Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

What’s Behind California’s Frozen Housing Market?

13 hours ago

Oil Prices Rise on Trade War Relief, US Pressure on Russia

14 hours ago

Marjorie Taylor Greene Is First Republican Lawmaker to Call Gaza Crisis a ‘Genocide’

16 hours ago

UK Will Recognize Palestinian Statehood in September, Barring Israel-Hamas Ceasefire

16 hours ago

Trump’s EPA to Repeal Core of Greenhouse Gas Rules in Major Deregulatory Move

17 hours ago

US Approval of Israel’s Gaza Offensive Drops to 32%, Poll Shows

18 hours ago

Shooter in New York Skyscraper Left Note Blaming NFL for Brain Injury, Mayor Says

19 hours ago

Trump Eyes Aug 1 Trade Deals as EU, China Talks Continue, US Commerce Chief Says

19 hours ago

Trump Says Many Are Starving in Gaza, Vows to Set up Food Centers

2 days ago
Cap and Trade, Offsets at a Crossroads in California’s Climate Policy
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 4 years ago on
March 1, 2021

Share

Should oil refineries in California be allowed to emit extra greenhouse gases if they “offset” their effects by paying hog farmers in Iowa to reduce methane from animal waste? Or by paying landowners to promise to take better care of their trees? In other words, should offset trading based on projects like these remain part of our state’s climate policy?

This is a big question facing the California Air Resources Board at a hearing this week and over the coming year as they revise the rules of the state’s climate law, AB 32 / AB 398.  Under that law’s cap-and-trade section, any California company that purchases approved offsets may emit more planet-heating gasses than would otherwise be allowed.

By Kathleen McAfee

Opinion

Carbon Offsets Making Greenhouse Emissions Problem Worse

Offsets pay for climate-friendly projects, mostly for improved forest management. Proponents contend that, over time, those projects will capture an amount of carbon or prevent the release of greenhouse gases equal to the extra amount a company may emit in one year. Offsets themselves do not result in any decrease in greenhouse gases; they simply make the extra emissions legal.

But California’s climate policy is already failing to reduce planet-warming emissions fast enough to meet the state’s 2030 target. This reality is recognized by a new state auditor’s report, the Legislative Analyst’s Office and increasingly, our lawmakers.

Why are we falling short? Offsetting and cap and trade – allowance trading – are playing a much larger role than the law’s designers originally intended. Too many allowances – tradable permits to emit greenhouse gases – are sold or given away. A glut of unused allowances reduces demand for them and lessens the incentive for polluters to curb their emissions: why not buy cheap allowances and even-cheaper offsets instead?

Since offsets are making this problem worse, it is bewildering that a new report by the Air Resources Board’s Compliance Offsets Protocol Task Force recommends even more ways for companies to pay for “green” activities by somebody else instead of cleaning up their own emissions. The task force calls for more offsetting, with weaker rules, based on the theory that offsetting ought to contribute to emissions reductions or avoidance. Its report says that offsets are “providing jobs and lowering pollution loads for neighboring residents” – a dubious, undocumented claim.

Our largest greenhouse gas producers have been the main offsets users. Partly as a result, emissions from industrial facilities have increased since the program began. These major polluters are disproportionately located in low-income areas, damaging health and shortening lives.

The task force presents its proposals as a partial response to this environmental injustice, one that will enable Native Californians and other “disadvantaged” communities to “participate” in the offsets program. Yet the report fails to recognize that the majority of environmental justice organizations in California are opposed to offsets.

Air Resources Board Being Asked to Expand Offsets

Astonishingly, the report asks the Air Resources Board to expand offsets without first evaluating the effects that it is having on frontline communities. The ARB does not even know how much its rules for allowances, offsetting and vehicle-fuels are affecting emissions or yielding the benefits these policies are supposed to provide.

Most offsets exchange an immediate, certain climate bad (extra greenhouse gases) for a future, hoped-for climate good (such as storage of carbon in trees for the next 100 years or long-term continuation of activities to capture methane or bury carbon on farms). But there is substantial evidence that California’s forest-based and mine-methane offsets are not storing nearly enough greenhouse gases to compensate for the extra emissions they allow.

The Air Resources Board appears determined to find “market solutions” to climate change through allowance and offset trading. The board’s decision to assemble a panel that mainly comprises people with professional or financial interests in offsetting probably made its outcome predictable, and is part of the reason why the environmental-justice and NGO members appointed to the task force have resigned.

There are many reasons to promote forest conservation and climate-wise use of farmlands. There are reasons, too, to provide special support to indigenous, non-white and low-income communities coping with climate change. If we are serious about environmental justice and greenhouse gas reductions, we must address these goals directly – not treat them as hope-for side-effects of business decisions and the uncertainties of the markets for offsets and allowances.

About the Author

Kathleen McAfee is a professor of international relations at San Francisco State University. Her email address is kmcafee@sfsu.edu.

[activecampaign form=31]

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

California Under Tsunami Advisory After Magnitude 8.7 Earthquake

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Dies in DUI Crash, Driver Arrested

DON'T MISS

Madera County Wildfire Burns Near Fairmead, Containment at 0%

DON'T MISS

Watch Twin Meteor Showers Reach Their Simultaneous Peak in Summer Skies

DON'T MISS

New York Gunman Was Flagged by Security Camera System Before Attack, Sources Say

DON'T MISS

As Trump Cuts Education, Candidates Line Up for California’s Top Schools Job

DON'T MISS

US House Panel Rejects Immunity Request by Epstein Associate Maxwell

DON'T MISS

Fresno’s Vacant Property Ordinance Punishes the Wrong People: Rassamni

DON'T MISS

Trump Approval Rating Sinks to 40%, the Lowest of His Term, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

DON'T MISS

What’s Behind California’s Frozen Housing Market?

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Dies in DUI Crash, Driver Arrested

UP NEXT

Madera County Wildfire Burns Near Fairmead, Containment at 0%

UP NEXT

Watch Twin Meteor Showers Reach Their Simultaneous Peak in Summer Skies

UP NEXT

New York Gunman Was Flagged by Security Camera System Before Attack, Sources Say

UP NEXT

As Trump Cuts Education, Candidates Line Up for California’s Top Schools Job

UP NEXT

US House Panel Rejects Immunity Request by Epstein Associate Maxwell

UP NEXT

Fresno’s Vacant Property Ordinance Punishes the Wrong People: Rassamni

UP NEXT

Trump Approval Rating Sinks to 40%, the Lowest of His Term, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

UP NEXT

What’s Behind California’s Frozen Housing Market?

UP NEXT

Tulare County Authorities Find Body in Sequoia National Park

Watch Twin Meteor Showers Reach Their Simultaneous Peak in Summer Skies

10 hours ago

New York Gunman Was Flagged by Security Camera System Before Attack, Sources Say

10 hours ago

As Trump Cuts Education, Candidates Line Up for California’s Top Schools Job

11 hours ago

US House Panel Rejects Immunity Request by Epstein Associate Maxwell

12 hours ago

Fresno’s Vacant Property Ordinance Punishes the Wrong People: Rassamni

12 hours ago

Trump Approval Rating Sinks to 40%, the Lowest of His Term, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

12 hours ago

What’s Behind California’s Frozen Housing Market?

13 hours ago

Tulare County Authorities Find Body in Sequoia National Park

14 hours ago

Oil Prices Rise on Trade War Relief, US Pressure on Russia

14 hours ago

Scottie Scheffler vs. Everybody: Open Champion Makes His Case Among the Greats

15 hours ago

California Under Tsunami Advisory After Magnitude 8.7 Earthquake

Update at 7:35 p.m. on July 29 The U.S. National Weather Service has issued a tsunami advisory for the California coast, with projected arri...

9 hours ago

9 hours ago

California Under Tsunami Advisory After Magnitude 8.7 Earthquake

Juan Carlos Mendoza Jr., 23, was arrested on suspicion of DUI and vehicular manslaughter after a crash in Fresno County killed a 24-year-old passenger. (Fresno County SO)
9 hours ago

Fresno Man Dies in DUI Crash, Driver Arrested

A wildfire in Madera County, dubbed the 19 Fire, has burned 16 acres with 0% containment as of Tuesday, July 29, 2025, afternoon, according to CalFire. (CalFire)
9 hours ago

Madera County Wildfire Burns Near Fairmead, Containment at 0%

10 hours ago

Watch Twin Meteor Showers Reach Their Simultaneous Peak in Summer Skies

A man holding a rifle walks into an office building at 345 Park Avenue shortly before a shooting that killed several people, in the Midtown Manhattan district of New York City, U.S. July 28, 2025, in a still image taken from surveillance video. Surveillance Camera/Handout via REUTERS
10 hours ago

New York Gunman Was Flagged by Security Camera System Before Attack, Sources Say

Teacher Uses Globe While Instructing Her Students
11 hours ago

As Trump Cuts Education, Candidates Line Up for California’s Top Schools Job

Jeffrey Epstein associate Ghislaine Maxwell stands at the podium to address Judge Alison Nathan during her sentencing in a courtroom sketch in New York City, U.S. June 28, 2022. (Reuters File)
12 hours ago

US House Panel Rejects Immunity Request by Epstein Associate Maxwell

12 hours ago

Fresno’s Vacant Property Ordinance Punishes the Wrong People: Rassamni

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend