Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Conflict Over Votes for Local Taxes Heats Up
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 5 years ago on
July 10, 2019

Share

For decades, it’s been an article of political faith – as well as law – that local government taxes designated for particular purposes require two-thirds approval by voters.


Dan Walters
CALmatters

The supermajority vote provision was created by Proposition 13, California’s famous – or infamous – property tax limit measure, passed by voters in 1978, and later bolstered by another initiative, Proposition 218.
Two years ago, however, the state Supreme Court seemingly carved out a way for local governments to sidestep that law. It implied, in ruling on a Southern California marijuana case, that if special purpose tax measures are placed on the ballot by initiative petition, rather than by the local governments themselves, the two-thirds vote threshold might not apply.
Ever since, those who want to raise local taxes have yearned to learn whether the Supreme Court really meant to make an exception and, not surprisingly, San Francisco’s very liberal city government, acting on the advice of City Attorney Dennis Herrera, volunteered to become the legal guinea pig.
Members of the city’s governing body, its Board of Supervisors, personally sponsored two tax increase initiatives last year, one for the June election and another in November, both listed on the ballot as “Proposition C.”

City Began Collecting  Taxes, but Not Spending Them

The June measure, a tax on commercial rents to finance early childhood education and child care services, received 51 percent voter support. The November proposal, a tax on businesses to finance services and housing for the homeless, garnered 61 percent voter support.
With both votes below two-thirds, opponents of the measures sued, contending that they were invalid. The city began collecting the taxes, but not spending them, while the legal battle raged.
Last week, San Francisco Superior Court Judge Ethan Schulman agreed with Herrera and validated both taxes. However, he doesn’t have the last word. Business and anti-tax groups, such as the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, vowed “an immediate appeal” and the issue is clearly headed to the state Supreme Court for a definitive ruling.
A third San Francisco tax measure, also placed by initiative petition and receiving a simple majority approval from voters in 2018, is also being contested. Proposition G imposes a new “parcel tax” on homes and other real estate to increase teacher pay.
Were the state’s highest court to convert its 2017 implication into declarative law, it would almost completely change the dynamics of local tax battles.
Rather than propose special purpose taxes directly, local officials and their political allies, especially public employee unions, could do it via initiative petition and completely bypass the long-standing supermajority vote requirement.

Another Wrinkle to the Situation

There is, however, another wrinkle to the situation.
Last year, as the San Francisco tax measures were being challenged, the state Supreme Court issued another decision that could affect the eventual outcome.

Last year, as the San Francisco tax measures were being challenged, the state Supreme Court issued another decision that could affect the eventual outcome.
It declared that when former San Diego Mayor Jerry Sanders sponsored a 2012 ballot measure to reform city pensions, he was acting in an official capacity, not as a private citizen, and therefore was legally obligated to “meet and confer” with unions on something that affected their members’ compensation.
Logically, if Sanders was under that legal obligation as an official while sponsoring a ballot measure, then members of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors also were acting officially, and not as ordinary citizens, when they sponsored their tax measures. If so, their measures probably should have been subject to the supermajority rule.
It will be interesting to see how the court balances one ruling with the other, if it can, with financial stakes astronomically high in the outcome.
CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=19]

DON'T MISS

CA Senate Passes Hospital Seismic Compliance Bill: What’s the Impact on Local Hospitals?

DON'T MISS

Take This Memorial Day Quiz Before Warming up the Grill

DON'T MISS

Hate Wasting Money? Use These 7 Hacks to Feed Your Family for Less

DON'T MISS

NCAA and Leagues Back $2.8 Billion Settlement, Setting Stage for Current, Former Athletes to Be Paid

DON'T MISS

UC Berkeley Faces a Summer of Discontent as Gaza Protesters Remain Steadfast

DON'T MISS

Newsom Promised 1,200 Tiny Homes for Homeless Californians. How Many Are Being Used?

DON'T MISS

Fresno Unified Unveils 5-Year Literacy Plan. What Are the Expectations?

DON'T MISS

Man Sentenced to 25 Years for Teaching Bomb-Making to Person Targeting Authorities

DON'T MISS

UCLA Police Arrest Young Man for Alleged Felony Assault in Attack on Pro-Palestinian Encampment

DON'T MISS

UAW Files Objection to Mercedes Vote, Accuses Company of Intimidating Workers

UP NEXT

Opinion: Likelihood of Trump Seeing the Inside of a Cell Is Increasing

UP NEXT

California Supreme Court Weighs Two Cases That Could Limit the Ballot Initiative Process

UP NEXT

Newsom Says No New Taxes, Yet His Budget Has Billions in New Levies on Businesses

UP NEXT

How the Beatles Empowered a Research Genius to Save Millions of Lives

UP NEXT

A Radical Lesson From El Salvador to Solve Fresno Housing & Homeless Crisis

UP NEXT

How California’s Bursting Budget Morphed into a $45 Billion Deficit in Just Two Years

UP NEXT

Hydrogen vs. Electric Batteries: A Case For Fresno’s Transportation & Ag Future

UP NEXT

Netanyahu’s Misguided Gaza Strategy Threatens Israel’s Future: Fareed Zakaria

UP NEXT

Opinion: How Urban Renewal Ruined Everything

UP NEXT

How California’s New Fixed Utility Charge Got Its Sneaky Start in the Legislature

NCAA and Leagues Back $2.8 Billion Settlement, Setting Stage for Current, Former Athletes to Be Paid

1 day ago

UC Berkeley Faces a Summer of Discontent as Gaza Protesters Remain Steadfast

1 day ago

Newsom Promised 1,200 Tiny Homes for Homeless Californians. How Many Are Being Used?

1 day ago

Fresno Unified Unveils 5-Year Literacy Plan. What Are the Expectations?

1 day ago

Man Sentenced to 25 Years for Teaching Bomb-Making to Person Targeting Authorities

1 day ago

UCLA Police Arrest Young Man for Alleged Felony Assault in Attack on Pro-Palestinian Encampment

1 day ago

UAW Files Objection to Mercedes Vote, Accuses Company of Intimidating Workers

1 day ago

Fresno County Fruit Trail: Rewards You Can Sink Your Teeth Into

1 day ago

Rising Stars Tigirlily Gold Wows the Crowd at 93.7 KISS Country Concert

1 day ago

Get Ready for the Indy 500 With This Look at Parnelli Jones, JC Agajanian & the Willard Battery Special

2 days ago

CA Senate Passes Hospital Seismic Compliance Bill: What’s the Impact on Local Hospitals?

The California Senate has unanimously passed SB 1432, a bill introduced by Sen. Anna Caballero (D-Merced) to provide a transparent and accou...

19 hours ago

19 hours ago

CA Senate Passes Hospital Seismic Compliance Bill: What’s the Impact on Local Hospitals?

21 hours ago

Take This Memorial Day Quiz Before Warming up the Grill

21 hours ago

Hate Wasting Money? Use These 7 Hacks to Feed Your Family for Less

1 day ago

NCAA and Leagues Back $2.8 Billion Settlement, Setting Stage for Current, Former Athletes to Be Paid

1 day ago

UC Berkeley Faces a Summer of Discontent as Gaza Protesters Remain Steadfast

1 day ago

Newsom Promised 1,200 Tiny Homes for Homeless Californians. How Many Are Being Used?

1 day ago

Fresno Unified Unveils 5-Year Literacy Plan. What Are the Expectations?

1 day ago

Man Sentenced to 25 Years for Teaching Bomb-Making to Person Targeting Authorities

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend