah Says Its Intensified Attacks Show Israel That All-out War Would Be Costly

17 hours ago

Alex Jones’ Assets Sold to Pay Sandy Hook Debt as Infowars’ Fate Decided

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend