Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Capping High Interest Rates on Loans Doesn't Fix Poverty
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
June 2, 2019

Share

Last month, the Federal Reserve System issued a report on “the economic well-being of U.S. households” and it contained a rather disturbing bit of data.


Dan Walters
CALmatters

“If faced with an unexpected expense of $400,” a survey of American households found, “61% of adults say they would cover it with cash, savings, or a credit card paid off at the next statement – a modest improvement from the prior year.”
Turning that around, 39% of American adults say they couldn’t readily cover an unexpected $400 expense – for a car repair, perhaps, or an emergency room visit. The survey found that two-thirds of them “would borrow or sell something to pay for the expense” and the remainder “would not be able to cover the expense at all.”
Not surprisingly, that 39% number coincides rather neatly – if unfortunately – with poverty in California.
The Census Bureau says California has the nation’s highest level of poverty when the cost of living is included in the calculation, with about 20% of its 40 million residents impoverished. The Public Policy Institute of California, using a similar methodology, calculates that another 20% are living in “near-poverty.”

Curbing the High-Interest Loans Poor Californians Often Take Out

It’s not a stretch to conclude that the 40% of Californians in economic distress probably are incapable of meeting a sudden $400 expense – which brings us to Assembly Bill 539, which passed the Assembly on a 60-4 vote on the same day the Federal Reserve report was released.
The measure, carried by Assemblywoman Monique Limón, a Santa Barbara Democrat, is aimed at curbing the very high-interest loans that poor Californians often take out to meet living costs because they are unable to qualify for conventional credit.
It would place a 36% annual interest rate cap on loans made by state-licensed lenders, more than a third of which have interest rates above 100%, according to the Department of Business Oversight.
Such ultra-high rates are, a legislative analysis of the bill says, “a relatively new phenomenon in California,” growing from 8,468 such loans in 2009 to more than 350,000 per year now, totaling more than $1 billion.
Critics call that “predatory lending” that takes advantage of poor people, who often lack the education or consumer awareness to steer clear of these legal loan sharks. Unable to afford the high payments such loans demand, their unpaid balances are often folded into new loans with high fees and interest.

Measures Seek to Alleviate the Effects of California’s Embarrassingly High Poverty

Limón says she wants to affect the “small number of lenders” that specialize in such loans. “I’ve worked hard to find a compromise,” she told the Assembly, saying her bill would “benefit both consumers and responsible lenders alike.”

Limón says she wants to affect the “small number of lenders” that specialize in such loans. “I’ve worked hard to find a compromise,” she told the Assembly, saying her bill would “benefit both consumers and responsible lenders alike.”
The legislation, now pending in the Senate, is clearly a sincere effort to protect the poor. However, it does nothing about the underlying fact that so many Californians live on the edges of financial precipices and turn to high-interest lenders in desperation when cars break down, when landlords demand rent, or when some other sudden expense rears its ugly head.
The bill is one of dozens of legislative measures that seek to alleviate the effects of California’s embarrassingly high poverty. There is, however, not nearly enough political action on poverty at the source – such as building more housing to bring down its cost, getting more kids through high school, improving skills to fill well-paying jobs now going unfilled for a lack of trained workers, and/or making California more attractive to investment in more jobs.
We sometimes lose sight of the well-proven fact that the best anti-poverty program is a good job.
CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

DON'T MISS

Pope Francis in Critical Condition After Long Respiratory Crisis

DON'T MISS

Musk Gives All Federal Workers 48 Hours to Explain What They Did Last Week

DON'T MISS

Fresno State Suspends 2 Players, Removes Another Amid Gambling Investigation

DON'T MISS

Israel Delays Release of Palestinian Prisoners, Citing ‘Degrading’ Hostage Handovers

DON'T MISS

Officer Killed After Gunman Took Hostages at Pennsylvania Hospital

DON'T MISS

Kash Patel Plans to Move Up to 1,500 Workers Out of Washington

DON'T MISS

Fired Employees Fear Beloved Yosemite National Park Will Lose Its Luster

DON'T MISS

US and Ukraine Nearing Rare Earths Deal That Would Tighten Relationship

DON'T MISS

Trump Fires Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Two Other Military Officers

DON'T MISS

Less Is More: 5 Ingredient Dinners Are Easier Than You Think

UP NEXT

Should Fossil Fuel Companies Be Forced to Pay for Los Angeles Wildfire Losses?

UP NEXT

How California’s Wildfire Crisis Is Burning Through Your Wallet

UP NEXT

LA Wildfires Intensify Political Jousting Over Home Insurance Premiums

UP NEXT

Conflicting Studies Obscure Reality of California’s Fast Food Wage Battle

UP NEXT

Not Quite a Unified Theory of Trumpism, but Still an Alarming Pattern

UP NEXT

California’s Aging Population Will Test Whether Its Demography Is Destiny

UP NEXT

CA Schools Still Fall Behind Despite Big Increases in Spending

UP NEXT

Editorials of The Times: Now Is Not the Time to Tune Out

UP NEXT

Look Past Elon Musk’s Chaos. There’s Something More Sinister at Work.

UP NEXT

The Deadly Truth: Record Number of Journalists Killed in 2024

Israel Delays Release of Palestinian Prisoners, Citing ‘Degrading’ Hostage Handovers

6 hours ago

Officer Killed After Gunman Took Hostages at Pennsylvania Hospital

6 hours ago

Kash Patel Plans to Move Up to 1,500 Workers Out of Washington

12 hours ago

Fired Employees Fear Beloved Yosemite National Park Will Lose Its Luster

12 hours ago

US and Ukraine Nearing Rare Earths Deal That Would Tighten Relationship

12 hours ago

Trump Fires Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Two Other Military Officers

12 hours ago

Less Is More: 5 Ingredient Dinners Are Easier Than You Think

12 hours ago

Trump-Putin Summit Preparations Are Underway, Russia Says

12 hours ago

Warren Buffett Offers Trump Some Advice While Celebrating Berkshire’s Success

12 hours ago

Hungarians Will Decide Whether Ukraine Can Join the European Union, Orbán Says

12 hours ago

Pope Francis in Critical Condition After Long Respiratory Crisis

ROME — Pope Francis was in critical condition Saturday after he suffered a prolonged asthmatic respiratory crisis while being treated for pn...

5 hours ago

5 hours ago

Pope Francis in Critical Condition After Long Respiratory Crisis

5 hours ago

Musk Gives All Federal Workers 48 Hours to Explain What They Did Last Week

5 hours ago

Fresno State Suspends 2 Players, Removes Another Amid Gambling Investigation

6 hours ago

Israel Delays Release of Palestinian Prisoners, Citing ‘Degrading’ Hostage Handovers

6 hours ago

Officer Killed After Gunman Took Hostages at Pennsylvania Hospital

12 hours ago

Kash Patel Plans to Move Up to 1,500 Workers Out of Washington

12 hours ago

Fired Employees Fear Beloved Yosemite National Park Will Lose Its Luster

12 hours ago

US and Ukraine Nearing Rare Earths Deal That Would Tighten Relationship

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend