Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Even More Confusion Over Tax Vote
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 4 years ago on
March 16, 2020

Share

Throughout California, local government and school officials have been stunned by voters’ reluctance this month to approve new taxes and bonds.
The California Taxpayers Association has reported that more than half of the local measures appeared to fail on March 3, although some may squeak through when all votes are tallied.


Dan Walters
Opinion
One of the casualties appears to be San Diego’s Measure C, backed by Mayor Kevin Faulconer and local business and labor interests, which would have boosted hotel taxes for expansion of the city’s convention center, curbing homelessness and street repairs.
As of last week, Measure C had about 65% of  San Diegans’ votes, a clear majority but shy of the two-thirds margin California law and San Diego’s city attorney say are required, thus folding it into a legal conflict that’s been simmering for the past three years.
State law says that “special purpose” taxes, which Measure C clearly is, must have two-thirds approval by voters. But three years ago, the state Supreme Court cast doubt on that principle in upholding the basic right of voters to impose taxes via the initiative process.

Some Tax Measures Failing to Receive Two-Thirds Votes Have Been Validated by Judges

Writing the 5-2 majority opinion, Justice Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar declared, “Multiple provisions of the state Constitution explicitly constrain the power of local governments to raise taxes. But we will not lightly apply such restrictions on local governments to voter initiatives.”
He thus implied that special purpose taxes placed on the ballot by voters via initiative may not be affected by the two-thirds vote requirement, but was not explicit, touching off a running legal battle.
Since then, some special tax measures failing to receive two-thirds votes have been validated by local judges, citing Cuéllar’s opinion, but most have not.
An early test arose in two San Francisco tax measures, both placed on the ballot in 2018 via initiatives personally sponsored by members of the city’s Board of Supervisors, one for early childhood education, the other to battle homelessness.
Both received less than two-thirds votes, but a local judge, Ethan Schulman, validated them anyway.
However, Fresno Superior Court Judge Kimberly Gaab went the other way on a sales tax measure to improve city parks. The tax hike received just 52.2% of the votes and when its sponsors sued to have it declared a winner, Gaab wrote, “The two-thirds vote requirement applies to all special tax proposals, regardless of the proponent of the proposal.”

Sooner Would Be Better Than Later as the Roster of Disputed Tax Measures Grows

Her interpretation was echoed by Alameda County Superior Court Judge Ronnie MacLaren as he declared a 2018 Oakland parcel tax for education a failure with 62% of the votes.

“Allowing Measure AA to be enacted with less than two-thirds of the votes would constitute a fraud on the voters. The ballot measures prepared by the city unambiguously advised voters that Measure AA would require two-thirds of the votes to pass.” — Judge MacLaren 
“Allowing Measure AA to be enacted with less than two-thirds of the votes would constitute a fraud on the voters,” Judge MacLaren wrote, noting that “the ballot measures prepared by the city unambiguously advised voters that Measure AA would require two-thirds of the votes to pass.”
San Diego voters were told the same thing, but backers of Measure C may take its validity to court should it fall short in the final count.
“What’s very clear is that a large majority of San Diegans support priorities in Measure C,” Rachel Laing, a spokeswoman for the support coalition said in a statement. “In the coming days, the coalition will discuss our options for how to move forward if the measure ultimately falls short of the two-thirds threshold.”
The earlier cases are already moving through the appellate process and eventually, the Supreme Court will have to tell us what it meant in that 2017 case. Sooner would be better than later as the roster of disputed tax measures grows.
CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=31]

DON'T MISS

Fresno Fire and Police Ramp up Probe Into Fires at Cemeteries

DON'T MISS

New Recruiting Programs Put Army, Air Force on Track to Meet Enlistment Goals. Navy Will Fall Short

DON'T MISS

Citing Safety, USC Cancels Speech by Valedictorian Who Has Publicly Supported Palestinians

DON'T MISS

Paris Hilton Backs California Bill to Bring More Transparency to Youth Treatment Facilities

DON'T MISS

House to Send Mayorkas Impeachment Articles to the Senate, Forcing a Trial

DON'T MISS

Parker Wins MLB Debut as Nationals Beat Dodgers on Jackie Robinson Day

DON'T MISS

Facing a Republican Revolt, House Speaker Johnson Pushes Ahead on US Aid for Ukraine

DON'T MISS

Giants Rally With 3 Runs in 7th to Beat NL-Worst Marlins

DON'T MISS

Ken Holtzman, MLB’s Winningest Jewish Pitcher Who Won 3 World Series With A’s, Dies at 78

DON'T MISS

Ex-Marine Gets 9 Years in Prison for Firebombing California Planned Parenthood Clinic

UP NEXT

Biden’s Embrace of Trump’s Tariffs Could Spell Trouble for His Reelection: Fareed Zakaria

UP NEXT

‘Digital Democracy’ Project Penetrates California’s Opaque Political Processes

UP NEXT

While California Politicians Skirmish Over Housing, the Shortage Keeps Growing

UP NEXT

As PG&E Bills Skyrocket, Will California Lawmakers Hold Anyone Accountable?

UP NEXT

Trustees Owe a Nationwide Superintendent Search to Fresno’s Children

UP NEXT

Taxes Are on the November Ballot in Monumental CA Showdown

UP NEXT

California Progressives Forced to Play Defense as State Faces Huge Budget Deficits

UP NEXT

CA Labor Priorities and Business ‘Job Killers’ on a Collision Course

UP NEXT

California Water Wars Continue Despite Now Healthy H20 Supply

UP NEXT

How the Saga of California’s Contentious Income-Based Utility Charge Began

Paris Hilton Backs California Bill to Bring More Transparency to Youth Treatment Facilities

23 mins ago

House to Send Mayorkas Impeachment Articles to the Senate, Forcing a Trial

51 mins ago

Parker Wins MLB Debut as Nationals Beat Dodgers on Jackie Robinson Day

1 hour ago

Facing a Republican Revolt, House Speaker Johnson Pushes Ahead on US Aid for Ukraine

1 hour ago

Giants Rally With 3 Runs in 7th to Beat NL-Worst Marlins

1 hour ago

Ken Holtzman, MLB’s Winningest Jewish Pitcher Who Won 3 World Series With A’s, Dies at 78

2 hours ago

Ex-Marine Gets 9 Years in Prison for Firebombing California Planned Parenthood Clinic

3 hours ago

Fresno Coin Gallery Owner Reveals Why Gold & Silver Are Hot Investments

4 hours ago

A Fresno Edition of Monopoly? That’s Capitalism at Work, Baby!

18 hours ago

California Officials Sue Huntington Beach Over Voter ID Law Passed at Polls

18 hours ago

Fresno Fire and Police Ramp up Probe Into Fires at Cemeteries

A Fresno Fire Department investigation into a series of blazes at cemeteries along Belmont Avenue reveals that the fires were set intentiona...

2 mins ago

2 mins ago

Fresno Fire and Police Ramp up Probe Into Fires at Cemeteries

4 mins ago

New Recruiting Programs Put Army, Air Force on Track to Meet Enlistment Goals. Navy Will Fall Short

18 mins ago

Citing Safety, USC Cancels Speech by Valedictorian Who Has Publicly Supported Palestinians

23 mins ago

Paris Hilton Backs California Bill to Bring More Transparency to Youth Treatment Facilities

51 mins ago

House to Send Mayorkas Impeachment Articles to the Senate, Forcing a Trial

1 hour ago

Parker Wins MLB Debut as Nationals Beat Dodgers on Jackie Robinson Day

1 hour ago

Facing a Republican Revolt, House Speaker Johnson Pushes Ahead on US Aid for Ukraine

1 hour ago

Giants Rally With 3 Runs in 7th to Beat NL-Worst Marlins

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend