Fresno’s leading candidates for mayor hammered on their campaign themes — and sometimes on each other — at a televised forum Tuesday evening that covered a variety of topics, including homelessness, marijuana dispensaries, and facing up to mistakes.

Listen to this article:


Jerry Dyer, left, and Andrew Janz, right, are the two leading candidates in Fresno’s mayoral race.

Jerry Dyer emphasized his long experience as the city’s police chief, overseeing multimillion-dollar budgets and thousands of employees, as a key reason why he should be elected.

Andrew Janz, a Fresno County deputy district attorney, said he will offer a fresh perspective and will not be beholden to the special interests — developers — who he says have long called the shots at City Hall.

(You can watch a replay of the forum at this link.)

“I’m going to make it very plain and simple — I’m not taking a dime from the developers.” — Andrew Janz

And although Janz said in a recent radio interview that he might consider accepting donations from developers in the future, on Tuesday he said adamantly that he won’t. (Note to readers: GV Wire’s publisher is Darius Assemi, who is president and CEO of Granville Homes.)

“Campaign finance reform is very important to me,” he told GV Wire after the forum. “It is something I ran on when I was running for Congress, and it’s something that I’m running on here locally. There is too much money from the developer class that has been spent on our local politics. And they’ve really owned the politicians. So I’m going to make it very plain and simple — I’m not taking a dime from the developers.”

The one-hour forum was broadcast at CMAC, the Community Media Access Collaborative on Van Ness Boulevard in downtown Fresno, and was moderated by Bill McEwen, GV Wire’s news director.

Solving Homelessness Crisis

After asking Dyer and Janz about their qualifications to head California’s fifth-largest city, McEwen asked them how they would solve Fresno’s homelessness crisis.

Fresno mayoral candidates Andrew Janz, left, and Jerry Dyer respond to questions from forum moderator Bill McEwen, GV Wire’s news director. (GV Wire/Jahz Tello)

Dyer and Janz agreed that it’s the city’s top problem and the issue they hear about most from residents.

Dyer said there have been good efforts to address the problem, but they have been clearly insufficient as the city’s homeless population continues to grow, expanding by 17% just in the past year.

He said the city will need to work closely with the Fresno County Board of Supervisors, who control the county’s social services budget — Dyer noted that he has been endorsed by all five supervisors — to attack the problem in new ways.

New Center Would House Homeless

“Those navigation centers are intended to bring services to individuals, to stabilize them over about a three- to four-month period. At the end of that period, they transition out into some form of housing.” — Jerry Dyer

He said he favors creating “navigation centers,” which he says have been effective in places like San Diego County to provide safe shelter. They can be subdivided to serve different homeless populations, including families and veterans, he said.

“Those navigation centers are intended to bring services to individuals, to stabilize them over about a three- to four-month period,” Dyer said. “At the end of that period, they transition out into some form of housing.”

With Fresno’s shortage of affordable housing, the city needs to look at alternatives such as tiny home villages or C train housing (shipping containers), he said.

Government Needs to Step Up

Janz said government needs to take a bigger role in addressing the problem, which he said up to now has been shouldered primarily by the private sector and nonprofits with limited resources.

Gov. Gavin Newsom on Wednesday proposed budgeting millions of dollars to help low-income people pay their rent, and for cities to pay for temporary housing units.

When Sacramento offers to help with affordable housing, Fresno needs to accept that help, Janz said.

“We need to make clear to folks in Washington that we need help. And we can only do that if we elect leaders that understand the problems of income inequality.”Andrew Janz

But voters also need to look at the leaders in Washington, D.C., such as President Donald Trump, whose tax policies have reinforced income inequalities that can worsen homelessness, Janz said.

“We need to make clear to folks in Washington that we need help,” he said. “And we can only do that if we elect leaders that understand the problems of income inequality.”

When Will Fresno OK Recreational Pot?

Dyer said that while he remains personally opposed to recreational marijuana use, it is legal in California and so the city must make good decisions about the best way to authorize both medical and recreational marijuana sales outlets. He said he doubts that the tax revenues that the city might gain would be as much as some have forecast. The high taxes imposed by the state, plus any city taxes, will turn some buyers to the black market.

Andrew Janz, left, and Jerry Dyer face off at a mayoral forum Tuesday at CMAC. (GV Wire/Jahz Tello)

Even so, he said, dispensaries in Fresno are inevitable, and city officials must make sure that the dispensaries have sufficient security to keep neighborhoods safe.

It was somewhat of a turnaround from Dyer’s comments in a recent radio interview, when he called legalized marijuana a “no-win” for the city.

Janz noted that he and Dyer now appear to be on the same page about recreational marijuana, which Janz maintains could pump at least $500,000 yearly in additional tax revenues into the city’s treasury.

And cannabis dispensaries will also provide an opportunity to support some of the same communities that were most adversely impacted by the ill-fated war on marijuana, which sent many people to prison, he said.

“I think we’re beginning to see, not only in our community but nationwide, an important cultural shift in terms of the war on drugs,” Janz said. “We know that what’s happened with this war on marijuana hasn’t worked, and is really bad for a lot of people who have been incarcerated for simple possession.”

Guilt By Association?

McEwen asked Janz if he regrets his association during his 2018 congressional campaign with attorney Michael Avenatti, who has been accused of trying to extort $25 million from Nike by threatening to make public claims that the athletic clothing company improperly paid athletes. Janz ran against incumbent Rep. Devin Nunes in the 22nd Congressional district.

Janz said that candidates can’t control who supports their campaign, and he pointed out that Avenatti did not work for him or donate money to his campaign.

But then he turned his response into an attack on Dyer.

“I’m willing to go out there and say I made a mistake,” Janz said. “In hindsight, it was a bad decision. But I’m sure I don’t regret it as much as Jerry hiring Keith Foster to be his second-in-command … .

“I think that if we’re going to have a debate on who’s supporting who, I think the more important question about leadership is … the people you surround yourself with.”

Foster was convicted in 2017 on federal drug charges and sentenced to four years in prison.

Regrets His ‘Indiscretions’

“I’ve made my share of mistakes, but I’ve learned from them, and I’ve tried to be the leader that people expect of me as the police chief, and I’ll be the same as the mayor.” — Jerry Dyer

McEwen then asked Dyer about how he’s answering voters who raise questions about the mistakes he’s admitted to making early on in his career as a police officer — an issue often cited by his opponents. One of those opponents, Elizabeth Arambula, wife of Assemblymember Joaquin Arambula, sat in the CMAC studio next to Janz’s wife during the forum.

The Arambula family has contributed nearly $100,000 to an independent expenditure campaign opposing Dyer’s candidacy for mayor, in part because Dyer talked openly about the child abuse allegations that Joaquin Arambula faced in 2018. Arambula was later acquitted.

Dyer said he has acknowledged his mistakes, although he is honoring his wife’s request not to go into details.

“No. 1, those indiscretions on my part occurred when I was in my 20s,” Dyer said. “There are decisions that I made that I’m not proud of. I’m ashamed of many of them. Again, they were made when I was in my 20s.”

Dyer said he hopes voters will base their decision on whether to support him on his 18 years as the city’s police chief and not on mistakes he made early in his career. “I’ve made my share of mistakes, but I’ve learned from them, and I’ve tried to be the leader that people expect of me as the police chief, and I’ll be the same as the mayor.”

6 Responses

  1. Jan

    Janz took plenty of money from special interests outside of Fresno including many hollywierdos like Rosie ODonnellthat contributed using psuedo names. Janz has unclean hands and unproven as a community or city leader. He would rather support pot, illegals and homeless ( whi largely are NOT from Fresno) than work with the business sector, major employers and businesses in Fresno .
    Please spare us his inexperience, Janz will learn lessons in life when his baby girl is born at the end of the month. The true responsibility of raising a family in today’s world. Hopefully his child will understanding accountability and not blaming or attacking others.
    Janz should move back to his hometown of Tulare and fix it. It’s an economic nightmare full of crime and homelessness.

    • Joe

      Jan – if Rosie O’Donnell actually made a donation under a false name she should be arrested. I hope you have informed the proper authorities with all of your
      evidence. I am sure that you are just as upset that Congressional member Nunes received over $3,000,000 or 60% of his contributions when he barely defeated Mr Janz from OUTSIDE of the 22nd
      District. Maybe if Congressional member Nunes would ever make a public appearance open to all of his constituents someone might be able to ask him.

    • Roman Valdes

      Sadly if innuendoes, allegations and bringing in a candidates daughter are all your justifications to not elect Mr. Janz – you fall woefully short.

  2. Howard K. Watkins

    Andrew Janz will provide a refreshing approach to actually addressing and helping resolve many of Fresno’s current difficulties: from homelessness, need for quality jobs, and affordable housing to the numerous potholes on most of Fresno’s streets.

    • Charles

      Janz has yet to demonstrate or provide any ability, knowledge and insight to becoming a true leader that can provide solutions outside of his constant complaining.

  3. Sandra Corona

    Only Jerry Deryer is the most qualified for mayor… he has worked closely with the people of this community, he also is a member of many organizations & made very important relationships in these organizations. In order for our city to prosper, I believe he will also continue to work closely with the new police chief in keeping criminal activity down.He knows the issues & problems of the city. I feel he has a very good idea of what Fresno needs since holding the position of police chief here in Fresno for 20+ years.with this experience backing him up..I believe he’ll make the best decisions looking into the future for the citizens and the homeless community.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

We've got issues, and we're willing to share
(but only if you want them in your inbox).