Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Opinion: Legislative Staff Right to Unionize: What Could Go Wrong?
Opinion
By Opinion
Published 4 years ago on
March 19, 2021

Share

After handing unions a brightly wrapped gift in 2019 with Assembly Bill 5, Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez is putting the bow on another present, Assembly Bill 314, which would allow legislative staffers to organize. Had she first asked a legendary labor leader what he thought about it, she would have likely received a response she didn’t want to hear.

AB 314, the San Diego Democrat’s third attempt to open the door for legislative staff unionization, promises job security for staffers, and would provide, according to Gonzalez’s office, “workplace protections laws that cover employees in private and public employment.”

“Every other employee in the state has the right to organize their workplace and join a union if they choose – legislative staff should be no different,” Gonzalez said.

Sounds fair enough. But opinions vary.

Headshot of Kerry Jackson

Kerry Jackson

Opinion

Differences with Private Sector Bargaining

Some, such as PRI’s director of communications and former legislative staffer, see the legislation as a naked effort to generate “more members and more dues for public employee unions.” Others believe government employees simply should not be allowed to organize. Their reasoning is clear: unlike collective bargaining in the private sector, in which there are opposing sides, negotiations between public-sector workers and their employers are one-way affairs.

In the private sector, management’s interest and unions’ interests are not the same. But when public-sector employees and governments talk, there is no counter argument coming from the other side of the table. Elected officials are duty-bound to represent the interests of taxpayers, yet when public employees and their unions make contributions to those officials’ political campaigns – California public-sector unions gave $74.1 million, or 46.4 percent, of the nationwide total given by unions to candidates in the 2018 election cycle – too often the negotiations are little more than a formal surrender to union demands.

Daniel DiSalvo, a City College of New York political science professor who has extensively researched the effects unions have on government, says California is one of many states which “find themselves heavily indebted, with public-sector unions at the root of their problems.”

“Taxpayers in these states are rewarded with larger and more expensive, yet less effective, government,” says DiSalvo, because elected officials “are afraid to cross the politically powerful unions.”

Legislators’ Fear of Union Clout

DiSalvo wrote those passages more than a decade ago. If anything, California lawmakers have more fear of union clout today. The Legislature, says Steven Greenhut, who has tracked Sacramento closely for years, is “union-controlled.”

Franklin Delano Roosevelt addressed the unusual union between government workers and government officials when he wrote a letter to the president of the National Federation of Federal Employees in 1937, telling him that “all government employees should realize that the process of collective bargaining, as usually understood, cannot be transplanted into the public service.”

Years later, in 1955, the iconic George Meany, first president of the AFL-CIO, admitted in a New York Times Magazine essay that “it is impossible to bargain collectively with the government.”

If the bill becomes law, it will be interesting to see how lawmakers react when their staff members walk off the job, demanding higher pay and better working conditions. What happens when they lose their secretaries, counselors, encyclopedias, personal assistants, and, as has been documented in several recent cases, easy targets for sexual harassment? Getting a taste of what the private sector has to deal with through contract negotiations, which governments have tilted in favor of organized labor, might not be so sweet.

Working Relationships Forever Changed

Since, as Gonzalez says “every other employee in the state has the right to organize their workplace and join a union,” what could be the harm in allowing maybe 2,000 more to unionize?

One complication that comes to mind: the relationships between elected officials and their staffs. They will be forever changed.

Gonzalez and her 44 co-authors apparently overlooked the awkward environments and conflicts of interest that will result should lawmakers seek, as they inevitably will, endorsements and campaign donations from their employees. Staff members, says Stanford lecturer and lifelong Democrat David Crane, “are supposed to provide uninterested counsel to elected representatives who should neither seek nor worry about” contributions and political backing from the professionals who support them. Shifting roles in a unionized work environment will produce a “dangerous” dynamic, he says.

Gonzalez seems optimistic that this time her bill will pass. Given that AB 5, her union-friendly legislation that virtually outlawed gig work in California, passed by overwhelming margins in 2019, her confidence is justified. Fresno and Central Valley are no stranger to the fights of unionization, especially in agriculture. Legislators may get more than they bargained for – pun intended – if they pass AB 314.

About the Author 

Kerry Jackson is a fellow with the Center for California Reform at the Pacific Research Institute.

[activecampaign form=19]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Florida State Gunman Used Deputy Mom’s Former Service Weapon, Authorities Say

DON'T MISS

Giants Befuddled by Sánchez’s Changeup in Loss to the Phillies

DON'T MISS

Trump Officials’ Defiance Over Abrego Garcia’s Deportation Is ‘Shocking,’ Appeals Court Says

DON'T MISS

Jane Fonda Packs the Saroyan Theatre, Delivers an Empowering Message

DON'T MISS

AOC Emerges as Top Democratic White House Contender for 2028

DON'T MISS

Why Fresno Unified Tried to Keep Superintendent Search Secret

DON'T MISS

White House Eyes Overhaul of Federal Housing Aid to the Poor

DON'T MISS

Dems Step Up Trump Resistance as Base Hungers for More of a Fight

DON'T MISS

2 Killed and 5 Hurt in Florida State University Shooting; Gunman in Custody

DON'T MISS

Fresno Unified Trustees Passed Over a National Superintendent of the Year

UP NEXT

Giants Befuddled by Sánchez’s Changeup in Loss to the Phillies

UP NEXT

Trump Officials’ Defiance Over Abrego Garcia’s Deportation Is ‘Shocking,’ Appeals Court Says

UP NEXT

Jane Fonda Packs the Saroyan Theatre, Delivers an Empowering Message

UP NEXT

AOC Emerges as Top Democratic White House Contender for 2028

UP NEXT

White House Eyes Overhaul of Federal Housing Aid to the Poor

UP NEXT

Dems Step Up Trump Resistance as Base Hungers for More of a Fight

UP NEXT

2 Killed and 5 Hurt in Florida State University Shooting; Gunman in Custody

UP NEXT

Fresno Unified Trustees Passed Over a National Superintendent of the Year

UP NEXT

Hamas Ready to Release All Remaining Hostages for End to Gaza War, Hamas’ Gaza Chief Says

UP NEXT

Ford Recalls More Than 148,000 Vehicles, NHTSA Says

Jane Fonda Packs the Saroyan Theatre, Delivers an Empowering Message

12 hours ago

AOC Emerges as Top Democratic White House Contender for 2028

12 hours ago

Why Fresno Unified Tried to Keep Superintendent Search Secret

13 hours ago

White House Eyes Overhaul of Federal Housing Aid to the Poor

13 hours ago

Dems Step Up Trump Resistance as Base Hungers for More of a Fight

13 hours ago

2 Killed and 5 Hurt in Florida State University Shooting; Gunman in Custody

13 hours ago

Fresno Unified Trustees Passed Over a National Superintendent of the Year

13 hours ago

Hamas Ready to Release All Remaining Hostages for End to Gaza War, Hamas’ Gaza Chief Says

15 hours ago

Ford Recalls More Than 148,000 Vehicles, NHTSA Says

15 hours ago

Supreme Court to Hear Arguments on Trump Plan to End Birthright Citizenship

15 hours ago

Florida State Gunman Used Deputy Mom’s Former Service Weapon, Authorities Say

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — The 20-year-old son of a sheriff’s deputy opened fire Thursday at Florida State University with his mother’s...

11 hours ago

11 hours ago

Florida State Gunman Used Deputy Mom’s Former Service Weapon, Authorities Say

11 hours ago

Giants Befuddled by Sánchez’s Changeup in Loss to the Phillies

11 hours ago

Trump Officials’ Defiance Over Abrego Garcia’s Deportation Is ‘Shocking,’ Appeals Court Says

12 hours ago

Jane Fonda Packs the Saroyan Theatre, Delivers an Empowering Message

12 hours ago

AOC Emerges as Top Democratic White House Contender for 2028

13 hours ago

Why Fresno Unified Tried to Keep Superintendent Search Secret

13 hours ago

White House Eyes Overhaul of Federal Housing Aid to the Poor

13 hours ago

Dems Step Up Trump Resistance as Base Hungers for More of a Fight

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend