Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Called to Order: Supreme Court Begins 1st Arguments by Phone
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
May 4, 2020

Share

WASHINGTON — It’s a morning of firsts for the Supreme Court, the first time audio of the court’s arguments was heard live by the world and the first arguments by telephone.

The changes are a result of the coronavirus pandemic, which has made holding courtroom sessions unsafe, especially with six justices aged 65 or older and at risk of getting seriously sick from the virus.

Arguments, scheduled to last an hour as they would generally in the courtroom, ran 17 minutes long, but without serious problems. The justices asked roughly two questions apiece at a time, and Roberts occasionally interjected to keep things moving.

The historic session began at the usual time of 10 a.m. EDT, when Marshal Pamela Talkin called the court to order and Chief Justice John Roberts announced the day’s case.

“Oyez! Oyez! Oyez!” Talkin began, dropping the words commanding people “to draw near” to reflect the unusual circumstances.

Arguments, scheduled to last an hour as they would generally in the courtroom, ran 17 minutes long, but without serious problems. The justices asked roughly two questions apiece at a time, and Roberts occasionally interjected to keep things moving.

And there was one mild surprise: Justice Clarence Thomas asked questions for the first time in more than a year.

Several justices said “good morning” to the lawyers, a telephone nicety not often heard in the courtroom. The justices also did not interrupt each other, as they frequently do in court, and instead took turns asking questions.

The court’s plaza, normally bustling on the mornings of arguments, was deserted Monday, as it has been since the building was closed to the public in mid-March because of the virus outbreak. Two months of arguments were postponed before the court decided to hear 10 cases over six days in May.

The experiment could propel the court to routinely livestream its arguments. Or it could just be an extraordinary exception to the court’s sustained opposition to broadening the audience that can hear, if not see, its work live.

Cases that will be heard over the next two weeks include President Donald Trump’s effort to shield tax and other financial records and whether presidential electors have to cast their Electoral College ballots for the candidate who wins the popular vote in their state.

Justices Chose to Hear Obscure Case

The court chose a somewhat obscure case about whether the travel website Booking.com can trademark its name for its first foray into remote arguments. The lawyers on both sides are well known to the justices and experienced in arguing before the nation’s highest court.

Justice Department lawyer Erica Ross, who once served as a law clerk to Justice Elena Kagan, was first up. She last argued at the court in late February. She delivered this Supreme Court argument, her sixth, from a Justice Department conference room.

She was followed by Lisa Blatt, a onetime government lawyer who will be arguing her 40th Supreme Court case. Blatt will be at her Washington-area home, she told The Washington Post.

She is known for her colorful writing and speaking style and for her ability to engage in a healthy give and take with the justices. She was also a prominent liberal supporter of Justice Brett Kavanaugh during his contentious Senate confirmation hearings for the Supreme Court.

Blatt, representing Booking.com, got Justice Sonia Sotomayor to laugh out loud when she told the justice, “It looks like we would have lost if you were the trial judge.”

Each lawyer got two uninterrupted minutes to make an opening statement, after which Roberts kicked off the questioning. After that, the justices asked questions in order of seniority. Kavanaugh, who joined the court in 2018, went last.

The court sometimes issues opinions at the start of argument sessions, with the justice who wrote for the majority reading a summary of the opinion and, more rarely, a second justice summarizing a dissent. But in another change wrought by the virus outbreak, opinions are being posted online without any statements from justices. The court will next issue opinions on Thursday.

The session ended as it always does in the courtroom. Roberts said, “The case is submitted.”

Talkin followed: “The honorable court is now adjourned until tomorrow at 10 o’clock.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Fresno City Council Opposes Parole for the ‘Tower Rapist’

DON'T MISS

Sanger Police Seek Public’s Help in Locating Missing At-Risk Teen

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Shoot Suspect in Head After Hostage Situation Near Manchester Center

DON'T MISS

Valley Crime Stoppers Offers $25,000 Reward to Find Escaped Murderer

DON'T MISS

‘Independent’ Vang Starts Work as New Fresno Councilmember. Cancels Tavlian Contract.

DON'T MISS

He Spent Decades Researching Dementia. Trump’s DEI Purge Killed His Grant, and Dozens More

DON'T MISS

Other States Do Housing Better Than California; a New Study Shows How They Do It

DON'T MISS

Trump Administration Task Force to Consider Declassifying COVID-19 Origins Materials

DON'T MISS

At the Supreme Court, the Trump Agenda Is Always an ‘Emergency’

DON'T MISS

Wing of Plane Carrying 6 Members of Congress Is Clipped at Reagan Airport

UP NEXT

Helicopter Has Crashed in the Hudson River off Manhattan, Authorities Say

UP NEXT

Fewer Americans Say the Israel-Hamas War Is Important: Survey

UP NEXT

Wood Has 2 Homers as Nats Win For First Home Series Victory Over Dodgers Since 2014

UP NEXT

Giants Suffer Second Straight Shutout Loss to Reds

UP NEXT

Curry Scores 25 as the Warriors Cruise Past the Suns in West Playoff Race

UP NEXT

Man Pleads Guilty to Trying to Assassinate Justice Kavanaugh

UP NEXT

Trump Administration to Roll Back Array of Gun Control Measures

UP NEXT

This Is Who Trump Has Targeted for Retribution

UP NEXT

Signs of a More Buyer-Friendly Housing Market Emerge for Spring

UP NEXT

Castellanos’ Grand Slam Helps Phillies Beat Dodgers, Take 2 of 3 From World Series Champions

Valley Crime Stoppers Offers $25,000 Reward to Find Escaped Murderer

1 hour ago

‘Independent’ Vang Starts Work as New Fresno Councilmember. Cancels Tavlian Contract.

2 hours ago

He Spent Decades Researching Dementia. Trump’s DEI Purge Killed His Grant, and Dozens More

3 hours ago

Other States Do Housing Better Than California; a New Study Shows How They Do It

3 hours ago

Trump Administration Task Force to Consider Declassifying COVID-19 Origins Materials

3 hours ago

At the Supreme Court, the Trump Agenda Is Always an ‘Emergency’

3 hours ago

Wing of Plane Carrying 6 Members of Congress Is Clipped at Reagan Airport

3 hours ago

Trump Repeals Biden-Era Limit on Water Flow in Shower Heads

3 hours ago

Helicopter Has Crashed in the Hudson River off Manhattan, Authorities Say

3 hours ago

Social Security Rolls Back Restrictions on Filing for Benefits by Phone

4 hours ago

Fresno City Council Opposes Parole for the ‘Tower Rapist’

The Fresno City Council wants the Tower Rapist to stay in prison. Rudolph Martin Acosta has been in prison since 1992, serving 78 years a...

19 minutes ago

19 minutes ago

Fresno City Council Opposes Parole for the ‘Tower Rapist’

The Sanger Police Department is seeking the public's help in locating Mellissa Rocker, 15, who went missing from her home on Saturday, April 5, 2024, and was last seen in Fresno. (Sanger PD)
29 minutes ago

Sanger Police Seek Public’s Help in Locating Missing At-Risk Teen

Fresno police shot a female suspect in the head on Thursday, April 10, 2025, after she took a woman hostage with a knife near Manchester Center, and the suspect remains in critical condition while the hostage was unharmed. (Fresno PD)
49 minutes ago

Fresno Police Shoot Suspect in Head After Hostage Situation Near Manchester Center

Authorities in Delano are searching for escaped inmate Cesar Hernandez, 34, who fled CDCR custody Tuesday and is considered dangerous. (Delano PD)
1 hour ago

Valley Crime Stoppers Offers $25,000 Reward to Find Escaped Murderer

2 hours ago

‘Independent’ Vang Starts Work as New Fresno Councilmember. Cancels Tavlian Contract.

3 hours ago

He Spent Decades Researching Dementia. Trump’s DEI Purge Killed His Grant, and Dozens More

3 hours ago

Other States Do Housing Better Than California; a New Study Shows How They Do It

Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, flanked by FBI Director Kash Patel, left, and CIA Director John Ratcliffe, testifies as the House Intelligence Committee holds a hearing on worldwide threats, at the Capitol, in Washington, Wednesday, March 26, 2025. (AP/J. Scott Applewhite)
3 hours ago

Trump Administration Task Force to Consider Declassifying COVID-19 Origins Materials

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend