Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: A Strange Bedfellows Alliance on Bail
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 5 years ago on
February 20, 2020

Share

Senate Bill 10, passed by the Legislature and signed by then-Gov. Jerry Brown in 2018, violated one of the unwritten rules of making public policy in California.
The measure, one of several criminal justice reforms championed by Brown during his second governorship, would eliminate cash bail for those accused of crimes in favor of a new “risk assessment” program.


Dan Walters
Opinion
Criminal justice reformers have clamored for years to eliminate cash bail, saying it discriminates against poor defendants who lack the financial ability to buy their way out of jail while awaiting disposition of their cases. Unable to return to their jobs and families, it’s argued, poor defendants feel compelled to plead guilty rather than await trial.
While SB 10 drew heavy opposition from bail bond agents, who would be put out of business, its final version was also opposed by civil rights and criminal justice reform groups which disliked the risk assessment alternative that had been inserted at the behest of judges.
They argued that having judges and probation officers use computerized risk assessment tools would perpetuate discrimination against poor defendants and could result in more, rather than fewer, being locked up while awaiting trial.

Dynamics of SB 10 Are Remarkably Similar

With Brown’s support, the Legislature set aside the opposition from both pro- and anti-bail groups but in doing so violated the unwritten rule that requires broad support from affected interest groups before making a major policy change.
Brown, particularly, should have known that acting without such support was perilous since one of the major accomplishments of his first governorship four decades ago was undone by the same unwritten rule.
He had, after laborious effort, won legislative approval of a “peripheral canal” to carry water around the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, even though both environmental groups and San Joaquin Valley farmers opposed it, albeit for vastly different reasons.
Farmers and environmentalists then forged a strange bedfellows alliance to challenge the peripheral canal via a 1982 referendum. By a 2-1 margin, voters rejected the canal and later that year also rejected Brown’s bid for a U.S. Senate seat.
The dynamics of SB 10 are remarkably similar, with those on both sides of the issues forming an informal alliance to sink the measure. Bail bond agents have put up the money to place a referendum on next November’s ballot while the criminal justice coalition that also opposed the bill has launched a campaign to denounce the risk assessment program that would replace bail.

‘It’s About More Than a Referendum’

JusticeLA Coalition, an umbrella group of criminal justice reformers, is opposing plans by the State Judicial Council, an arm of the state Supreme Court that represents judges, to proceed with risk assessment pilot programs even though SB 10’s provisions are on hold pending the outcome of the referendum.

“Replacing money bail with a new system of e-carceration is not progress; it’s the status quo masquerading as reform. Without community input, SB 10’s early implementation will harm the exact same people who have been targeted by mass incarceration and on a similar scale.” — Scott Roberts, a coalition leader 
“Replacing money bail with a new system of e-carceration is not progress; it’s the status quo masquerading as reform,” Scott Roberts, a coalition leader, said as the group staged a protest outside the Judicial Council’s offices in San Francisco this month. “Without community input, SB 10’s early implementation will harm the exact same people who have been targeted by mass incarceration and on a similar scale.”
Does its criticism of SB 10 mean that Roberts’ coalition will directly support the bail agents’ campaign to erase the law?
In an interview, Marena Blanchard from Color of Change, one of the coalition members, hedged a bit. “We’re not for SB 10,” she said. “We don’t want to see it become law.” However, she stopped short of formally supporting the bail agent referendum, saying, “It’s about more than a referendum.”
CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=31]

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Tulare County Authorities Arrest Man in Dinuba Shooting

DON'T MISS

Fresno Murder Suspect Arrested in Madera County Following Shooting

DON'T MISS

Millions of Americans Like Trump Better in Theory Than in Practice

DON'T MISS

Tucker Carlson Says Trump ‘Complicit’ in Israel’s Attack on Iran

DON'T MISS

Fresno Stabbing Leads to 7-Hour SWAT Standoff and Arrest, Suspect Identified

DON'T MISS

A Look Inside Israel’s ‘Fortress of Zion’ Command Beneath Tel Aviv

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Make DUI Arrest, Cite 135 Drivers in Distracted Driving Crackdown

DON'T MISS

Russia Says US Has Cancelled Next Round of Talks on Easing Tensions

DON'T MISS

Protester Killed at Utah ‘No Kings’ Rally Was Fashion Designer From ‘Project Runway’

DON'T MISS

Possum the Wanderer Finds Her Groove After Tumor Surgery

UP NEXT

Newsom Wanted To Fast-Track the Delta Tunnel Project. The Legislature Slowed the Flow

UP NEXT

Israel Had the Courage to Do What Needed to Be Done

UP NEXT

California’s Battle Against Homelessness Needs a ‘Combined Arms’ Approach

UP NEXT

An Anti-War Movement Is Stirring in Israel

UP NEXT

This Israeli Government Is a Danger to Jews Everywhere

UP NEXT

Water Scarcity Is Forcing Tough Decisions. This Legislation Can Keep Our Family Farm Afloat

UP NEXT

The Democrats’ Problems Are Bigger Than You Think

UP NEXT

Health Care Is a Lifeline. The Central Valley Deserves Better.

UP NEXT

California’s Stubborn Problems Keep Thwarting Its Ballooning Budget

UP NEXT

Why Reforming California’s Bedrock Environmental Law Is Good for the Environment

Tucker Carlson Says Trump ‘Complicit’ in Israel’s Attack on Iran

50 minutes ago

Fresno Stabbing Leads to 7-Hour SWAT Standoff and Arrest, Suspect Identified

1 hour ago

A Look Inside Israel’s ‘Fortress of Zion’ Command Beneath Tel Aviv

1 hour ago

Fresno Police Make DUI Arrest, Cite 135 Drivers in Distracted Driving Crackdown

2 hours ago

Russia Says US Has Cancelled Next Round of Talks on Easing Tensions

2 hours ago

Protester Killed at Utah ‘No Kings’ Rally Was Fashion Designer From ‘Project Runway’

2 hours ago

Possum the Wanderer Finds Her Groove After Tumor Surgery

2 hours ago

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Norman James Walker

2 hours ago

JJ Spaun Turns a Free Fall into US Open Title at Rainy Oakmont

2 hours ago

Fresno Vehicle Fire Spreads to Garage, No Injuries Reported

2 hours ago

Tulare County Authorities Arrest Man in Dinuba Shooting

Detectives with the Tulare County Sheriff’s Office arrested a man following a shooting near Dinuba on Friday. Just after 5:30 p.m., de...

8 minutes ago

Gilberto Lopez Mendez, 23, was arrested after pistol-whipping and shooting a victim in the leg near Dinuba on , with deputies recovering a converted fully automatic firearm. (Tulare County SO)
8 minutes ago

Tulare County Authorities Arrest Man in Dinuba Shooting

Fresno police have arrested Scott Alvarado, 41, in the shooting death of Nicholas Bolanos, 33, on Friday, June 13, 2025. (Fresno PD)
15 minutes ago

Fresno Murder Suspect Arrested in Madera County Following Shooting

Trump Takes Questions about Pope Image
25 minutes ago

Millions of Americans Like Trump Better in Theory Than in Practice

Economist Jeffrey Sachs warns of potential US-Iran war in an interview with Tucker Carlson (pictured), citing decades of Israeli-influenced foreign policy in the Middle East. (Shutterstock)
50 minutes ago

Tucker Carlson Says Trump ‘Complicit’ in Israel’s Attack on Iran

A man was slashed in the chin with a machete in a North Fresno apartment complex on Sunday, June 15, 2025,, prompting a seven-hour SWAT standoff that ended Monday, June 16, 2025. The suspect has been identified as Ronny Harris, 51. (Fresno PD)
1 hour ago

Fresno Stabbing Leads to 7-Hour SWAT Standoff and Arrest, Suspect Identified

Officials inside the Israeli Army’s underground command bunker in Tel Aviv, Israel, on Friday, May 21, 2021. A former leader in Israel’s top commando unit acknowledged that the distance from the battlefield could create indifference to human lives. (Dan Balilty/The New York Times)
1 hour ago

A Look Inside Israel’s ‘Fortress of Zion’ Command Beneath Tel Aviv

2 hours ago

Fresno Police Make DUI Arrest, Cite 135 Drivers in Distracted Driving Crackdown

National flags of Russia and the U.S. fly at Vnukovo International Airport in Moscow, Russia April 11, 2017. (Reuters File)
2 hours ago

Russia Says US Has Cancelled Next Round of Talks on Easing Tensions

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend