Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Storyland Will Sparkle for All Visitors With $1 Million City of Fresno Grant

7 hours ago

Ozzy Osbourne, Black Sabbath’s Bat-Biting Frontman, Dies at 76, BBC Reports

12 hours ago

What’s Fresno County Worth? Property Tax Roll Grows by Billions of Dollars

14 hours ago

Fresno County Authorities Seek Help Locating Missing Woman and Infant

14 hours ago

Maddy Institute Fundraiser to Highlight Central Valley’s Impact at State Capitol

14 hours ago

No Aid Supplies Left and Staff Are Starving in Gaza, Says Norwegian Refugee Council

15 hours ago

US Justice Dept. Asks Epstein Associate Maxwell to Speak to Prosecutors

15 hours ago

Trump’s Golden Dome Looks for Alternatives to Musk’s SpaceX

15 hours ago

Fresno Unified’s Free Immunization Clinics for Students Start in August

17 hours ago
Big Oil Loses Appeal, Climate Suits Go to California Courts
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
May 27, 2020

Share

LOS ANGELES — Big Oil lost a pair of court battles Tuesday that could lead to trials in lawsuits by California cities and counties seeking damages for the impact of climate change.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected arguments by energy companies and ruled state courts are the proper forum for lawsuits alleging producers promoted petroleum as environmentally responsible when they knew it was contributing to drought, wildfires, and sea level rise associated with global warming.

The lawsuits claim Chevron, Exxon Mobil, ConocoPhillips, BP, Royal Dutch Shell and other companies created a public nuisance and should pay for damage from climate change and help build sea walls and other infrastructure to protect against future impact — construction that could cost tens of billions of dollars.

The lawsuits claim Chevron, Exxon Mobil, ConocoPhillips, BP, Royal Dutch Shell and other companies created a public nuisance and should pay for damage from climate change and help build sea walls and other infrastructure to protect against future impact — construction that could cost tens of billions of dollars.

The ruling overturned a decision by one federal judge, who had tossed out lawsuits brought by the cities of San Francisco and Oakland.

“It is time for these companies to pay their fair share,” San Francisco City Attorney Dennis Herrera said in a statement applauding the ruling. “They should not be able to stick taxpayers with the bill for the damage they knew they were causing. We will continue to hold these companies accountable for their decades-long campaign of public deception about climate change and its consequences.”

While the rulings were victories for the coastal counties and cities — all in the San Francisco Bay Area except for the tiny city of Imperial Beach in San Diego County — and cheered by environmental groups, it could take years before they ever get to a jury, if they make it that far.

The 3-0 rulings are expected to meet continued challenges that could include a review by a larger 9th Circuit panel and, eventually, review by the U.S. Supreme Court.

An appeals court in Virginia ruled that a similar case brought by Baltimore belonged in Maryland courts and lower federal courts in other cities have issued similar decisions.

A group that is a project of the National Association of Manufacturers issued a statement saying climate liability lawsuits should be resolved by the Supreme Court to prevent years of court proceedings.

Chevron did not say how it would proceed but said the cases involve issues of national law and policy and do not belong in state courts.

The Companies Had Argued That Federal Law Controls Fossil Fuel Production

“In whichever forum the cases are ultimately determined, these factually and legally unsupported claims do nothing to sensibly address the significant national economic, legal and policy issues presented by climate change,” said Sean Comey, a Chevron spokesman.

Ann Carlson, an environmental law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles, said the rulings move the cases closer to the discovery process and requesting potentially damaging documents.

“This means they can depose top executives about what they knew and when they knew it and what oil companies did to fund a campaign to dissuade the American public that climate change was happening,” said Carlson, who has provided free counsel to cities in the cases. “The oil companies’ strategy is to keep the light from shining on their own behavior. This gets closer to allowing plaintiffs to shine that light.”

The ruling written by Judge Sandra Ikuta, picked for the court by President George W. Bush, move the cases back to state courts, where they were initially filed. The other judges on the panel were nominated by Presidents Barack Obama and Donald Trump.

Oil companies got the cases transferred to San Francisco federal court, where two judges reached different conclusions.

After holding a unique five-hour “tutorial” by top researchers on the science of climate change, U.S. District Judge William Alsup in 2018 threw out the Oakland and San Francisco litigation. He ruled Congress and the president — not the courts —- were best suited to address the contribution of fossil fuels to global warming.

“The problem deserves a solution on a more vast scale than can be supplied by a district judge or jury in a public nuisance case,” Alsup wrote.

In cases brought by the the counties of San Mateo, Marin and Santa Cruz, and the cities of Richmond and Imperial Beach, Judge Vincent Chhabria ruled the cases belonged in state court, but he allowed the oil companies to appeal.

The companies had argued that federal law controls fossil fuel production, and Congress has encouraged oil and gas development. They said the harm claimed was “speculative” and part of a complex chain of events that includes billions of oil and gas users and “environmental phenomena occurring worldwide over many decades.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Trump Announces Trade Deal With Japan, Including 15% Tariff

DON'T MISS

Why American Jews No Longer Understand One Another

DON'T MISS

Visalia DUI Operation Nets 17 Arrests Over Weekend

DON'T MISS

Storyland Will Sparkle for All Visitors With $1 Million City of Fresno Grant

DON'T MISS

Former Madera Charter School Executive Charged With Embezzling Federal Funds

DON'T MISS

Fresno Unified Doesn’t Respond to Public Records Requests. Is District Hiding Something?

DON'T MISS

US Appeals Court Will Not Lift Limits on Associated Press Access to White House

DON'T MISS

Feds Award $93 Million to Key San Joaquin River Salmon Restoration Project

DON'T MISS

With Backing From Dyer, Ashjian Reinstated to Measure C Panel

DON'T MISS

Fresno Shooting Leaves One Dead, Authorities Looking for Witnesses

UP NEXT

NPR’s Top Editor Edith Chapin to Step Down

UP NEXT

Less Than 400 EV Charging Ports Built Under $7.5 Billion US Infrastructure Program

UP NEXT

California Voters Say State Is Off Course. Housing Emerges as Top Concern

UP NEXT

Fresno County Authorities Seek Help Locating Missing Woman and Infant

UP NEXT

Americans’ Confidence in Institutions Remains Low. Divides by Party Widen

UP NEXT

US Judge Sentences Ex-Police Officer to 33 Months for Violating Civil Rights of Breonna Taylor

UP NEXT

Should ICE Agents Wear Masks? LA Mayor Bass Says No

UP NEXT

Brother of Army Ranger and NFL Star Pat Tillman Crashes Into Post Office

UP NEXT

How Will KVPR and Valley PBS Deal With Loss of Federal Funding?

UP NEXT

At Least 30 Injured When Car Hits Crowd Outside Los Angeles Club, Fire Department Says

Storyland Will Sparkle for All Visitors With $1 Million City of Fresno Grant

7 hours ago

Former Madera Charter School Executive Charged With Embezzling Federal Funds

7 hours ago

Fresno Unified Doesn’t Respond to Public Records Requests. Is District Hiding Something?

8 hours ago

US Appeals Court Will Not Lift Limits on Associated Press Access to White House

8 hours ago

Feds Award $93 Million to Key San Joaquin River Salmon Restoration Project

8 hours ago

With Backing From Dyer, Ashjian Reinstated to Measure C Panel

9 hours ago

Fresno Shooting Leaves One Dead, Authorities Looking for Witnesses

9 hours ago

Epstein Files Fight Leads US House Republicans to Start Summer Break a Day Early

10 hours ago

Obama Reiterates Conclusion of Attempted Russian Interference in 2016 Election

10 hours ago

What Do Fresno Families Pay in Taxes? Study Says 11th Lowest Rate in Nation

11 hours ago

Trump Announces Trade Deal With Japan, Including 15% Tariff

WASHINGTON – President Donald Trump on Tuesday announced a trade deal with Japan that he said will result in Japan investing $550 bill...

6 hours ago

Containers are pictured at an industrial port in Tokyo, Japan, July 2, 2025. (Reuters File)
6 hours ago

Trump Announces Trade Deal With Japan, Including 15% Tariff

American Jews are fracturing over Israel’s war in Gaza, as a generational divide deepens between older Jews who see Israel as essential for Jewish survival and younger Jews who view its actions as a moral crisis incompatible with liberal values. (Shutterstock)
6 hours ago

Why American Jews No Longer Understand One Another

7 hours ago

Visalia DUI Operation Nets 17 Arrests Over Weekend

7 hours ago

Storyland Will Sparkle for All Visitors With $1 Million City of Fresno Grant

A U.S. Justice Department logo or seal showing Justice Department headquarters, known as "Main Justice," is seen behind the podium in the Department's headquarters briefing room before a news conference with the Attorney General in Washington, January 24, 2023. (Reuters File)
7 hours ago

Former Madera Charter School Executive Charged With Embezzling Federal Funds

FUSD Fresno Unified paper shredder gvwire
8 hours ago

Fresno Unified Doesn’t Respond to Public Records Requests. Is District Hiding Something?

AP's members leave the U.S. District Court, on the day a judge hears arguments in the Associated Press' (AP) bid to restore access for its journalists to cover press events aboard Air Force One and at the White House, after the Trump administration barred the news agency for continuing to refer to the Gulf of Mexico in its coverage, in Washington, D.C., U.S., March 27, 2025. (Reuters File)
8 hours ago

US Appeals Court Will Not Lift Limits on Associated Press Access to White House

Artist Rendering of Sack Dame and Arroyo Canal Project Site for San Joaquin River Salmon Restoration Project
8 hours ago

Feds Award $93 Million to Key San Joaquin River Salmon Restoration Project

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend