Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California Justices Skeptical of Requiring Trump Tax Returns
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
November 7, 2019

Share

SACRAMENTO — California Supreme Court justices seemed skeptical Wednesday of a state law requiring President Donald Trump to disclose his tax returns if he wants to be a candidate in the state’s primary election next year.
The justices wondered in a rapid-fire hour of questioning if the nation’s first such law might be expanded to require all sorts of things, from birth certificates to psychiatric and medical records.
Could candidates also be required to swear they’re not communists or never committed adultery, asked Justice Joshua Groban. How about requiring that they disclose five years of their school report cards, added Justice Ming Chin.
It could evolve into “a laundry list of potential requirements,” Chin objected, adding, “Where does it end?”
Supervising state Deputy Attorney General Jay Russell argued that the Legislature has discretion to set restrictions.
A federal judge already temporarily blocked the state law in response to a different lawsuit.
The case before the state Supreme Court was filed by the California Republican Party and chairwoman Jessica Millan Patterson challenging Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom’s July signing of the law aimed at Trump.

The Justices Sped up Their Usual Timetable

Their attorney Thomas Hiltachk argued Wednesday that the law violates the California Constitution, specifically a 1972 voter-approved amendment guaranteeing that all recognized candidates must be on the ballot.
In addition, keeping Trump off the ballot could lower voter turnout in the primary, hurting Republican legislative and congressional candidates’ chances of reaching the general election, the plaintiffs said.
Lawyers for the state called the release of tax returns a common-sense requirement so voters can gauge candidates’ “financial status and honesty concerning financial matters.”
State officials appear to “have an uphill battle defending this statute,” based on the high court’s tough questioning — even its more progressive justices, said University of California law professor Richard “Rick” Frank, who attended the hearing.
“A critical mass of the justices … were asking a lot of pointed questions of the ‘slippery slope’ variety,” he said.
The justices sped up their usual timetable because there would be a Nov. 26 deadline for candidates to file tax returns if the law survives. However, the court could take up to 90 days to rule on the matter.
State officials would not say why they didn’t seek a faster review of the federal judge’s decision by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals or if that meant they are giving up on getting Trump’s returns in time for next year’s election.

Trump Broke With Decades of Tradition in Refusing to Release His Returns

Hiltachk said a ruling against the law by the state Supreme Court would be more defining, because it couldn’t be appealed.
His co-counsel, Charles Bell, after the hearing called the law “a slap in the face of an open primary,” noting that “if all manner of things were required, there would be very few candidates.”
State officials did not comment after the hearing.
Trump broke with decades of tradition in refusing to release his returns, citing an ongoing Internal Revenue Service audit.
The California Supreme Court hearing consideration came the same week that a federal appeals court in New York ruled that Trump’s tax returns can be turned over to a grand jury that usually keeps the records from public view.
Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance Jr. is seeking the returns as part of a broader investigation that includes alleged payments to buy the silence of adult film actress Stormy Daniels and Playboy centerfold Karen McDougal, both of whom claim they had affairs with the president before the 2016 presidential election. Trump has denied the allegations.

DON'T MISS

Filmmaker Dallas Jenkins Is Keynote Speaker for Fresno Clovis Prayer Breakfast

DON'T MISS

Kiké Hernández and World Series Champion Dodgers Finalize a $6.5 Million, 1-Year Contract

DON'T MISS

California Man Calls 375 Hoax Threats in Swatting Spree Will Face Prison Time

DON'T MISS

White House Fires USAID Inspector General After Warning About Funding Oversight

DON'T MISS

Red, White, and Blueland? GOP Congressman Proposes Bill to Rename Greenland

DON'T MISS

White House Bars AP Reporter From Oval Office Because of AP Style Policy on ‘Gulf of America’

DON'T MISS

Trump Steel, Aluminum Tariffs Likely to Drive up Car Costs, Industry Leaders Say

DON'T MISS

After Criminal Case Tossed, Madec Fights to Get Fresno CC Classroom Job Back

DON'T MISS

Atmospheric River Stays on Track to Soak Fresno With Rain

DON'T MISS

Blood Center Picks Long-Time Industry Leader as New CEO

UP NEXT

Red, White, and Blueland? GOP Congressman Proposes Bill to Rename Greenland

UP NEXT

White House Bars AP Reporter From Oval Office Because of AP Style Policy on ‘Gulf of America’

UP NEXT

Californians Picked Up in Recent ICE Raids Include Kids and Volunteers

UP NEXT

Denmark Wants to Buy California? Online Petition Hits 200,000 Signatures

UP NEXT

Russia Has Released Detained American Teacher Marc Fogel, the White House Says

UP NEXT

Facing Backlash Over $500K Salary, LA’s Wildfire Recovery Czar Agrees to Work for Free

UP NEXT

Canned Tuna Sold at Trader Joe’s, Costco, H-E-B Recalled for Botulism Risk

UP NEXT

Fact Check: No Evidence Chelsea Clinton Took $84 Million From USAID

UP NEXT

Private Jets Collide at Scottsdale Airport in Arizona, Killing at Least 1 Person, Authorities Say

UP NEXT

Farmers Caught in Limbo as Trump’s USDA Suspends Program Funding

White House Fires USAID Inspector General After Warning About Funding Oversight

14 hours ago

Red, White, and Blueland? GOP Congressman Proposes Bill to Rename Greenland

15 hours ago

White House Bars AP Reporter From Oval Office Because of AP Style Policy on ‘Gulf of America’

15 hours ago

Trump Steel, Aluminum Tariffs Likely to Drive up Car Costs, Industry Leaders Say

15 hours ago

After Criminal Case Tossed, Madec Fights to Get Fresno CC Classroom Job Back

16 hours ago

Atmospheric River Stays on Track to Soak Fresno With Rain

16 hours ago

Blood Center Picks Long-Time Industry Leader as New CEO

17 hours ago

Californians Picked Up in Recent ICE Raids Include Kids and Volunteers

17 hours ago

Denmark Wants to Buy California? Online Petition Hits 200,000 Signatures

19 hours ago

Fresno Crash Kills Pedestrian. Driver Cooperates With Police.

19 hours ago

Filmmaker Dallas Jenkins Is Keynote Speaker for Fresno Clovis Prayer Breakfast

Dallas Jenkins, the creator and director of the television series “The Chosen,” is the keynote speaker at the Fresno Clovis Pray...

1 hour ago

1 hour ago

Filmmaker Dallas Jenkins Is Keynote Speaker for Fresno Clovis Prayer Breakfast

13 hours ago

Kiké Hernández and World Series Champion Dodgers Finalize a $6.5 Million, 1-Year Contract

Photo of an armored vehicle
13 hours ago

California Man Calls 375 Hoax Threats in Swatting Spree Will Face Prison Time

Flowers and a sign are placed outside the headquarters of the U.S. Agency for International Development, or USAID, Friday, Feb. 7, 2025, in Washington. (AP/Jose Luis Magana)
14 hours ago

White House Fires USAID Inspector General After Warning About Funding Oversight

15 hours ago

Red, White, and Blueland? GOP Congressman Proposes Bill to Rename Greenland

Elon Musk listens as President Donald Trump speaks with reporters in the Oval Office at the White House, Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025, in Washington. (AP/Alex Brandon)
15 hours ago

White House Bars AP Reporter From Oval Office Because of AP Style Policy on ‘Gulf of America’

An employee works on the production line at the Martinrea auto parts manufacturing plant that supplies auto parts to Canada and U.S. plants, in Woodbridge, Ontario, Monday, Feb. 3, 2025. (AP File)
15 hours ago

Trump Steel, Aluminum Tariffs Likely to Drive up Car Costs, Industry Leaders Say

16 hours ago

After Criminal Case Tossed, Madec Fights to Get Fresno CC Classroom Job Back

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend