Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Does Spending More on Schools Pay Off?
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 5 years ago on
June 23, 2019

Share

As Gov. Gavin Newsom’s first budget was being wrought, the perennial issue of spending on K-12 education was thrashed out once again.


Dan Walters
CALmatters

The education establishment – professional educators, their unions, their political allies and sympathetic academicians  – complained anew that California schools are being shorted the money they need to raise achievement levels of the state’s nearly 6 million elementary and secondary students.
The newly elected state schools superintendent, former Assemblyman Tony Thurmond, has postulated that California needs to be spending another $30 billion a year – roughly $5,000 more per pupil – to adequately educate its youngsters.
Assemblyman Kevin McCarty, a Sacramento Democrat, arose on the Assembly floor during its debate on the budget to decry that “We’re still 41st in per-pupil spending,” even though Newsom included a handsome increase for schools in his budget.
The exchanges raised two questions that deserve exploration:

  • Are we, in fact, 41st in the nation in school funding?
  • Would significantly increasing school spending result in better academic outcomes?

California Likely in Top 10 in Per-Pupil Spending

The first would seem to be easy to answer, but as with all comparisons, it depends on definitions and context.
The assertion that we are near the bottom is based on adjusting spending for the cost-of-living and since California has very high costs, arguably the highest in the nation, whatever we spend will be pushed downward in rankings.
In unadjusted dollars, according to the Census Bureau’s most recent annual report on school finances, we were 21st in per-pupil spending in 2017 at $12,143 from all sources, including federal funds, slightly below the national average of $12,201.
The District of Columbia topped the list at $23,091, followed by New York at $21,974, Connecticut at $19,322 and New Jersey at $18,920.
Utah was dead last at $7,179, with Idaho ($7,486) and Arizona ($8,003) slightly higher.
With virtually stagnant enrollment, California has increased overall spending and thus per-pupil spending by about 50% in recent years and Newsom’s first budget raises the latter to $17,160.
Using the 2017 Census Bureau rankings as a guide, California is likely in the top 10 in per-pupil spending now – albeit unadjusted for the cost-of-living. Even with such an adjustment, we’re at least in the middle ranks of states.
The second question is even trickier. The advocates of pushing California’s school spending into the top ranks imply that were we to spend $5,000 more per pupil per year, we would see a miraculous improvement in our – at best – mediocre academic outcomes.

There Is No Correlation Between Money and Achievement

But another comparison – how students perform on the federal government’s National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) testing – is not encouraging.

There is simply no correlation between money and achievement in side-by-side comparisons of 8th-grade reading scores, an important benchmark because reading comprehension is vital to success in all subjects, particularly for students about to enter high school.
There is simply no correlation between money and achievement in side-by-side comparisons of 8th-grade reading scores, an important benchmark because reading comprehension is vital to success in all subjects, particularly for students about to enter high school.
The District of Columbia spends the most but its 2019 reading score of 247 is 18 points under the national average and one of the nation’s lowest. New York is second in spending but its reading score, 263, is not only two points under the average, but identical to California’s.
No. 3 Connecticut and No. 4 New Jersey are both markedly above average, but so are No. 51 Utah and No. 50 Idaho.
The inescapable point is that money is clearly not the only factor in educational outcomes, and perhaps not even the most important one. There are socioeconomic, cultural, familial and other forces at play and we shouldn’t make money the sole approach to our educational dilemma. It’s much more complicated than that.
CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=19]

DON'T MISS

IDF Chief Rebukes Netanyahu Over Absence of Gaza Postwar Strategy

DON'T MISS

Will Becerra Run for Governor? He Tours UCSF Fresno With Costa

DON'T MISS

Israeli Defense Chief Opposes ‘Israeli Military Rule’ in Gaza

DON'T MISS

Nelly Korda Triumphs at Mizuho Americas Open

DON'T MISS

Sheriff’s Office to Break Ground on Memorial for Fallen Officers. What Will It Look Like?

DON'T MISS

Hydrogen vs. Electric Batteries: A Case For Fresno’s Transportation & Ag Future

DON'T MISS

Operation Gridlock: 32 Arrests, 59 Gun Seized, Violent Gangs Dismantled

DON'T MISS

Bulldogs Blasted by Air Force, Fall to 4th Seed for MW Tourney

DON'T MISS

What Drives California’s Budget Decisions? A Lot of Politics, Not as Much Data

DON'T MISS

Brunson’s Broken Left Hand in Game 7 the Final Injury for Eliminated Knicks

UP NEXT

Netanyahu’s Misguided Gaza Strategy Threatens Israel’s Future: Fareed Zakaria

UP NEXT

Opinion: How Urban Renewal Ruined Everything

UP NEXT

How California’s New Fixed Utility Charge Got Its Sneaky Start in the Legislature

UP NEXT

Empowering Education: Join the Fight for California Kids’ Literacy

UP NEXT

Newsom’s No New Taxes Pledge Upsets California Progressives

UP NEXT

SF Unified Flirts with Insolvency. It’s Not the Only District in California.

UP NEXT

Sustainable Farms Need to Come Together, Not Cast Blame Over California Methane Program

UP NEXT

Will California Supreme Court Knock Anti-Tax Measure Off the November Ballot?

UP NEXT

A Sustainable Future for Fresno: Rethinking Our Hydrogen Strategy

UP NEXT

Politicians Keep Shifting Blame as California’s Homelessness Crisis Worsens

Nelly Korda Triumphs at Mizuho Americas Open

10 hours ago

Sheriff’s Office to Break Ground on Memorial for Fallen Officers. What Will It Look Like?

10 hours ago

Hydrogen vs. Electric Batteries: A Case For Fresno’s Transportation & Ag Future

10 hours ago

Operation Gridlock: 32 Arrests, 59 Gun Seized, Violent Gangs Dismantled

11 hours ago

Bulldogs Blasted by Air Force, Fall to 4th Seed for MW Tourney

11 hours ago

What Drives California’s Budget Decisions? A Lot of Politics, Not as Much Data

12 hours ago

Brunson’s Broken Left Hand in Game 7 the Final Injury for Eliminated Knicks

12 hours ago

Students Stage Mass Walkout in Pro-Palestinian Protest, UC Academic Workers Authorize Strike

12 hours ago

Extremists Reign in Israel After Decades of Unchecked Violence

13 hours ago

Clovis East Alum DeChambeau Puts on a Show at PGA Championship, Falls 1 Stroke Short

13 hours ago

IDF Chief Rebukes Netanyahu Over Absence of Gaza Postwar Strategy

IDF Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi strongly criticized Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in recent security discussions for his failure to devi...

6 hours ago

6 hours ago

IDF Chief Rebukes Netanyahu Over Absence of Gaza Postwar Strategy

9 hours ago

Will Becerra Run for Governor? He Tours UCSF Fresno With Costa

Image of Benjamin Netanyahu on a hill looking down on a West Bank neighborhood
10 hours ago

Israeli Defense Chief Opposes ‘Israeli Military Rule’ in Gaza

10 hours ago

Nelly Korda Triumphs at Mizuho Americas Open

10 hours ago

Sheriff’s Office to Break Ground on Memorial for Fallen Officers. What Will It Look Like?

10 hours ago

Hydrogen vs. Electric Batteries: A Case For Fresno’s Transportation & Ag Future

11 hours ago

Operation Gridlock: 32 Arrests, 59 Gun Seized, Violent Gangs Dismantled

11 hours ago

Bulldogs Blasted by Air Force, Fall to 4th Seed for MW Tourney

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend