Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Trump Pushes for Release of Epstein, Maxwell Grand Jury Testimony

3 hours ago

Trump Says US to Hit India With 25% Tariff Starting Friday

3 hours ago

Tariff Revenues Hit Record $150 Billion Amid Trump’s Trade Talks, Fox Business Reports

5 hours ago

Fed Likely to Hold Rates Steady Despite Trump’s Push for Big Cuts

5 hours ago

What’s Behind California’s Frozen Housing Market?

24 hours ago

Oil Prices Rise on Trade War Relief, US Pressure on Russia

1 day ago

Marjorie Taylor Greene Is First Republican Lawmaker to Call Gaza Crisis a ‘Genocide’

1 day ago

UK Will Recognize Palestinian Statehood in September, Barring Israel-Hamas Ceasefire

1 day ago
Prop. 20: Should California’s DNA Bank Expand to Shoplifters, Opioid Offenders?
gvw_calmatters
By CalMatters
Published 5 years ago on
October 19, 2020

Share

DNA evidence — a speckle of spit or a drop of blood — can exonerate a suspect or help put them behind bars. Now California voters are being asked to expand the pool of DNA data that law enforcement taps into.

A little-noticed provision of Proposition 20 would require law enforcement to bank the DNA of people convicted of a long list of misdemeanors. Currently DNA is collected only from arrested and convicted felons, registered sex offenders and arsonists.

Byrhonda Lyons

CalMatters

Prop. 20 would roll back some of the effects of criminal justice reforms that voters approved in 2014’s Proposition 47, which downgraded some felonies to misdemeanors and resulted in fewer DNA profiles in the state’s data bank.

The initiative would reclassify certain misdemeanors as “wobblers” — crimes that can be charged as either misdemeanors or felonies. It would change criteria for considering parole, make some crimes ineligible for early release, create a three-strikes rule for people who violate their post-release supervision and collect DNA samples from people who are convicted of certain misdemeanors.

The list of misdemeanors includes twelve crimes, mainly theft and drug offenses, as well as domestic abuse and prostitution with a minor. If the proposition wins the support of voters, people convicted of those offenses in California would be forced to supply their DNA to be stored permanently in the state’s database.

Prop. 20 supporters, who have raised nearly $5 million, include the Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, Assemblymember Jim Cooper, GOP Congressman Devin Nunes’ campaign committee, the California Grocers Association and the California Correctional Peace Officers Association.

The opposition, which has raised four times more, about $20 million, includes Gov. Gavin Newsom, former Gov. Jerry Brown and a statewide association of probation officers.

Supporters say the initiative will get more DNA into the statewide data bank and could lead to more arrests.

“Oftentimes, folks that have been convicted of those (misdemeanor) crimes lead law enforcement to identify or solve cases that are violent crimes, rape, murders, those types of crimes,” said Sacramento County District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert, who co-authored the proposition. “Prop. 20 deals specifically with individuals that are convicted of theft and drugs that under the current law, because of Prop. 47, we can no longer collect (DNA from) because they’re no longer felonies.”

But opponents like Contra Costa District Attorney Diana Becton aren’t convinced that adding people to the database who have been convicted of shoplifting, forgery, possession of opioids and other relatively minor crimes will help solve violent crimes.

“I don’t know that there’s any correlation between those types of cases (included in Prop. 20) and the solving of violent crime or unsolved murders,” Becton said. “I just don’t think that we have the data to prove that including those cases in the DNA data bank is going to help us solve violent crimes in California.”

Newsom didn’t say why he opposes the measure, only saying in a statement that “there’s more we must do to root out racial inequity and structural bias and to embrace proven reforms that work.”

Civil liberties advocates say that adding DNA profiles of people convicted of misdemeanors will have long-term implications for Black and Latino people and their families.

“The reach of the database effectively includes parents, siblings, children of everyone whose DNA is stored in the database,” said Lizzie Buchen, director of the ACLU’s California Criminal Justice Program. “For that reason, it’s going to result in more communities of color being mistakenly identified as suspects of crimes.”

The state data bank includes DNA from nearly 3 million people. The proposition, if enacted, could expand that by tens of thousands, according to the Legislative Analyst’s Office.

The expansion would add to an already big backlog. As of the end of September, nearly 23,000 samples are waiting to be uploaded to the database.

Andrea Roth, a UC Berkeley law professor, said putting more money into collecting DNA means there will be “less money for testing crime scene samples for DNA.”

“It’s a zero-sum game,” she said. “We really should be putting that money into getting rid of our backlogs in testing crime scene samples. That’s how we’re gonna solve more crimes.”

After peaking in 2009, the year felony arrestees were added to the databank, with samples collected from about 300,000 convicted felons, DNA submissions have steadily declined in California. In 2013, a year before voters approved Prop. 47, the state logged about 168,000 DNA samples. Now, the state averages about 100,000 samples each year, according to the Legislative Analyst’s Office. The main reason for the decline is that felony arrests are down since Prop. 47 passed. At the same time, misdemeanor arrests have grown, especially violent and drug-related misdemeanors.

DNA and High-Profile Arrests

California’s DNA databank is famous for cracking high-profile cold cases. It helped catch the Grim Sleeper. But it also led to the wrong person spending time behind bars.

According to the state attorney general’s office, the California State DNA Index System has helped with 104,368 state and national investigations.

When there are hits, they can sometimes bring closure to crimes that have haunted victims and communities for decades.

Investigators also can seek permission from the state Department of Justice to tap into the DNA database for a familial search, which means checking for genetic similarities that identify relatives.

When Christopher Franklin was sent to prison for a felony weapons charge, he had to submit a DNA profile. His genetic material was similar to that of DNA found at the scene of a serial killer who had murdered at least 10 women and girls in the Los Angeles area. It was the state’s first familial DNA search, and it ended with Franklin’s father, Lonnie David Franklin, Jr.,  identified as the Grim Sleeper.

That was 2008. Since then, familial searches have helped solve multiple cases, most famously, the Golden State Killer, Joseph James DeAngelo Jr., who committed dozens of rapes and at least 13 murders. (He was tracked through a private ancestry database.)

DNA evidence, however, is not infallible.

When 26-year-old Lukis Anderson was charged with murdering Raveesh Kumra, the case seemed clear. Anderson’s DNA was found under Kumra’s fingernails. Anderson was in jail for months before investigators realized they had made a mistake. Anderson’s DNA was under Kumara’s fingernails because they rode in the same ambulance that night. His DNA was at the wrong place at the wrong time.

Some opponents of adding misdemeanors to the DNA database are concerned that people of color are overrepresented.

Blacks make up 17% of California’s DNA profiles, while representing 6% of the state’s population, according to a study by New York University School of Law professors.

“People of color are more likely to be convicted of these offenses because they’re more likely to be searched and stopped and really implicated at all stages of the criminal justice system,” said the ACLU’s Buchen. “These negative consequences, unfortunately, (are) felt by people of color.”

Orange County’s Experience

As California voters decide whether people convicted of misdemeanors deserve to be added into the statewide database, Orange County can provide some lessons: It started logging DNA samples for some people charged with nonviolent misdemeanors back in 2007.

After forgoing their rights to challenge the legality of the program, offenders can volunteer to pay $110, provide their DNA and get a plea deal or have their misdemeanors dismissed.

It’s called Spit and Acquit, available only to people charged with nonviolent misdemeanors.

Spit and Acquit is a byproduct of Proposition 69, which was co-authored by an Orange County assistant district attorney. The initiative allowed DNA samples to be collected as a part of plea negotiations.

According to Orange County Assistant District Attorney Tammy Spurgeon, the county’s database includes about 195,000 DNA profiles. There have been about 2,000 hits by investigators looking for suspects.

“It’s always been our theory that people who commit violent crimes also commit…minor crimes. And so, getting these people into the system as misdemeanors, getting their DNA, it helps us identify them when they do commit that violent crime,” Spurgeon said.

But critics say that adding so many people convicted of minor crimes could eventually mean that virtually everyone has their DNA on file.

“It’s a significant leap to include any misdemeanors because simply being convicted for a misdemeanor, we wouldn’t expect that to make you that much more likely than the rest of the population to be committing DNA solvable offenses in the future,” Roth said.

“If it’s okay to take to force DNA from people just convicted of misdemeanor drug possession, for example, then the rest of us can’t really be far behind.”

About the Author 

Byrhonda Lyons is a national award-winning video journalist for CalMatters. She creates compelling multimedia stories about how California policy affects people’s everyday lives. From the state’s mental health crisis, to an investigation into shady state contractors, her work aims to hold politicians accountable and educate Californians about the ins and outs of their state government. 

[activecampaign form=19]

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Kamala Harris Will Not Run for Governor of California in 2026

DON'T MISS

How Netanyahu Keeps Playing Trump for a Fool in Gaza

DON'T MISS

Trump Signs Order Implementing Additional 40% Tariff on Brazil, White House Says

DON'T MISS

Could Madera Poach Stalled Costco? It’d Be ‘a Significant Financial Blow,’ Says Dyer

DON'T MISS

Trump Pushes for Release of Epstein, Maxwell Grand Jury Testimony

DON'T MISS

Clovis Police Arrest Eight at DUI Checkpoint

DON'T MISS

Trump Says US to Hit India With 25% Tariff Starting Friday

DON'T MISS

Republican US Senator Grassley Clashes With Trump Over Nominations

DON'T MISS

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Navpreet Singh

DON'T MISS

Tariff Revenues Hit Record $150 Billion Amid Trump’s Trade Talks, Fox Business Reports

UP NEXT

Bains Is Challenging Valadao. An Early Look at Fundraising.

UP NEXT

CIA Review Finds Flaws but Does Not Dispute Finding Putin Sought to Sway 2016 Vote to Trump

UP NEXT

Zohran Mamdani Officially Wins Democratic Primary for New York City Mayor

UP NEXT

Gavin Newsom Finally Admits He’s Contemplating a Run for President

UP NEXT

5 Takeaways From the Democrats’ Final NYC Mayoral Debate

UP NEXT

US Judge Blocks Trump Administration From Overhauling Federal Elections

UP NEXT

Trans Athlete Competes in California Championships in Clovis Despite National Controversy

UP NEXT

Tim Walz Urges Democrats to Fight Back Harder Against ‘Bully’ Trump

UP NEXT

Republican Tuberville Announces Bid for Alabama Governor

UP NEXT

Why Kamala Harris Could Run for California Governor and Bypass Another White House Bid

Could Madera Poach Stalled Costco? It’d Be ‘a Significant Financial Blow,’ Says Dyer

2 hours ago

Trump Pushes for Release of Epstein, Maxwell Grand Jury Testimony

3 hours ago

Clovis Police Arrest Eight at DUI Checkpoint

3 hours ago

Trump Says US to Hit India With 25% Tariff Starting Friday

3 hours ago

Republican US Senator Grassley Clashes With Trump Over Nominations

3 hours ago

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Navpreet Singh

5 hours ago

Tariff Revenues Hit Record $150 Billion Amid Trump’s Trade Talks, Fox Business Reports

5 hours ago

White House Set to Unveil Closely Watched Crypto Policy Report

5 hours ago

Warner or Conklin? Fresno State QB Battle Builds Ahead of Kansas Opener

5 hours ago

Protein Bar Arms Race Is Waged on Store Shelves and Social Media

5 hours ago

Kamala Harris Will Not Run for Governor of California in 2026

Democratic former U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris said on Wednesday she will not run for governor of California, ending speculation that t...

42 minutes ago

Former U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris attends the 56th NAACP Image Awards at the Pasadena Civic Auditorium in Pasadena, California, U.S. February 22, 2025. (Reuters FIle)
42 minutes ago

Kamala Harris Will Not Run for Governor of California in 2026

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
1 hour ago

How Netanyahu Keeps Playing Trump for a Fool in Gaza

President Donald Trump speaks at a dinner with Republican Senators, in the State Dining Room at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., July 18, 2025. (Reuters File)
1 hour ago

Trump Signs Order Implementing Additional 40% Tariff on Brazil, White House Says

A map showing the Herndon/Riverside Costco location with a big arrow pointing to Hwy 99/Avenue 7 and a big question mark.
2 hours ago

Could Madera Poach Stalled Costco? It’d Be ‘a Significant Financial Blow,’ Says Dyer

Jeffrey Epstein associate Ghislaine Maxwell listens to her sentencing from Judge Alison Nathan in a courtroom sketch in New York City, U.S. June 28, 2022. (Reuters File)
3 hours ago

Trump Pushes for Release of Epstein, Maxwell Grand Jury Testimony

3 hours ago

Clovis Police Arrest Eight at DUI Checkpoint

President Donald Trump and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi shake hands, at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., February 13, 2025. (Reuters File)
3 hours ago

Trump Says US to Hit India With 25% Tariff Starting Friday

President Donald Trump walks on the South Lawn as he arrives at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., July 13, 2025. (Reuters File)
3 hours ago

Republican US Senator Grassley Clashes With Trump Over Nominations

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend