Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

West Bank Town Becomes ‘Big Prison’ as Israel Fences It In

2 days ago

Trump Says He’s Willing to Let Migrant Farm Laborers Stay in US

2 days ago

US Electric Vehicle Tax Breaks Will Expire on Sept. 30

3 days ago

Eyeing Arctic Dominance, Trump Bill Earmarks $8.6 Billion for US Coast Guard Icebreakers

3 days ago

Trump’s Sweeping Tax-Cut and Spending Bill Wins Congressional Approval

3 days ago

Americans Celebrate Their Independence With Record-Breaking Travel Numbers

3 days ago

US Supreme Court to Decide Legality of Transgender School Sports Bans

3 days ago

Nvidia Set to Become the World’s Most Valuable Company in History

3 days ago

Poll: 41% in US ‘Extremely Proud’ to Be American, Near Historic Low

3 days ago
Judges Seem Skeptical on Fresno Park Tax Outcome. Case Headed to State's Top Court?
David Taub Website photo 2024
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 5 years ago on
December 16, 2020

Share

An appellate court panel appeared skeptical Tuesday about whether restrictions on government bodies passing taxes also applies to voters themselves.

If the court rules they don’t, it could mean that the 2018 parks tax initiative that Fresno voters seemingly rejected, could pass after all.

A three-judge panel of the Fresno-based California 5th District Court of Appeal heard one hour of oral arguments Tuesday through video teleconference.

Simple Majority or Two-Thirds Approval Needed?

At issue was Measure P, which divided the community and appeared to fail because it did not muster two-thirds of the popular vote. But the court is considering whether Measure P only needed a simple majority to pass.

The judges have not yet made a ruling and did not offer a timetable when their decision could be released.

An attorney involved in the case expects it to wind up in the state’s highest court.

“In any event, if the Court rules against us as I expect it will, then we will petition the Supreme Court for review,” Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association attorney Tim Bittle said.

Clockwise from top left: attorneys Tom Willis and Tim Bittle; Justices Mark Stauffer, Rosendo Pena Jr. and Donald Franson Jr. (Image: screen shot)

Main Argument: Petition-Based Initiatives are Different

The case was argued in front of Rosendo Peña Jr., Donald Franson Jr. and Mark Snauffer — appointed by governors Gray Davis, Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jerry Brown respectively.

The main question argued — what is the proper voting standard for a specific tax when placed on the ballot by initiative?

Proposition 13 of 1978 and Proposition 218 of 1996 set standards for governments that place tax measures in front of the voters, including a requirement for a two-thirds majority to approve a levy that goes to a specific purpose.

“Did the voters intend to include themselves in that term ‘local government’ in cities and counties? The answer is no,” attorney Tom Willis argued on behalf of plaintiff Fresno Building Health Communities.

HJTA attorney Tim Bittle argued that the two-thirds standard should apply to petition-based initiatives.

Even if a petition qualifies for the ballot, it still goes through a governmental body, Bittle said. The petition can either be adopted and enacted by the government or sent to the voters to decide.

“All special taxes, regardless of who proposes them, goes through that funnel and lands on the city council dais,” Bittle said.

Franson asked Willis whether the motivations of Proposition 13 was to limit the power of government. Willis agreed.

“They weren’t scared of themselves, I guess, is one way of looking at it,” Willis answered.

A link to the video of the arguments can be found here (it starts at the 4:40:00 mark).

Judges Question Taxpayer Group’s Interpretation

Snauffer was skeptical of Bittle’s argument.

“If it’s proposed by an initiative of the people in a given jurisdiction, I don’t see how that two-thirds vote applies,” he said.

Franson questioned whether a governmental body’s votes to place a petition-based initiative on the ballot is anything more than just an administrative decision. He did not indicate his view on whether that process has an affect on how many votes would be required for the initiative to pass.

Bittle insisted that the two-thirds standard applies in the case of Measure P. He said if only a simple majority vote is needed, governmental bodies would just rely on petitions to pass special taxes.

“Creating a loophole would thwart that intent (of requiring the higher voter threshold),” Bittle told the judges.

Bittle said other similar cases are ongoing, all in the state’s appeals court based in San Francisco.

“Your court is our last hope for protecting the right to an election that the voters gave themselves,” Bittle said. “We already know how the First District Court of Appeal views this.”

2017 Supreme Court Ruling Leads to a New Look on Taxes

The state Supreme Court ruled in 2017 in the California Cannabis Coalition v. City of Upland case that certain aspects of the law did not apply to petition-based initiatives as opposed to those placed on the ballot by a vote of a governmental body.

The Upland ruling dealt specifically about the timing of placing an initiative on a ballot and did not address the vote threshold question.

The First District Court interpreted the Upland case as having included the vote threshold when it considered a similar 2018 tax measure in the same city.

Willis argued that appeal court got it right, that propositions 13 and 218 restrictions do not apply to petition-based initiative.

“There was no explicit reference to the right of initiative, no statement of intent to limit the right of initiative,” Willis told the judges. “Either the framers (of propositions 13 and 218) didn’t want to limit the right of initiative or they didn’t think about it.”

Measure P Received Majority, But Did it Pass?

Fresno voters rejected Measure P when it only received 52.17% — less than a two-thirds majority as the law seemingly required — or at least how it was interpreted at the time by City Attorney Doug Sloan and accepted by the City Council. The measure aimed to raise the city’s sales tax by three-eighths of a percent.

A coalition led by former mayor Ashley Swearengin and parks advocates, including Fresno BHC, pushed for the tax, which was estimated to raise $38 million for parks and other programs annually during its 30 year life span.

Opposing the tax were Mayor Lee Brand, Jerry Dyer — then police chief and now mayor-elect — and other public safety advocates.

The business community was also split. The late David McDonald, former Pelco CEO, favored Measure P; Darius Assemi, CEO of Granville Homes and publisher of GV Wire, was opposed.

After its apparent defeat, Fresno BHC sued, saying the city’s interpretations of propositions 13 and 218 were wrong and only a simple majority is needed when a question is placed on the ballot through a petition process.

A Fresno County Superior Court judge ruled in favor of the city in 2019 — with the case argued by an intervening party, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association. Fresno Building Healthy Communities appealed, resulting in the case being heard Tuesday.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

How Trump’s ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’ Will Make China Great Again

DON'T MISS

What’s Caitlin Clark Worth to the WNBA? A Lot More Than Her $78,066 Salary.

DON'T MISS

Trump to Sign Tax-Cut and Spending Bill in July 4 Ceremony

DON'T MISS

Madre Fire Spurs Evacuations Across 3 Counties, Grows to More Than 70,000 Acres

DON'T MISS

Clovis, Sanger, Madera, and Bass Lake Will Light the Sky With Fireworks Shows Tonight

DON'T MISS

Oil Dips Ahead of Expected OPEC+ Output Increase

DON'T MISS

613 Killed at Gaza Aid Distribution Sites, Near Humanitarian Covoys, Says UN

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Authorities Investigating Suspicious Death of Transient Man

DON'T MISS

West Bank Town Becomes ‘Big Prison’ as Israel Fences It In

DON'T MISS

Israeli Military Kills 20 in Gaza as Trump Awaits Hamas Reply to Truce Proposal

UP NEXT

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Rachelle Maria Blanco

UP NEXT

Fresno Police to Conduct DUI Checkpoint on Fourth of July, Boost Holiday Patrols

UP NEXT

Fresno Crash Involving Unlicensed Teen Driver Sends Woman to Hospital

UP NEXT

RIP John Harris: Fresno County Rancher, Racehorse Breeder Was a Visionary Leader Who Leaves a ‘Profound Legacy’

UP NEXT

Valadao, Costa Spar on What Passage of Trump’s Bill Means for Medicaid Recipients

UP NEXT

Kaweah Health Names Its New Chief Nurse. She’s From Texas

UP NEXT

Clovis Police Say At-Risk Missing Woman Found Dead in Mariposa County

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Recover Some of the $40,000 in Fireworks Stolen From Bullard High Team

UP NEXT

Riverdale High School Coach Arrested for Allegedly Arranging to Meet Minor

UP NEXT

Could Cuddly Colby Be the Darling Gem for You?

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

Trump Calls Musk’s Formation of New Party “Ridiculous” and Confusing

36 minutes ago

Fresno DUI Driver Slams Into CHP Motorcycle, Tow Truck on Highway 99

7 hours ago

Russia Downs 120 Ukrainian Drones Overnight, Defense Ministry Says

7 hours ago

Israel Sends Delegation to Qatar for Gaza Talks Ahead of Netanyahu Trip to US

7 hours ago

San Luis Obispo’s Madre Fire Grows to Nearly 80,000 Acres, 30% Contained

7 hours ago

Musk Announces Forming of ‘America Party’ in Further Break From Trump

7 hours ago

Death Toll From Texas Floods Reaches 59, Including 21 Children

7 hours ago

California’s Politics Drifts Right While New York’s Leans Left

8 hours ago

How Trump’s ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’ Will Make China Great Again

1 day ago

What’s Caitlin Clark Worth to the WNBA? A Lot More Than Her $78,066 Salary.

1 day ago

TikTok Building New Version of App Ahead of Expected US Sale, the Information Reports

TikTok is building a new version of its app for users in the United States ahead of a planned sale of the app to a group of investors, The I...

25 minutes ago

A logo is displayed over a door at the U.S. headquarters of the social media company TikTok in Culver City, California, U.S. January 17, 2025. (Reuters File)
25 minutes ago

TikTok Building New Version of App Ahead of Expected US Sale, the Information Reports

Boxes of aid are stacked as Gaza Humanitarian Foundation said it has commenced operations to begin distribution of aid, in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip, May 26, 2025. (Reuters File)
27 minutes ago

Hamas Government Office Rejects US Accusation of Involvement in Gaza Aid Site Attack

A volunteer searches for flood victims after deadly flooding in Kerr County, Texas, U.S., July 6, 2025. REUTERS/Sergio Flores
30 minutes ago

Death Toll From Texas Floods Reaches 78, Trump Plans Visit

Tesla CEO and X owner Elon Musk listens as US President-elect Donald Trump speaks during a meeting with House Republicans at the Hyatt Regency hotel in Washington, DC, U.S. on November 13, 2024. (Reuters File)
36 minutes ago

Trump Calls Musk’s Formation of New Party “Ridiculous” and Confusing

A 22-year-old suspected DUI driver crashed into a parked CHP motorcycle and tow truck on Highway 99 near Fresno, narrowly missing an officer and bystanders, CHP said Saturday, July 5, 2025. (CHP)
7 hours ago

Fresno DUI Driver Slams Into CHP Motorcycle, Tow Truck on Highway 99

A service member of a drone unit of the 24th Separate Mechanized Brigade named after King Danylo of the Ukrainian Armed Forces controls a heavy combat drone while it flies over positions of Russian troops, amid Russia's attack on Ukraine, in Donetsk Region, Ukraine June 12, 2025. (Reuters File)
7 hours ago

Russia Downs 120 Ukrainian Drones Overnight, Defense Ministry Says

An Israeli tank maneuvers in Gaza, as seen from the Israeli side of the border, July 6, 2025. (Reuters/Amir Cohen)
7 hours ago

Israel Sends Delegation to Qatar for Gaza Talks Ahead of Netanyahu Trip to US

The Madre Fire near New Cuyama has burned nearly 80,000 acres as of Sunday, July 6, 2025, morning, prompting widespread evacuation orders and warnings across three counties. (CalFire)
7 hours ago

San Luis Obispo’s Madre Fire Grows to Nearly 80,000 Acres, 30% Contained

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend