Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Court Tosses Black Man's Murder Conviction Over Racial Bias
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 5 years ago on
June 21, 2019

Share

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Friday threw out the murder conviction and death sentence of a black man in Mississippi because of a prosecutor’s efforts to keep African Americans off the jury. The defendant already has been tried six times and now could face a seventh trial.

The long record of Flowers’ trials stretching back more than 20 years shows District Attorney Doug Evans’ “relentless, determined effort to rid the jury of black individuals,” with the goal of an all-white jury, Kavanaugh wrote.
The removal of black prospective jurors deprived inmate Curtis Flowers of a fair trial, the court said in a 7-2 decision written by Justice Brett Kavanaugh.
The long record of Flowers’ trials stretching back more than 20 years shows District Attorney Doug Evans’ “relentless, determined effort to rid the jury of black individuals,” with the goal of an all-white jury, Kavanaugh wrote.
In Flowers’ sixth trial, the jury was made up of 11 whites and one African American. Prosecutor Evans struck five black prospective jurors.
In the earlier trials, three convictions were tossed out, including one when the prosecutor improperly excluded African Americans from the jury. In the second trial, the judge chided Evans for striking a juror based on race. Two other trials ended when jurors couldn’t reach unanimous verdicts.
“The numbers speak loudly,” Kavanaugh said in a summary of his opinion that he read in the courtroom, noting that Evans had removed 41 of the 42 prospective black jurors over the six trials. “We cannot ignore that history.”

Flowers Has Been in Jail More Than 22 Years

In dissent, Justice Clarence Thomas called Kavanaugh’s opinion “manifestly incorrect” and wrote that Flowers “presented no evidence whatsoever of purposeful race discrimination.” Justice Neil Gorsuch joined most of Thomas’ opinion.
Thomas, the only African American on the Supreme Court, said the decision may have one redeeming quality: “The state is perfectly free to convict Curtis Flowers again.”
Flowers has been in jail more than 22 years, since his arrest after four people were found shot to death in a furniture store in Winona, Mississippi, in July 1996.
Flowers was arrested several months later, described by prosecutors as a disgruntled former employee who sought revenge against the store’s owner because she fired him and withheld most of his pay to cover the cost of merchandise he damaged. Nearly $300 was found missing after the killings.
Defense lawyers have argued that witness statements and physical evidence against Flowers are too weak to convict him. A jailhouse informant who claimed Flowers had confessed to him recanted in recorded telephone conversations with American Public Media’s “In the Dark” podcast. There’s a separate appeal pending in state court questioning Flowers’ actual guilt, citing in part evidence that reporters for “In the Dark” detailed.

 

Supreme Court Tried to Stamp out Discrimination in ’86

“A seventh trial would be unprecedented, and completely unwarranted given both the flimsiness of the evidence against him and the long trail of misconduct that has kept him wrongfully incarcerated all these years. We hope that the state of Mississippi will finally disavow Doug Evans’ misconduct, decline to pursue yet another trial and set Mr. Flowers free,” Sheri Lynn Johnson, who represented Flowers at the Supreme Court, said in an emailed statement.

“A seventh trial would be unprecedented, and completely unwarranted given both the flimsiness of the evidence against him and the long trail of misconduct that has kept him wrongfully incarcerated all these years.” — Sheri Lynn Johnson, who represented Flowers at the Supreme Court
Evans did not respond to email requests for comment and no one answered the phone in his office Friday.
In the course of selecting a jury, lawyers can excuse a juror merely because of a suspicion that a particular person would vote against their client. Those are called peremptory strikes, and they have been the focus of the complaints about discrimination.
The Supreme Court tried to stamp out discrimination in the composition of juries in Batson v. Kentucky in 1986. The court ruled then that jurors couldn’t be excused from service because of their race and set up a system by which trial judges could evaluate claims of discrimination and the race-neutral explanations by prosecutors.
Flowers’ case has been to the high court before. In 2016, the justices ordered Mississippi’s top court to re-examine racial bias issues in Flowers’ case following a high court ruling in favor of a Georgia inmate because of a racially discriminatory jury. But the Mississippi justices divided 5-4 in upholding the verdict against Flowers. The state, defending the conviction, said the justices must narrow the focus from Evans’ broader record to the case at hand.
But Kavanaugh said that even on the narrower basis, there is evidence that at least one prospective black juror for the sixth trial, Carolyn Wright, was similarly situated to white jurors and was improperly excused by Evans.

DON'T MISS

On Juneteenth, Freedom Came With Strings Attached

DON'T MISS

California Should Fight the Ticketmaster Monopoly, Not Embolden It

DON'T MISS

Willie Mays, Giants’ Legendary ‘Say Hey Kid,’ Dies at 93

DON'T MISS

Balderrama Applies for Texas Police Chief Job

DON'T MISS

California Fines Amazon Nearly $6M, Alleging Illegal Work Quotas at 2 Warehouses

DON'T MISS

Nvidia’s Stock Market Value Topped $3.3 Trillion. How It Became No. 1 in the S&P 500, by the Numbers

DON'T MISS

Two Fresnans Defrauded a Mentally Ill Man out of Millions. First Sentencing Comes Down.

DON'T MISS

California Governor Wants to Restrict Smartphone Usage in Schools

DON'T MISS

Fresno Trustees Prepare for Votes on $2.1 Billion Budget, $500M Bond Measure

DON'T MISS

Fresno Garbage Rate Hike Vote on Thursday. Where Does Council Stand?

UP NEXT

After Delay, Top Democrats in Congress Sign Off on Sale of F-15 Jets to Israel

UP NEXT

Joe Biden’s Best Chance to Shake up the Race

UP NEXT

Biden’s Stimulus Juiced the Economy, but Its Political Effects Are Muddled

UP NEXT

Did You Buy a Disneyland ‘Dream Key’? Disney May Owe You Money.

UP NEXT

The Washington Post Delves Into a Difficult Story: Itself

UP NEXT

Judge Orders Railway to Pay Washington Tribe Nearly $400 Million for Trespassing with Oil Trains

UP NEXT

America Needs Big Wins. These Would Be Three.

UP NEXT

Long Prison Stint for Fresno Man Busted in Child Solicitation Sting

UP NEXT

2 Killed When Vintage Plane Crashes During Father’s Day Event at Southern California Airfield

UP NEXT

Maryland Gov. Wes Moore to Issue Over 175,000 Marijuana Pardons

Balderrama Applies for Texas Police Chief Job

14 hours ago

California Fines Amazon Nearly $6M, Alleging Illegal Work Quotas at 2 Warehouses

15 hours ago

Nvidia’s Stock Market Value Topped $3.3 Trillion. How It Became No. 1 in the S&P 500, by the Numbers

15 hours ago

Two Fresnans Defrauded a Mentally Ill Man out of Millions. First Sentencing Comes Down.

16 hours ago

California Governor Wants to Restrict Smartphone Usage in Schools

16 hours ago

Fresno Trustees Prepare for Votes on $2.1 Billion Budget, $500M Bond Measure

16 hours ago

Fresno Garbage Rate Hike Vote on Thursday. Where Does Council Stand?

16 hours ago

Palestinian Supporters Hang ‘Stop the Genocide’ Banner on El Capitan in Yosemite Protest

17 hours ago

California Business & Labor Hammer Out a Deal on Workplace Violation Lawsuits

19 hours ago

How the Teamsters and a Homegrown Union Plan to Take On Amazon

19 hours ago

On Juneteenth, Freedom Came With Strings Attached

Opinion by Charles M. Blow on June 18, 2024. Last week at a Juneteenth concert on the South Lawn of the White House, Vice President Kamala H...

20 mins ago

20 mins ago

On Juneteenth, Freedom Came With Strings Attached

2 hours ago

California Should Fight the Ticketmaster Monopoly, Not Embolden It

13 hours ago

Willie Mays, Giants’ Legendary ‘Say Hey Kid,’ Dies at 93

14 hours ago

Balderrama Applies for Texas Police Chief Job

15 hours ago

California Fines Amazon Nearly $6M, Alleging Illegal Work Quotas at 2 Warehouses

15 hours ago

Nvidia’s Stock Market Value Topped $3.3 Trillion. How It Became No. 1 in the S&P 500, by the Numbers

16 hours ago

Two Fresnans Defrauded a Mentally Ill Man out of Millions. First Sentencing Comes Down.

16 hours ago

California Governor Wants to Restrict Smartphone Usage in Schools

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend