Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: A New Front in Battle Over Gig Workers
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
May 30, 2019

Share

One of the most contentious – and potentially far-reaching – bills of the current legislative session is Assembly Bill 5, which would draw a legal line between the definitions of employees and contractors.

Dan Walters
CALmatters

AB 5, carried by Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez, a San Diego Democrat, is an outgrowth of a state Supreme Court decision establishing a three-factor test to determine whether a worker can be a contractor or must be considered to be an employee.

It creates, therefore, uncertainty about the status of hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions, of California workers and could lead to a blizzard of individual legal conflicts.

Overall, the decision, dubbed Dynamex for the package delivery company that was the chief defendant and whose contract drivers were the issue, will probably lead to many contract employees being reclassified. But who and how many are the subjects of AB 5.

The bill would essentially place the Dynamex decision into state labor law, thus shielding it from being overturned by some future court. However, as now written, the bill would also carve out exemptions for some kinds of non-employee workers, such as real estate and insurance agents, hair stylists, barbers and investment advisors.

Gonzalez Is a Former Labor Union Official

Lobbyists for many other economic sectors are petitioning Gonzalez for exemptions before the bill reaches Gov. Gavin Newsom’s desk, but she seems unlikely to bend much further

Gonzalez is a former labor union official and contends that those who perform core functions for an employer should be payroll workers with the benefits that come from that status, including unemployment, disability and workers’ compensation insurance coverage.

The decision, and her legislation, are clearly aimed at thwarting expansion of the so-called “gig economy” of part-time, short-term, and contract work, most famously the taxi-like services offered via such firms as Uber and Lyft.

Meanwhile, another front has been opened in the same conflict – this one affecting contract workers for governmental agencies.

Last year, in a case involving the Cambria Community Services District in San Luis Obispo County, the board that governs the California Public Employees Retirement System (CalPERS) declared that an employee of a third-party contractor for the district was a “common law employee” and therefore, Cambria must make contributions to CalPERS for that worker’s pension benefits.

Opportunities to Recruit Workers

The employee involved in the Cambria case served as an interim finance manager for eight months in 2014 under a contract between the district and Regional Government Services. RGS was created by a consortium of local governments specifically to provide temporary workers, such as retired public employees, to agencies “without jeopardizing retirement benefits from prior employment.”

Now the CalPERS board is poised, during a June meeting, to declare its Cambria decision as “precedential,” meaning that it could be cited in future disputes over whether local government workers hired under contract could be deemed to be employees for pension purposes, thus requiring contributions to CalPERS.

The CalPERS assertion that the worker involved, Tracy Fuller, was entitled to have pension contributions made by Cambria stems from another state Supreme Court decision, issued in 1970 in an employment insurance case, defining a “common law employee.”

Now the CalPERS board is poised, during a June meeting, to declare its Cambria decision as “precedential,” meaning that it could be cited in future disputes over whether local government workers hired under contract could be deemed to be employees for pension purposes, thus requiring contributions to CalPERS.

Regional Government Services and other local government groups fear that widespread application of the ruling would raise their costs and discourage local agencies from using contract workers – much as employers see the Dynamex decision as making their operations more expensive and less flexible.

On the flip side, both Dynamex and the CalPERS ruling are boons to California’s labor unions, giving them more opportunities to recruit workers once they are designated as employees.

CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

[activecampaign form=19]

DON'T MISS

Trump Administration Directs All Federal Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Staff Be Put on Leave

DON'T MISS

Baseball’s Newest Hall of Famers: Suzuki, Sabathia, Wagner

DON'T MISS

‘Once in a Lifetime’ Snow Hits Parts of the US South

DON'T MISS

Trump Temporarily Halts Leasing and Permitting for Wind Energy Projects

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Who Dealt Deadly Fentanyl Pill Gets 80-Month Prison Term

DON'T MISS

What’s Next for EVs as Trump Moves to Revoke Biden-Era Incentives?

DON'T MISS

US Throws out Policies Limiting Arrests of Migrants at Sensitive Locations like Schools, Churches

DON'T MISS

Visalia Police Find Man Shot Near Shopping Center. Tips Sought.

DON'T MISS

Convicted Jan. 6 Rioter Benjamin Martin Still Going to Prison

DON'T MISS

Is Lawsuit on Planned Reedley Job Center a ‘Shakedown’?

UP NEXT

Even This Year Is the Best Time Ever to Be Alive

UP NEXT

Voices for Justice: Diverse Figures Unite in Support of Palestine

UP NEXT

California Housing Crisis Will Get Worse as LA Fires Destroy Homes

UP NEXT

Gov. Newsom, Mayor Bass Targeted in Wildfire Witch Hunt

UP NEXT

As Crazy as It Sounds, Trump’s Approach to Foreign Policy Could Work

UP NEXT

The Biden Presidency: Four Illusions, Four Deceptions

UP NEXT

Can Democrats Be the Party of the Future Again?

UP NEXT

California’s Battle Over Taxing Multinational Corporations Heats Up Again

UP NEXT

Promises to Cut CA’s High Living Costs Clash With Progressive Policies

UP NEXT

If CA Wants to Lead on AI, It Can’t Let 3 Companies Hog the Infrastructure

Trump Temporarily Halts Leasing and Permitting for Wind Energy Projects

5 hours ago

Fresno Man Who Dealt Deadly Fentanyl Pill Gets 80-Month Prison Term

5 hours ago

What’s Next for EVs as Trump Moves to Revoke Biden-Era Incentives?

5 hours ago

US Throws out Policies Limiting Arrests of Migrants at Sensitive Locations like Schools, Churches

5 hours ago

Visalia Police Find Man Shot Near Shopping Center. Tips Sought.

6 hours ago

Convicted Jan. 6 Rioter Benjamin Martin Still Going to Prison

6 hours ago

Is Lawsuit on Planned Reedley Job Center a ‘Shakedown’?

7 hours ago

Much of the Damage from the LA Fires Could Have Been Averted

8 hours ago

CA Sued the Tar Out of Trump the First Time Around. How Did It Do?

8 hours ago

Israel’s Top General Resigns over Oct. 7 Failures, Adding to Pressure on Netanyahu

9 hours ago

Trump Administration Directs All Federal Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Staff Be Put on Leave

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump’s administration is directing that all federal diversity, equity and inclusion staff be put on pai...

2 hours ago

President Donald Trump signs an executive order as he attends an indoor Presidential Inauguration parade event at Capital One Arena, Monday, Jan. 20, 2025, in Washington. (AP/Evan Vucci)
2 hours ago

Trump Administration Directs All Federal Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Staff Be Put on Leave

Ichiro Suzuki in Yankee Pinstripes
5 hours ago

Baseball’s Newest Hall of Famers: Suzuki, Sabathia, Wagner

People walk past the 1900 Storm memorial sculpture on Seawall Blvd. during an icy winter storm on Tuesday, Jan. 21, 2025 in Galveston, Texas. (Brett Coomer/Houston Chronicle via AP)
5 hours ago

‘Once in a Lifetime’ Snow Hits Parts of the US South

The five turbines of Block Island Wind Farm operate, Dec. 7, 2023, off the coast of Block Island, R.I., during a tour organized by Orsted. (AP File)
5 hours ago

Trump Temporarily Halts Leasing and Permitting for Wind Energy Projects

Photo of Mexican Oxy, fentanyl laced blue pills
5 hours ago

Fresno Man Who Dealt Deadly Fentanyl Pill Gets 80-Month Prison Term

President Donald Trump talks about the Endurance all-electric pickup truck, made in Lordstown, Ohio, at the White House, Sept. 28, 2020, in Washington. (AP File)
5 hours ago

What’s Next for EVs as Trump Moves to Revoke Biden-Era Incentives?

A Border Patrol truck rides along the border wall in Sunland Park, N.M., Tuesday, Jan. 21, 2025. (AP/Andres Leighton)
5 hours ago

US Throws out Policies Limiting Arrests of Migrants at Sensitive Locations like Schools, Churches

Police are investigating after a man was found shot near a Visalia shopping center and transported to Kaweah Health.
6 hours ago

Visalia Police Find Man Shot Near Shopping Center. Tips Sought.

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend