Maybe Sean McVay made it all look just too easy.
Adding play calling to a rookie head coach’s job description, it turns out, can be too difficult for newcomers to handle along with basic game management.
Aaron Rodgers in Green Bay and Kyler Murray in Arizona have eased the growing pains for Matt LaFleur and Kliff Kingsbury. Zac Taylor in Cincinnati and Freddie Kitchens in Cleveland , on the other hand, are being second-guessed for trying to do too much halfway through their first seasons. And neither is willing to lighten the load and hand off play-calling duties.
“No. It is not happening,” Kitchens said Monday. “I am calling the plays. I am the head coach. That is not happening.”
Taylor is the first Bengals coach to lose his first eight games, and his big change at Cincinnati’s bye is benching veteran Andy Dalton for rookie Ryan Finley. Taylor will continue to call plays for the NFL’s last winless team.
“We’ve won zero games and have not scored enough points,” Taylor said. “And that 100 percent falls on me. But I do like the communication we have as a staff. The play calls come out of my mouth. We have great chemistry as a staff. We put a good plan together, and we are all on the same page when the calls come out regardless of who call it.”
Injuries Have Been a Big Issue
Neither Kitchens nor Taylor had ever been head coaches at any level until this season, and they have little experience calling plays. At least Kitchens can point to how Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield blossomed over the second half of last season once Kitchens was promoted to offensive coordinator from running backs coach.
Taylor called plays for the final five games in 2015 with the Miami Dolphins and was offensive coordinator in college at Cincinnati in 2016. The Bengals hired Taylor after he was assistant wide receivers coach in 2017 and quarterbacks coach in 2018 with the Rams — and McVay, who calls his own plays.
And Taylor uses a play-action system similar to the Rams that is heavily dependent on a decent run game. Unfortunately, the banged-up Bengals rank last in the NFL averaging 59.5 yards rushing a game and have been held under 35 yards four times. Cincinnati’s offensive line has struggled so much Taylor has had to keep tight ends in to help block.
The Browns are 2-6 after being popular picks to win the AFC North. Injuries have been a big issue. But Kitchens has appeared overwhelmed at times on the sideline. Kitchens was criticized heavily for not calling a running play inside the 10 late in a 20-13 loss to the Rams in September. Mayfield threw four times, the last intercepted in the end zone. The Browns coach took the blame for his play-calling in that fourth quarter.
More than a month later, Kitchens called a shovel pass New England intercepted on its way to a 27-13 win. Worse, the Browns’ offense ranks 25th, scoring 19 points a game.
Then There’s LaFleur
“Everything about the program should reflect on me and I will accept it,” Kitchens said. “But I also have a hand in fixing it.”
Still, Kingsbury has had his growing pains.
“I’m used to 80 or 85 snaps, and now you’re getting 65, maybe 70, so you have to make sure when you look at that sheet, you’re not just calling something to get it called or playing really fast because you’re trying to out-maneuver them with tempo,” Kingsbury said. “You have to make sure you have a point to every play, and that’s helped me throughout this first month and a half get adjusted.”
Then there’s LaFleur who is working with the 35-year-old two-time MVP in Rodgers. LaFleur was the Rams’ coordinator in McVay’s rookie season and only called plays in 2018 as Tennessee’s coordinator before Green Bay hired him. But the Packers are 7-2, and LaFleur says the relationship between quarterback and coach is critical.
“The way I view the quarterback is, it’s an extension of the coaching staff,” LaFleur said. “And so yeah we got to be on the same page. I think that just like any relationship, it takes time to make sure the communication is on point.”
Faster for some than others.