Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California Cities Want Transparency Rules Waived in Pandemic
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
April 1, 2020

Share

SAN FRANCISCO — Citing the unprecedented challenges created by the coronavirus pandemic, city officials across California are asking Gov. Gavin Newsom to suspend or delay numerous state laws, saying they can’t comply with everything from environmental regulations to public records laws that give people a window into how the government is spending public money.

Spokeswoman Kayla Woods said the group is not seeking to suspend all public records requests, but wants “flexibility to cities if their ability to respond to certain PRA requests is limited due to decreased staffing or closure of city facilities.”

Noting that “city resources and personnel are stretched thin” responding to the pandemic, the executive director of the League of California Cities asked Newsom last week to “take immediate action to pause certain statutory requirements.”

The league that represents nearly 500 cities is seeking to delay the state’s constitutionally mandated California Public Records Act, which requires transparency in government decision-making and spending. The law requires public agencies to respond to requests for information within 10 days, though many routinely drag their feet with legally allowed extensions.

Spokeswoman Kayla Woods said the group is not seeking to suspend all public records requests, but wants “flexibility to cities if their ability to respond to certain PRA requests is limited due to decreased staffing or closure of city facilities.” She said the delay would be limited to records requests “other than those created during, and relating to, the COVID-19 crisis.”

“Cities have varying levels of staffing and resources, and are focusing nearly all of their efforts on responding to this public health crisis,” Woods said in an email.

The danger with suspending such laws, even partially or temporarily, “is that the public won’t know and won’t have ability to oversee financial improprieties, public employee wrongdoing, fraud — myriad important aspects of the government will not be able to be seen by the public if the public doesn’t have access to public records,” said Duffy Carolan, a San Francisco attorney who represents media outlets.

Newsom Has Already Waived Regulations on Everything From Hospital Staffing to School Funding

The league’s request comes as governments worldwide are spending billions of dollars, often through contracts with private companies, to build emergency hospitals, acquire hotel rooms and buy much-needed personal protective equipment. In California alone, the state Legislature approved $1 billion in emergency spending that will filter out to local governments.

Newsom has already waived regulations on everything from hospital staffing to school funding in sweeping executive orders. He temporarily suspended parts of the state’s open meeting laws, allowing boards and commissions to meet and vote by teleconference and exempting rules that people be allowed to speak in person.

The governor’s office did not respond to a request Tuesday from The Associated Press Tuesday asking whether he is considering any more such suspensions.

Across the U.S., governors, lawmakers, mayors and county officials have already opted to keep the public away from public meetings for the sake of health. Federal agencies have cited the crisis in refusing to respond to records requests. In California, the mayor of San Francisco suspended the city’s stringent Sunshine Law and Fresno’s city council voted to suspend the entire California Public Records Act.

In response, 132 good government and media companies have urged governments to redouble transparency during the crisis, saying credibility is more critical than ever.

“As people are asked to make increasing sacrifices in their daily lives for the greater good of public health, the legitimacy of government decision-making requires a renewed commitment to transparency,” the groups wrote.

In response to his request for emails related to Sonoma County’s coronavirus response, county officials told Santa Rosa Press-Democrat reporter Tyler Silvy that “the public’s interest is not served by diverting staff resources away from essential emergency response work to immediately respond to records requests.” In subsequent correspondence, a county attorney told Silvy the county would process such requests when normal business resumes.

[covid-19-tracker]

The League of California Cities Requested a Host of Delays in Its Six-Page Letter

Aaron Field, a San Francisco attorney who specializes in media law and is co-chair of the Northern California Society of Professional Journalists’ freedom of information committee, noted that the California Supreme Court has said open government “is essential to the functioning of society,” so the bar for suspending such a rule — even temporarily — should be high.

“In the midst of a crisis in which the government is more involved in our daily lives than it has ever been in my memory, it’s more important than ever for public access to be preserved.” Aaron Field, a San Francisco attorney who specializes in media law and is co-chair of the Northern California Society of Professional Journalists’ freedom of information committee 

“In the midst of a crisis in which the government is more involved in our daily lives than it has ever been in my memory, it’s more important than ever for public access to be preserved,” he said.

The League of California Cities requested a host of delays in its six-page letter. Woods, the league’s spokeswoman, said many city employees who would normally work on fulfilling statutory requirements “have been pulled from their regular assignments to work on these vital emergency response efforts.”

The League is requesting delays to numerous waivers and deadlines, including for construction project approvals, housing reviews and annual staff salary information. It also seeks to:

— Suspend a California law requiring public officials to file statements of economic interest that can show conflicts of interest and weighing fees for late submissions, which California’s Fair Political Practices Commission approved. Woods said the suspension ensures that local leaders can focus on responding to the crisis.

— Delay some parts of California’s environmental law by four months, including the need to hold timely meetings and a rule requiring California Environmental Quality Act reviews to be completed within a year.

— Cut by 25% the locally required spending on some transportation projects, which governments have previously sought to waive; and extend the deadline to approve some construction projects.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

NFL Owners Unanimously Approve Player Participation in Olympic Flag Football for 2028

DON'T MISS

Madera Police Arrest Man for Concealed Black Powder Derringer

DON'T MISS

Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and the Thunder Beat the Rested Timberwolves in Game 1 of West Finals

DON'T MISS

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Chad Owen Baugus

DON'T MISS

Birdsong Pitches the Giants Past the Royals in His 1st Start of Season

DON'T MISS

Dodgers’ Yoshinobu Yamamoto Goes 7 Scoreless Innings in Win Over Diamondbacks

DON'T MISS

Israel Intercepts Missile from Yemen as Houthi Attacks Continue

DON'T MISS

US Army to Change Transgender Soldiers’ Records to Birth Sex

DON'T MISS

UK Pauses Trade Deal Talks With Israel, Summons Ambassador Over New Gaza Offensive

DON'T MISS

Gaza Still Waiting for Aid as Pressure Mounts on Israel

UP NEXT

Why California’s Biggest Local Effort to Fight Homelessness Is Starting All Over Again

UP NEXT

GV Wire Takes Home 14 California News Reporting Awards

UP NEXT

Bubic’s 7 Shutout Innings and Pasquantino’s Homer Lift the Royals Over the Giants

UP NEXT

Should CA’s Climate Budget Pay for High-Speed Rail, Firefighters?

UP NEXT

CBS News President McMahon to Step Down, Memo Shows

UP NEXT

One Killed in ‘Intentional’ Explosion Outside Palm Springs Fertility Clinic, Police Say

UP NEXT

Police and Firefighters Respond to an Explosion Rocking the California City of Palm Springs

UP NEXT

Israel Launches a New Military Operation in Gaza a Day After Trump Leaves the Middle East

UP NEXT

Kristen Stewart Was Always Ready to Direct

UP NEXT

Severe Weather Leaves at Least 23 Dead, Including 14 in Storm-Battered Kentucky

Netanyahu Says Israel Probably Killed Hamas Leader Mohammed Sinwar

49 minutes ago

California Cop Was Partying at Festival While Collecting $600,000 for Fake Injury

52 minutes ago

Attorney: Fresno Unified Needs to Find ‘Nearest Exit’ in Defamation Lawsuit

1 hour ago

Trump Presses False ‘Genocide’ Narrative in Tense Meeting With South African Leader

1 hour ago

Here’s What to Expect at the Army’s 250th Anniversary Parade on Trump’s Birthday

2 hours ago

Fresno EOC Spending Depleted $8 Million Reserve. Agency Needed $5 Million Loan to Survive

2 hours ago

Defense Department Accepts Boeing 747 From Qatar for Trump’s Use

2 hours ago

Hundreds Attend Measure C Meeting. Will Their Voices Be Heard?

2 hours ago

Defense Department Accepts Boeing 747 From Qatar for Trump’s Use

2 hours ago

Wall Street Stocks Slip as Treasury Yields Rise on Worries About Trump Tax Cuts

3 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Felon on Probation After Finding Concealed Gun

A man on probation for a prior weapons conviction was arrested after Fresno police say they found a concealed firearm during a traffic stop ...

13 minutes ago

Fresno Police arrested a man on probation after finding a concealed firearm during a traffic stop near Belmont Avenue and Parkway Drive. (Fresno PD)
13 minutes ago

Fresno Police Arrest Felon on Probation After Finding Concealed Gun

29 minutes ago

What Does It Mean for Biden’s Prostate Cancer to Be ‘Aggressive’? A Urologic Surgeon Explains

32 minutes ago

Wired Wednesday: As Gold Hits Record High, People Cash In

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks during a press conference, in Jerusalem, May 21, 2025. REUTERS/Ronen Zvulun/Pool
49 minutes ago

Netanyahu Says Israel Probably Killed Hamas Leader Mohammed Sinwar

52 minutes ago

California Cop Was Partying at Festival While Collecting $600,000 for Fake Injury

1 hour ago

Attorney: Fresno Unified Needs to Find ‘Nearest Exit’ in Defamation Lawsuit

1 hour ago

Trump Presses False ‘Genocide’ Narrative in Tense Meeting With South African Leader

2 hours ago

Here’s What to Expect at the Army’s 250th Anniversary Parade on Trump’s Birthday

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend