Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Court Slaps Down No-Bid School Contracts in Fresno Case
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 4 years ago on
December 1, 2020

Share

An alternative view of California’s public school system is that it is a huge industry with six million customers who spend more than $100 billion a year.

There’s big money to be made in supplying the goods and services those young customers demand, which translates into political jousting for pieces of the financial pie.

Dan Walters

Opinion

A recent California appellate court decision dealt with the syndrome — putting the brakes on one especially insidious practice that allowed those with political pull to profitably twist a law meant to help local school systems build much-needed facilities.

It dates back to 1957, when the Legislature, seeking to help school districts cope with a tidal wave of baby boomer students, enacted something called “lease-leaseback.”

It authorized a district to lease a school site to a contractor for a token amount. The contractor would build the school and then lease it back to the district for up to 40 years, after which ownership would revert to the district, bypassing the traditional use of voter-approved bonds.

The law allowed a school contractor/lessor to be chosen without competitive bidding, and some school officials began misuing that exemption with projects whose “leases” would last only through construction, after which contractors would be paid off with state and local bond funds.

The Warning Went Unheeded and No-Bid Lease-Leaseback Contracts Proliferated

In 2004, the State Allocation Board, which parcels out school construction money, questioned the propriety of such contracts, declaring “the integrity of the use of general obligation bonds…must be above reproach” and suggested that the lease-leaseback law be clarified.

The warning went unheeded and no-bid lease-leaseback contracts proliferated. Los Angeles Unified alone did more than 70 projects worth more than $2.7 billion. Some have been scandals, involving favors to local school officials and bond campaign financing from contractors.

A notorious example occurred in the Fresno Unified School District in 2012 when Harris Construction Co. received a lease-leaseback contract for a middle school without bidding. The district paid for the construction in installments, and then assumed ownership on completion.

Stephen Davis, a rival contractor, filed a double-barreled lawsuit alleging that the contract violated competitive bidding and conflict-of-interest laws, the latter because Harris had also been retained as a “consultant.”

Fresno Unified’s superintendent, Michael Hanson, received intense criticism in local media for his close relationship with Harris Construction’s owner, Richard Spencer, including Spencer’s buying radio ads to praise Hanson’s performance and underwriting his “state of education” event. Eventually, as the lawsuit wound through the courts, Hanson lost his job.

School Construction Firms Attempted and Failed to Get Legislation

Both facets of the lawsuit prevailed, with one going to the state Supreme Court. Only one issue remained — whether Harris could be compelled to return the $37 million it was paid for the school, which the law calls “disgorgement.”

With dozens of questionable lease-leaseback deals at risk, school construction firms attempted and failed to get legislation that would have protected them from disgorgement.

Last month, an appellate court declared that “the remedy of disgorgement is available” in the Fresno Unified case, overturning a lower court ruling.

Justice Donald Franson Jr. wrote in his opinion that the middle school contract functioned as a traditional construction contract and not a genuine lease, and should have been awarded by competitive bidding.

Harris Construction may take the issue to the state Supreme Court, but having been rebuffed earlier, is unlikely to prevail.

It’s a big win for Stephen Davis and Kevin Carlin, a San Diego lawyer who represented him and has pursued other questionable lease-leaseback cases.

More than anything, however, the decision is a warning to construction companies and school officials that bending the law with sweetheart contracts is intolerable.

[activecampaign form=19]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Ray Appleton Set to Resume His KMJ Show. E Curtis Johnson Retires

DON'T MISS

Fresno Unified Communications Boss on Leave After AI-Generated FTA Dossier Debacle

DON'T MISS

Visalia Teen Takes Second Place in Dramatic Scripps National Spelling Bee Finals

DON'T MISS

Newsom Tussles With Local Officials Over Homelessness

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Arrest Two Women Suspected in Targeted Shootings

DON'T MISS

Taylor Swift Has Regained Control of Her Music, Buys Back First 6 Albums

DON'T MISS

How Trump’s Vow to Revoke Chinese Student Visas Could Hurt California

DON'T MISS

Speaker Johnson Raises Campaign Money in Fresno

DON'T MISS

2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Panthers-Oilers Final Rematch, Who Is Favored and What to Watch For

DON'T MISS

Fire Contained After Visalia House Blaze Prompts Evacuations and Road Closures

UP NEXT

Fresno Unified Communications Boss on Leave After AI-Generated FTA Dossier Debacle

UP NEXT

Visalia Teen Takes Second Place in Dramatic Scripps National Spelling Bee Finals

UP NEXT

Newsom Tussles With Local Officials Over Homelessness

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Arrest Two Women Suspected in Targeted Shootings

UP NEXT

Taylor Swift Has Regained Control of Her Music, Buys Back First 6 Albums

UP NEXT

How Trump’s Vow to Revoke Chinese Student Visas Could Hurt California

UP NEXT

Speaker Johnson Raises Campaign Money in Fresno

UP NEXT

2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Panthers-Oilers Final Rematch, Who Is Favored and What to Watch For

UP NEXT

Fire Contained After Visalia House Blaze Prompts Evacuations and Road Closures

UP NEXT

Brunson, Towns Carry Knicks to Victory That Cuts Pacers’ Series Lead to 3-2

Newsom Tussles With Local Officials Over Homelessness

2 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Two Women Suspected in Targeted Shootings

2 hours ago

Taylor Swift Has Regained Control of Her Music, Buys Back First 6 Albums

2 hours ago

How Trump’s Vow to Revoke Chinese Student Visas Could Hurt California

2 hours ago

Speaker Johnson Raises Campaign Money in Fresno

2 hours ago

2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Panthers-Oilers Final Rematch, Who Is Favored and What to Watch For

2 hours ago

Fire Contained After Visalia House Blaze Prompts Evacuations and Road Closures

3 hours ago

Brunson, Towns Carry Knicks to Victory That Cuts Pacers’ Series Lead to 3-2

3 hours ago

NY Times Bestselling Author Celebrating Book Release at Fresno Barnes & Noble

3 hours ago

Dodgers Acquire Former All-Star Reliever Alexis Díaz in Trade With Cincinnati Reds

3 hours ago

Ray Appleton Set to Resume His KMJ Show. E Curtis Johnson Retires

Ray Appleton is returning to the KMJ airwaves on Monday. He posted an update on Facebook, and his boss — program director and fill-in hos...

10 minutes ago

10 minutes ago

Ray Appleton Set to Resume His KMJ Show. E Curtis Johnson Retires

32 minutes ago

Fresno Unified Communications Boss on Leave After AI-Generated FTA Dossier Debacle

1 hour ago

Visalia Teen Takes Second Place in Dramatic Scripps National Spelling Bee Finals

2 hours ago

Newsom Tussles With Local Officials Over Homelessness

fresno shooting
2 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Two Women Suspected in Targeted Shootings

2 hours ago

Taylor Swift Has Regained Control of Her Music, Buys Back First 6 Albums

2 hours ago

How Trump’s Vow to Revoke Chinese Student Visas Could Hurt California

2 hours ago

Speaker Johnson Raises Campaign Money in Fresno

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend