A Very Elegant Coup - 'All the Shah's Men: An American Coup and the Roots of Middle East Terror'
Share
[aggregation-styles]
Wayback Machine
BOOK REVIEW — All The Shah’s Men: An American Coup and the Roots of Middle East Terror, by Stephen Kinzer
In the summer of 1953, the CIA and Britain’s MI6 arranged a coup in Tehran. The Iranian prime minister, Mohammad Mossadegh, appeared to be opening his country to the Soviets, and the objective was to overthrow him. The coup succeeded brilliantly. Mossadegh spent the rest of his life on his country estate; Iran remained a strong Cold War ally of the West. And a myth central to the Left took lasting shape: The CIA is thuggish, arrogant, immoral, and — finally — stupid, because interventions of that sort prove counterproductive. No matter how many countries the Soviet Union might subvert, in this view, the United States should never interfere in other peoples’ internal affairs. This myth is being revived forcefully, now that the U.S. has gone far beyond staging a mere coup in order to keep the peace in many trouble spots, including Iraq.
Stephen Kinzer is a New York Times correspondent who prefers to deal in myth rather than consider realities. Everything that has ever gone wrong with Iran, he thinks, is the fault of the British. Admittedly, the British had discovered Iran’s oil resources, and developed the huge Anglo-Iranian Oil Company — but they did this only to exploit Iran’s wealth. In the face of these colonialists, the Iranians could do nothing except grow angry. Righteous indignation bubbles out of Kinzer.
It might all have been so different — because, in its hour of crisis, Iran produced Mossadegh, whom Kinzer in awe and trembling more than once calls a titan, a towering figure, “one of history’s most gifted visionaries.” A tall man with a stoop and the lugubrious appearance of a vulture, Mossadegh was an aristocrat, educated in France and Switzerland.
Read More →
Wayback Machine
BOOK REVIEW — All The Shah’s Men: An American Coup and the Roots of Middle East Terror, by Stephen Kinzer
In the summer of 1953, the CIA and Britain’s MI6 arranged a coup in Tehran. The Iranian prime minister, Mohammad Mossadegh, appeared to be opening his country to the Soviets, and the objective was to overthrow him. The coup succeeded brilliantly. Mossadegh spent the rest of his life on his country estate; Iran remained a strong Cold War ally of the West. And a myth central to the Left took lasting shape: The CIA is thuggish, arrogant, immoral, and — finally — stupid, because interventions of that sort prove counterproductive. No matter how many countries the Soviet Union might subvert, in this view, the United States should never interfere in other peoples’ internal affairs. This myth is being revived forcefully, now that the U.S. has gone far beyond staging a mere coup in order to keep the peace in many trouble spots, including Iraq.
Stephen Kinzer is a New York Times correspondent who prefers to deal in myth rather than consider realities. Everything that has ever gone wrong with Iran, he thinks, is the fault of the British. Admittedly, the British had discovered Iran’s oil resources, and developed the huge Anglo-Iranian Oil Company — but they did this only to exploit Iran’s wealth. In the face of these colonialists, the Iranians could do nothing except grow angry. Righteous indignation bubbles out of Kinzer.
It might all have been so different — because, in its hour of crisis, Iran produced Mossadegh, whom Kinzer in awe and trembling more than once calls a titan, a towering figure, “one of history’s most gifted visionaries.” A tall man with a stoop and the lugubrious appearance of a vulture, Mossadegh was an aristocrat, educated in France and Switzerland.
Read More →
By David Pryce-Jones, National Review | 15 Sept 2003
RELATED TOPICS:
Fresno Police, CHP Crack Down on Impaired Driving for July 4th
Local /
37 minutes ago
Despite Last-Minute Changes, Senate Bill Deals Big Blow to Renewable Energy
Energy /
1 hour ago
Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Amaury Fernandez
Local /
2 hours ago
CA Rolls Back Its Landmark Environmental Law to Speed Housing Construction
Housing /
3 hours ago
Visalia Police Investigate Deadly Shooting Near Bethlehem Center
Local /
3 hours ago
Trump-Backed Tax-Cut and Spending Bill Passes US Senate
Politics /
3 hours ago
Homeland Security Secretary Noem Says CNN May Be Prosecuted Over Report on Migration App
Politics /
3 hours ago
Musk Promises a New Political Party if the GOP Bill Passes
Politics /
3 hours ago
Dollar Gains Ground Against Major Peers After Better-Than-Expected US Jobs Data
Economy /
4 hours ago
Latest
Videos

Crime /
14 minutes ago
Fresno Police Arrest Intoxicated Employee Following Morning Disturbance

Politics /
30 minutes ago
US Senate Strikes AI Regulation Ban From Trump Megabill

Local /
37 minutes ago
Fresno Police, CHP Crack Down on Impaired Driving for July 4th

Energy /
1 hour ago
Despite Last-Minute Changes, Senate Bill Deals Big Blow to Renewable Energy

Local /
2 hours ago
Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Amaury Fernandez

Housing /
3 hours ago