Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Watchdog Criticizes Newsom for Favoring Big Cities with COVID Relief Funds
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 4 years ago on
January 19, 2021

Share

California should have spent more money helping its smaller counties battle the coronavirus, state Auditor Elaine Howle said Tuesday, criticizing Gov. Gavin Newsom’s administration for favoring places with big populations despite data showing the needs of rural areas “were at least the same if not greater.”

And while the Newsom administration pledged to withhold some of that money from cities that didn’t follow public health orders, Howle said the state did not consistently monitor that issue, raising questions about how many cities got funding when they shouldn’t have.

The dual findings were part of Howle’s first look at how California is spending more than $71 billion in coronavirus aid the state is slated to receive from the federal government — a figure that has already increased after Congress approved additional spending in December.

It’s so much money that, last year, Howle declared the state was at “high risk” for waste, fraud and abuse — a designation that gives her authority to investigate. A second audit is due next week examining the billions of dollars in federal unemployment benefits that have flowed to the state during the pandemic — benefits the state has already acknowledged has been abused by prison inmates and others who were not eligible.

The audit released Tuesday examined the $15.3 billion Congress sent California in May from the Coronavirus Relief Fund. Of that money, $5.8 billion went directly to counties and cities with populations greater than 500,000 people. State officials had to decide how to spend the other $9.5 billion.

The Newsom administration, together with the Legislature, decided to give $1.3 billion to county governments, with more than half of it going to the 16 biggest counties that had already gotten money directly from the federal government.

Those counties got about $190 per person while the 42 smaller counties got $102 per person, the audit says.

“It’s a pretty common frustration in California,” said Assemblyman James Gallagher, a Republican who represents six smaller counties. “The way that funds are distributed tends to favor the Bay Area and Los Angeles, where the majority of legislature are from, right? Whereas, the rural areas really feel like they get kind of short shrift.”

The Department of Finance, the state agency in charge of distributing the money, said it gave most of it to the bigger counties because it believed their denser populations would lead to greater spread of the virus. But the audit, citing data from the Department of Public Health, says the virus spread evenly through counties despite their population — and in some cases it was much worse in smaller places.

Newsom and the Legislature Agreed to Withhold Money From Cities That Did Not Follow Public Health Orders

Imperial County, with a population of just over 188,000 people, averaged 3,215 COVID-19 cases per 100,000 people while Los Angeles County, with more than 10.1 million people, averaged 989 cases per 100,000 people.

The state’s strategy, Howle said, contradicted guidance from the U.S. Treasury that urged states to “treat local governments equitably, regardless of their population size.”

“By not equitably providing counties with funds, there is greater risk that more small counties’ COVID-19 related funding needs were unmet,” Howle wrote.

In a response letter to Howle, Department of Finance Director Keely Martin Bosler said the department and the Legislature agreed to give the money to counties “generally based on their relative share of the state’s population.” Howle disputed that, saying the department’s strategy was based on a belief the virus would spread more in densely populated areas.

Department of Finance spokesman H.D. Palmer deferred to the Legislature, which approved the funding strategy as part of the state’s operating budget.

“If the auditor’s office has concerns over this process, they should take their policy recommendations directly to the Legislature,” Palmer said.

Newsom and the Legislature agreed to withhold money from cities that did not follow public health orders, including enforcing the state’s stay-at-home order that required some businesses to close and others to limit capacity.

The state withheld money from two cities — Coalinga and Atwater — because they passed resolutions defying public health orders. But Howle said the Governor’s Office of Emergency Services, which was in charge of monitoring local governments, “could not demonstrate that it had evaluated all cities.”

Bosler, director of the Department of Finance, said cities had to certify they were following the rules before they could get the money, adding that the Office of Emergency Services did a legal analysis of any local laws that might defy the rules.

Howle said that “overstates” the work the office did, noting they used “an informal process” to evaluate cities’ compliance.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Wired Wednesday: Fired Teacher and Coach Ed Madec Seeks Justice

DON'T MISS

Fresno Location Is Among the 500 JOANN Fabrics Closures

DON'T MISS

Clovis Wrestles With Fallout From ‘Non-Sanctuary City’ Idea

DON'T MISS

California Farm Donates Hundreds of Thousands of Eggs to Wildfire Victims, First Responders

DON'T MISS

As Council Race Heats Up, Dyer Credits ‘One Fresno’ for New SE Sports Park

DON'T MISS

Editorials of The Times: Now Is Not the Time to Tune Out

DON'T MISS

Fresno Unified Substitute Questions Students About Immigration Status

DON'T MISS

USAID in Turmoil as Aid Programs Cut, Staff Stranded

DON'T MISS

Look Past Elon Musk’s Chaos. There’s Something More Sinister at Work.

DON'T MISS

Navy Crew Members Eject From Their Jet Before It Crashes off the San Diego Coast

UP NEXT

USAID in Turmoil as Aid Programs Cut, Staff Stranded

UP NEXT

Navy Crew Members Eject From Their Jet Before It Crashes off the San Diego Coast

UP NEXT

Pentagon’s New Media Rotation Program Boots NPR, NY Times, NBC News

UP NEXT

Apple Changes Gulf of Mexico to Gulf of America on Maps

UP NEXT

California’s FAIR Plan Needs $1B for Wildfire Claims, Costs Passed to Policyholders

UP NEXT

California Man Calls 375 Hoax Threats in Swatting Spree Will Face Prison Time

UP NEXT

Red, White, and Blueland? GOP Congressman Proposes Bill to Rename Greenland

UP NEXT

White House Bars AP Reporter From Oval Office Because of AP Style Policy on ‘Gulf of America’

UP NEXT

Californians Picked Up in Recent ICE Raids Include Kids and Volunteers

UP NEXT

Denmark Wants to Buy California? Online Petition Hits 200,000 Signatures

California Farm Donates Hundreds of Thousands of Eggs to Wildfire Victims, First Responders

14 hours ago

As Council Race Heats Up, Dyer Credits ‘One Fresno’ for New SE Sports Park

14 hours ago

Editorials of The Times: Now Is Not the Time to Tune Out

15 hours ago

Fresno Unified Substitute Questions Students About Immigration Status

15 hours ago

USAID in Turmoil as Aid Programs Cut, Staff Stranded

15 hours ago

Look Past Elon Musk’s Chaos. There’s Something More Sinister at Work.

15 hours ago

Navy Crew Members Eject From Their Jet Before It Crashes off the San Diego Coast

16 hours ago

Kellen Moore Exits Eagles to Become Saints Head Coach

16 hours ago

The Deadly Truth: Record Number of Journalists Killed in 2024

17 hours ago

CHP K-9 Seizes 50 Pounds of Illicit Mushrooms in Fresno County

17 hours ago

Wired Wednesday: Fired Teacher and Coach Ed Madec Seeks Justice

On this week’s Wired Wednesday, GV Wire senior reporter David Taub talks with KMPH Fox 26 “Great Day” anchor Karl Cooke about the firing of ...

12 hours ago

12 hours ago

Wired Wednesday: Fired Teacher and Coach Ed Madec Seeks Justice

13 hours ago

Fresno Location Is Among the 500 JOANN Fabrics Closures

13 hours ago

Clovis Wrestles With Fallout From ‘Non-Sanctuary City’ Idea

Rosemary Farm family representatives Jose Pelayo, left, and Lisa Stothart deliver a donation of hundreds of thousands of fresh eggs to feed first responders and those in need in the community through the donation of Rosemary Eggs at the Los Angeles Food Regional Bank in City of Industry, Calif., Wednesday, Feb. 12, 2025. (AP/Damian Dovarganes)
14 hours ago

California Farm Donates Hundreds of Thousands of Eggs to Wildfire Victims, First Responders

14 hours ago

As Council Race Heats Up, Dyer Credits ‘One Fresno’ for New SE Sports Park

President Donald Trump signs an executive order on birthright citizenship in the Oval Office of the White House, Monday, Jan. 20, 2025, in Washington. (AP/Evan Vucci)
15 hours ago

Editorials of The Times: Now Is Not the Time to Tune Out

15 hours ago

Fresno Unified Substitute Questions Students About Immigration Status

Priya Kathpal, right, and Taylor Williamson, left, who work for a company doing contract work for the United States Agency for International Development, or USAID, carry signs outside the USAID headquarters in Washington, Monday, Feb. 10, 2025. (AP/Manuel Balce Ceneta)
15 hours ago

USAID in Turmoil as Aid Programs Cut, Staff Stranded

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend