Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
To Guide Police Reform in Fresno, Look at What the Data Reveals
Opinion
By Opinion
Published 4 years ago on
November 18, 2020

Share

The Fresno Commission for Police Reform was established to examine the future of policing in the City of Fresno. Many claim there is over-policing and discriminatory arrests among segments of our community.

Fresno is not alone. Across the country protests and demonstrations have called for an end to racial injustices in our cities’ police forces. The public discourse has centered on police cultures that promote racial discrimination, pervasive racist institutional practices and policies, while others have attributed the problem to isolated incidents of bad cops. Before there can be meaningful and long-term police reform, community consensus is required on the genesis for the racial disparities in arrests and police shootings. What are the causes? What can be done?

Opinion

Paul Garcia

Dr. Christian Wandeler

Dr. Ken Magdaleno

  

Research-Based Reform Needed

To avoid a myopic view or the politicization of the crisis, a research-based approach could more accurately frame the narrative on police reform. An evidence-based process is necessary to protect the integrity of any reform. The Commission has conducted focus groups and a community wide survey was administered. Other data exists.

In 2015, the California Endowment funded the Center for Leadership, Equity and Research (CLEAR) to conduct research on the status of Boys and Men of Color (BMOC) between the ages of 16 and 24 in the city of Fresno. Among the questions was to examine whether there were disparities in arrest rates between White males and their African American, Latino, and Southeast Asian counterparts.

Data Reveals Racial Disparities

Perhaps, a review of the findings can help determine where police reform should be focused. Data from 2014 was collected from the Fresno County Juvenile Probation and the Fresno Police Department. It found:

  • Among those in Juvenile Hall, Latino males represented 62 percent of all male arrests compared to 24 percent for Blacks, 9 percent for Whites, and 3 percent for Asians.
  • The severity of charges varied by ethnicity/race. Almost two thirds of all arrests for Latino (64%), Black (69%), and Asian (68%) youth were felony counts compared to 50 percent for Whites.
  • Minority youth were more likely to be arrested at an earlier age than White youth. Fifty percent of all misdemeanor arrests of Asian youth occurred among ages 13 to 14. This compares to 46 percent for Black, 40 percent for  Latino, and 36 percent for White youths.
  • Black youths were more likely to be charged with a felony than a misdemeanor when arrested for Burglary (28% felony; 13% misdemeanor), Failure to Obey (29% felony; 13% misdemeanor) and Assault (28% felony; 0% misdemeanor).
  • Among all arrests of male youths and young adults of color, about one-third occurred among the age group 16 to 19, (Black 32%; Latino 30%; Asian, 36%; Whites, 23%).
  • There did not appear to be discernable differences in the number of offenses charged at time of arrest for any ethnic/racial group.

Transparency and Accountability Needed

To what extent does ethnicity and race continue to predict arrest patterns in the city of Fresno? The BMOC study supports the following to supplement the Commission’s work and enhance accountability and transparency in police reform:

  • The police department should produce regular reports on crime trends disaggregated by race/ethnicity, age and gender.
  • In the Annual State of the City, the mayor should report progress toward ending racial disparities in arrests and youth incarcerations.
  • The police department and Fresno Juvenile Probation should provide increased access for researchers and members of the public to examine data on arrests, criminal charges, and incarceration rates.
  • Establish an ad hoc committee to guide and advise the police department on the kinds of data collection and analysis to inform police operations and increase public safety.

Investigate Community Investments to Address Inequities

Police reform and community relations should be framed in the wider context of educational inequities that selectively curtail social mobility among students of color, housing patterns that fuel segregation and define where families can afford to live, and limited employment opportunities that lead to despair and dissolution. While that is not the current charge of the Commission, phase two should examine community investments that can intercede in the disparate arrests of youth and young adults of color.

Programs that focus on rehabilitation, education, and personal development are critical. However, institutional sources of racial discrimination and inequities that contribute to crime also exist outside the police force.

About the Authors 

Paul A. Garcia is a retired educator. Dr. Christian Wandeler is an associate professor with the CSU Fresno Kremen School of Education. Dr. Ken Magdaleno is the founding executive director of the Center for Leadership, Equity, and Research.

DON'T MISS

Tulare Gang Member Gets Life Without Parole for 2022 Murders

DON'T MISS

Will Trump Loyalist Devin Nunes Be Tapped to Head the CIA?

DON'T MISS

Gov. Newsom Said No, but California Voters Overwhelmingly Said Yes

DON'T MISS

Mike Tyson-Jake Paul: How to Watch the Fight, Time, Odds

DON'T MISS

Travel in the West Bank Is a Tale of Two Journeys

DON'T MISS

Chris Wallace Is Leaving CNN, Eager to Explore New Media Landscape

DON'T MISS

Merced’s Iconic Laura Fountain Returns to Splendor With $300K Restoration

DON'T MISS

If You Thought Trump Wasn’t Serious About Deportations, Look at His First Appointments

DON'T MISS

Biden EPA to Charge First-Ever ‘Methane Fee’ for Emissions Waste by Oil and Gas Companies

DON'T MISS

Trump Picks Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee to Be Ambassador to Israel

UP NEXT

Will Trump Loyalist Devin Nunes Be Tapped to Head the CIA?

UP NEXT

Gov. Newsom Said No, but California Voters Overwhelmingly Said Yes

UP NEXT

Mike Tyson-Jake Paul: How to Watch the Fight, Time, Odds

UP NEXT

Travel in the West Bank Is a Tale of Two Journeys

UP NEXT

Chris Wallace Is Leaving CNN, Eager to Explore New Media Landscape

UP NEXT

Merced’s Iconic Laura Fountain Returns to Splendor With $300K Restoration

UP NEXT

If You Thought Trump Wasn’t Serious About Deportations, Look at His First Appointments

UP NEXT

Biden EPA to Charge First-Ever ‘Methane Fee’ for Emissions Waste by Oil and Gas Companies

UP NEXT

Trump Picks Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee to Be Ambassador to Israel

UP NEXT

At the Pandemic’s Start, Americans Began Drinking More. They Still Are.

Mike Tyson-Jake Paul: How to Watch the Fight, Time, Odds

2 hours ago

Travel in the West Bank Is a Tale of Two Journeys

2 hours ago

Chris Wallace Is Leaving CNN, Eager to Explore New Media Landscape

2 hours ago

Merced’s Iconic Laura Fountain Returns to Splendor With $300K Restoration

3 hours ago

If You Thought Trump Wasn’t Serious About Deportations, Look at His First Appointments

3 hours ago

Biden EPA to Charge First-Ever ‘Methane Fee’ for Emissions Waste by Oil and Gas Companies

3 hours ago

Trump Picks Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee to Be Ambassador to Israel

3 hours ago

At the Pandemic’s Start, Americans Began Drinking More. They Still Are.

4 hours ago

Last GOP Congressman Anchored in Democratic LA County Concedes in Race Against Former NASA Exec

4 hours ago

Aid Groups Say Israel Misses US Deadline to Boost Humanitarian Aid Entering Gaza

4 hours ago

Tulare Gang Member Gets Life Without Parole for 2022 Murders

Nathaniel Lujano, 23, of Tulare, was sentenced to life without parole for two murders the Tulare County District Attorney’s Office ann...

13 mins ago

Nathaniel Lujano, 23, of Tulare, a known gang member was sentenced to life without parole for two 2022 murders, committed to benefit a criminal street gang. (Tulare County DA)
13 mins ago

Tulare Gang Member Gets Life Without Parole for 2022 Murders

Photo of Devin Nunes
49 mins ago

Will Trump Loyalist Devin Nunes Be Tapped to Head the CIA?

2 hours ago

Gov. Newsom Said No, but California Voters Overwhelmingly Said Yes

2 hours ago

Mike Tyson-Jake Paul: How to Watch the Fight, Time, Odds

Grigory Kels Tsvi, left, crosses the West Bank on a bus, May 10, 2024. Israel says it manages the roads to reduce friction and prevent militant attacks on Israelis — rights groups say the movement restrictions on Palestinians create deep inequality. (Sergey Ponomarev/The New York Times)
2 hours ago

Travel in the West Bank Is a Tale of Two Journeys

2 hours ago

Chris Wallace Is Leaving CNN, Eager to Explore New Media Landscape

3 hours ago

Merced’s Iconic Laura Fountain Returns to Splendor With $300K Restoration

3 hours ago

If You Thought Trump Wasn’t Serious About Deportations, Look at His First Appointments

Search

Send this to a friend